Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The ultimate failure of the legislation

Socialist Organiser no. 486, 17 May 1991 · scan pp. 11–12 · about 474 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

In reality, in assessing the impact of the legislation there are insuperable problems in isolating its operation and specific effect from wider political and economic factors which also mould the behaviour of workers.

But, of course, in Mrs Thatcher's project the law was not intended to be isolated. What distinguished her approach from her predecessors was the integration of legal change in wider policies on industrial relations and economic strategy.

Taken as an important ingredient in a total strategy, the legislation has played an important role in producing what is, from a socialist viewpoint, a weaker trade union movement than existed in 1979 — not ignoring the problems that existed them. Taken as an important ancillary to economic and industrial developments, crucially the recession of the early 1980s, increased unemployment and changes in the industrial structure, it has influenced the creation of a trade unionism reduced in coverage - 4 million fewer members, in class awareness, in confidence, In horizons, political clout, In rank and file autonomy and in sion.

But if we return to where we started and measure success against the final objectives the legislation was intended to achieve - reduced wages, increased productivity, higher profitability, a regenerated economy - then the picture looks different.

The unions have not been weakened and remoulded enough. The values of the legislation have been denied ideological acceptance by a majority of workers. The coercive power of the law has changed behaviour, but changed it inadequately on too small a scale. The set piece sequestrations have proved of limited value in changing the day-to-day attitude and produce of the workers. As they used to say, you can't dig coal with bayonets!

Average earnings increased annually at between 7% and 8% between 1982 and 1990, signficantly out-shooting inflation which itself outstripped the rate of price increases in the UK's competitor countries. Decentralisation of wage bargaining made things worse, not better. The legislation had little imJohn Mellroy Unions in Bri theoming bọo pact on employment trends. Unemployment remained at levels unknown in the days before the Employment Acts.

The immunities were shredded as Hayek and Thatcher demanded. The impact on the economy was far from what they promised in consequence.

There is no evidence that as they predicted the legislation would influence a decline in the earnings of union members relative to nonorganised workers and increase productivity. The union mark-up over non-union labour has, at around 7%, hardly changed at all in the 1980s. -Thatcherism produced, from our viewpoint, weaker unions; from the viewpoint of many members work through the '80s with rising living standards the picture was different. But it has also produced a weaker economy. The dream is still just that.

John Mellroy is author of Trade Tradi Id a 1 theoming book on the anti-union laws. •unio

Scan page 12

Socialist Organiser No. 486 page 12

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 486

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →