Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The limits of the Tor

Socialist Organiser no. 486, 17 May 1991 · scan p. 10 · about 776 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

The Tory anti-union laws, as we saw last week, have proved themselves as a powerful weapon on the dustrial battlefield. But Certainly the balloting provisions have met with limited success, and in some cases have boomeranged. By 1990 only one of the 53 unions which had balloted their members on political funds had voted against such a tund. Indeed, 20 unions had been galvanised by the1984 Act into creating a fund for the first time, and more than 80% of trade unionists are now members of unions with political funds.

The impact of the legislation on the closed shop appears to have been relatively neutral. In 1986 ACAS estimated that only 30,000 out of more than 3 million workers then covered by closed shop arrangements had taken part in ballots required by the 1980 and 1982 Acts to protect 100% union membership. Of the 100 or so ballots reported by that date, more than 75% had resulted in the unions achieving the required 80% majority - quite an achievement for trade Since then, ballots have been axed - in itself an acceptance of Pai ge brat opi goon is that the and doubted decline in the closed shop has been the product of changes in the industrial structure and the decline of manufacturing industry where it was particularly strong. It is not down to the legislation.

Similarly, the best view would seem to be that legal changes have not had a great deal of adverse impact on union recognition: partly because the previous procedures were themselves inadequate and stymied by hostile legal judgements. ACAS reported in 1988 that "formal de-recognition continued to be rare" and that there was no major change in employers recognising unions in comparison with the 1970s. More on There have been changes in white-collar and managerial occupations, particularly in printing and publishing, and recent reports argue an increase in de-recognition in the last two years. However, it is difficult to credit the legal changes strike ballots from the inception of the legislation in 1984 until the end of 1989. In that period there were around 1,000 strikes annually, so ballots, although they were on the increase, were only held before around a third of all stoppages.

Where ballots were held, 90% of them resulted in a vote for industrial action and in a majority of these cases employers settled without a strike taking place.

The balloting requirements for the election of union leaders appear to have had little impact in terms of their avowed aim of replacing left with right-wing leaders. They have possibly led to an intensification of, or at least better organised, factionalism within the unions. In practice, the broad lefts have been able to come to terms with the ballots but they have, if anything, increased their pre-existing focus on elections and positions.

The balloting provisions generally have produced greater formalisaton and centralisation within the unions. They now have to have computerised membership lists, more carefully kept accounts and, because of the need to win ballots and escape legal liability, greater control over stewards and closer links with the membership.

We should not see that as completely negative. Any socialist rank necessarily the ideology behind them and file movement will have to attempt to seize control of the union to register the resilience of wage machine, fight to overcome sec- growth and the fact that, despite a tionalism, and encourage greater greater parochialism, workplace centralisation - albeit on a dif- organisation has remained ferent, more democratic, fighting remarkably intact, indeed has basis. spread to new areas. If in some secSo, if we look beyond the success tors it is more consultative and less of the legislation in the big set piece control conscious than in earlier confrontations of the 1980s, a more decades, a majority of employers complex picture begins to emerge. still involve stewards in changes in And Thatcher's achievement looks the workplaces. a little shakier. The dramatic battles over the law captured public atten- witnessed a significant decline in the tion, but by-passed the majority of number of strikes. However, the trade unionists. average number of working days In weighing the evidence "lost" per 1000 employees, at least for most of the decade, compared favourably with the position during the 1960s, whilst the reduction in stoppages was paralleled in other countries which did not introduce new employment legislation.

how we measure the impact, success or failure of the legislation. For example, there have been far less than 200 cases coming before the courts during the whole decade; more than

----- pull-quotes -----

more detail the picture more complex.

with this development. ACAS reported just under 1,200

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 486

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →