Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

["You cannot overthrow or-supersede ean Matgamna opened the…]

Socialist Organiser no. 486, 17 May 1991 · scan pp. 8–10 · about 2,206 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

"You cannot overthrow or-supersede ean Matgamna opened the socialism trem confusion and "new world order" the USSR, where the workers have after the collapse of Stalinism in great cause to hate "socialism', The Western bourgeoisie StI The workers will claiming triumph; and they have outgrow their confusion. On the good cause. Tand-SCOR supersede advanced capitalism by WAITIS developing a backward country in the future with confidence. competition with it. Marx knew A move by Dennis Church to give that. Lenin and Trotsky knew that. conference time to debate the view But the bureaucracy, led by Stalin, held by him and a few others, that which overthrew workers' power in the Stalinist states should still be t equated "socialism" with it rejected. The conference decided own goal, the development of that the debate should instead be backward Russia - and then other continued in writing. backward countries - by way of an Time was, however, given to this economic forced march organised argument on the conference *frby an all-powerful terrorist state. inge", with Saturday evening Stalinism was the "actually ex- "bureaucratic collectivist" isting" alternative to capitalism. capitalist", "deformed workers® The collapse of such "socialism" states, and "dead-end societies Nevertheless, nothing of solid debated in a way refreshingly free value to working-class socialism is from the factional point-scoring Much is gained -the freeing of ed this issue for so long. On the weekend of 4-5 May, 150 socialists met in London launch the "Alliance for They represented a section of the activists who support and sustain Socialist Organiser, and one of their major decision: was to promote this newspaper Below we print Cathy Nugent's introduction to the main debate, 'Building the Chris Reynolds summarises some of the other main debates of the weekend.

1847 Marx and Engels drafted the manifesto of the Communist Party. It was the first rounded statement of what we would call Marxian socialism or scientific socialism. It was a statement of what Communists stood for.

The Communist Manifesto is like that record you play when you get a bit down. You play it over and over again. The Communist Manifesto you read over and over again, and every time you find something new and something that sums up in a different way how the world is organised.

Generations of working class people have read The Communist Manifesto and found that it has literally changed their lives.

-Decades of working class struggle and the lessons of those struggles have enriched and further clarified what is in this little book. It is as relevant today as it was in 1847Maybe that is one way of summing with it."

скот ge bo SIMENE M alP Noose can cre not influenced by defined Marxist theory hat equation gained great sway in the world workers" movement.

was inevitable.

lost with the collapse of Stalinism. up how profound is — its longevity.

There are 3 ideas in The Communist Manifesto which I want to mention here. They are just as accessible and equal to summing up what we, Socialist Organiser, are about todayas they were 140 years ago.

irstly, capitalist society, with its ruling capitalist class, has, as Marx and Engels put_it, "created its own gravedigger"

That gravedigger is the working class, a class that lives only as long as it can find work, a class that is literally a slave to the wages system.

This slavery means if you can't find work and are unemployed you feel useless. And this wage system means that a struggle over wages or jobs can potentially develop towards a struggle that can challenge the whole system, provoking the naked repression of the bourgeois state with its police and its courts just as it did in the miners' strike.

this world of advanced but sick capitalism. It is the only class that has no interest in and just not does not have the power to exploit any other section of society.

A workers' socialist revolution is the only genuine democratic revolution - democratic because it will end all exploitation and achieve the liberation of all of humanity.

The second idea in The Communist Manifesto is that the dominant ideas in society are those of the ruling class.

The bosses have economic power. Essentially that is the basis of their rule, but class rule is more than this.

The bourgeoisie also have regiments of spokespeople: politiand do hate "socialism", the class Stalinism, the green shoots of new or life are already visible. The Alliance degenerated workers states, was "deformed and forum in which different analyses the Stalinist state state without any ruling class" were tharconims cians, thinkers, intellectuals who spend their lives and get paid for explaining, justifying, criticising within limits the way things are, the way things just are and, therefore, have got to be.

And they have their gofers, toadies like the populist scum who write for The Sun, who manage to reach out to and can find a hearing among working class people, downtrodden and ruled by conventions which say this is how it is and the way things have always been.

The working class does not have these kinds of ready made intellectuals who can speak up for its own interests. And working class politics spontaneously developed through struggle - syndicalism, labourism — has been shaped and marred by bourgeois ideas.

"In 1989-90 were massive Marxism was entered centre stage.

Vastly, The Communist Manifesto tells us what we have to be.

Communists are the "the most advanced and resolute sections of the working class parties, that section that pushes forward all others". We "have the advantage of clearly understanding the line of march, the conditions and the ultimate general results of the proletarian movement."

We are thoroughly involved in the working class movement but we have set ourselves the goal of being able to rise above the pressures of bourgeois existence and to fight for a vision of the future. We have to fight piecemeal, in small ways, but also to organise and implement the historical goal of working class struggle, the overthrow of the wage slave system, an insurrection to found a socialist and democratic society, In 1989/1990 there were massive upheavals in Eastern Europe. The tyranny that had been in place in the name of a barbarically corrupt Marxism was overthrown. The working class re-entered centre stage.

But it did not have an independent voice and never had the chance to organise, develop ideas collectively. And so the intellectuals of the liberal' opposition with their bourgeois ideals, such as Havel in Czechoslovakia, came to the forefront. There was no revolutionary socialist alternative able to steer the working class away from the bright lights and ephemeral possibilities of western capitalism.

Now the working class in Eastern Europe has to assimilate all the lessons of their own situation but of the past as well. It has to learn about a history that has been buried beneath a huge weight of lies and Stalinist propaganda.

It has to rediscover the ideas that May 1989. Chinese workers and stud lents have yet to win this fight were found from 1847 in The Communist Manifesto, and which were discussed and debated and implemented in the workers' revolution of 1917. That will be a painful, difficult process.

Socialists such as ourselves have a part to play. The best thing we can do is pass down our ideas of an alternative society and our traditions. We can try to develop a better understanding of how the world works. That job cannot be done by just a few people in our ranks but all of us to the best of our abilities. Our role of developing ideas is irreplaceable, essential. If we cannot pass the ideas on, we are finished.

But more than this, we have to reach out and also agitate with the paper, Socialist Organiser, and use it as a tool to make sense of the world to all working class people, youth, students, everyone who wants to understand more.

his self-renewal, as we have called the task of working towards these high ideas will not be achieved overnight.

Scan page 9

The struggle around the poll tax has been the major class battle of recent times "We must understand how our -We must bezinvpivedEn campangns routine activities are linked ike thosezagannst Peregraph 1b and "Poll tax-related cuts are biting: a trade union fight back is needed"

Theresist no 'ranks and file nethe Alliance, Evenyone must take We want to draw upon all our collective experience and all our tremendous youthful enthusiasm to achieve that, for we have set ourselves high standards.

Above all, we have to follow the advice of Marx and Engels: "Communists disdain to conceal their views and aims. They openly declare that their ends can be attained only by the forcible overthrow of all existing social conditions". We have to be just as open and forthright. We have to go out and win recruits. future of socialism"

laving set the basic political went on to discuss the practical details of activity.

Joe Macaulay, introducing this session, called on activists not only to read bvt also to use, Socialist Organiser - to sell it, discuss it, write for it.

The main job of the Alliance now, said Macaulay, is political education — educating its own activists, and reaching out to educate others. Everyone who has understood and accepted the basic idea of workers' liberty as the alternative to both capitalism and Stalinism can and should take that idea out to educate others, and educate themselves further in the responsibility" C proposals about baiding local aroline Harrison presented groups of the Alliance, Again, the focus was on education, on making every person a reliable activist in their own field who deals competently with the political issues and actively spreads socialist ideas rather than just being a "consumer".

Much of the debate was around a proposal for a sales drive with process. The Alliance's activists should also be the best activists in the Labour Party and trade unions, said Macaulay. They should fight every inch of the way against the Labour leadership's attempts to purge socialists from the Party.

Amendments to Macaulay's proposals took the discussion over a wide range of issues — campaigning against Health Service cuts, learning from the experience of Australia's disastrous Labor government, noting the trend for the capitalist world to polarise into "trade blocs" , making links with socialists in other countries, developing activity in Labour Party women's sections and the wider women's movement.

Socialist Organiser. The principle was agreed unanimously, but some people argued that to call for SO sellers immediately to commit themselves to extra sales was too summary, and the details should be remitted to the committee elected by the conference to run the AWL week-to-week. The proposal to remit was defeated by a margin of one-to-three, and the substantive carried unanimously. Clamse_25° peaking in the debate on lesbian and gay liberation liberation, Janine Booth argued: "Liberation requires the abolition of class society - the achievement of socialism"

Other speakers said that the movements against bigoted Tory hris Corbett introduced on work in the trade unions, Cate Richards on the Labour Party, and Jill Mountford on students.

The conference agreed to work to link campaigns against the poll tax with battles against local government cuts. Several speakers criticised Socialist Organiser for inadequate coverage of poll tax campaigning, and SO editor John O'Mahony accepted the criticism.

"The struggle to transform the existing labour movement cannot be done by dipping in and out of the labour movement"

A Central Line guard spoke about the current dispute on the London Underground, and a Sheffield railworker about the strike ballot in British Rail. He stressed measures — Clause 28, Paragraph 16, Clause 25 — had mobilised tens of thousands of lesbians and gay men who previously took no interest in politics, and forced them to think about the society they live in and how it should be changed. Socialists should be active in the movement, arguing our ideas.

the value and viability of workplace bulletins, presenting socialist ideas every fortnight in close connection with workplace issues.

Arguing for an effort to build groups like *Labour Party. Socialists" and fight purges in the Labour Party, Cate Richards stressed: "A revolutionary alternative will be built through the struggle to transform the existing labour movement, which cannot be done by dipping in and out of that labour movement."

However, "student work is the best opportunity we have to recruit young people," said Jill Mountford. Jill urged student activists at the conference to re-double their efforts to tie the struggle for socialist politics to united campaigning. Jill added: "We must strengthen work in initiatives such as Left Unity."

The student debate evoked some controversy about possibilities for organising the left in the National Organisation of Labour Students, and that discussion will continue.

Scan page 10

Assessing the anti-union laws Organiser IN PERSPECTIVE

----- pull-quotes -----

advanced capitalism by demerophug a acknand country-in competition

The working class is the basic ex- ploited class, the majority now in

upheavals in Eastern Europe. The tyranny that had been in place in the name of a barbarically corrupt

overthrown. The working class re-

Liberty" lamicked s is irreplaceable"

tax-related union fight

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 486

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →