Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The politics behind the Mandela scandal

Socialist Organiser no. 486, 17 May 1991 · scan p. 7 · about 930 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

*ash giton mots Robin Templeton reports munity resisted. There was Otrer anteine and one cly Dus were set he ICpmlin б.зіма were arrested and over 40 response by Latinos, African- used greater force to confront Amberincah., and white the rioters. HusanÇapelice members of the community. OWee IOnevecomoskoyymu THer ONOM MECE TERST Bois:: sun the e Myeint perkenceds wen eifemen i Pleasant area: police set up Toe so w Luart noa) SHANN =AITAnbarricadee, wehhcitT •CAM- Amoricansn n tm su beisshon. By Bob Fine and Tom Sound guily. She has been o Winnie Mandela has been sentenced to six years for the kidnapping, and being an accessory "after the fact" to the assault of murdered young black activist Stompie Mokhetsi.

But Mrs Mandela will not be going to prison yet, anyway; she has been given bail and leave to appeal, a process that could take a year at least.

Many long-standing opponents of apartheid will be rightly disgusted by the hypocrisy of the South African state. The response of many on the left will be that this vile racist regime, guilty of so many crimes, has no right to stand in judgement on Winnie Mandela.

But there is more to say. The «Winnie Mandela affair" has raised important issues, not least the future and past of the ANC itself.

The Mandela trial fits President De Klerk's purposes very well -though suggestions of a conspiracy are too crude.

De Klerk's basic strategy is to introduced controlled reform from above, culminating in one-personone-vote, at some time in the nottoo-distant future.

For this strategy to be successful it is essential to weaken, divide, disorganise and discredit the ANC. The Mandela trial has provided the perfect opportunity to do this.

Resentment in the townships against Mrs Mandela is not the creation of "the system" • Her reputation amongst the black working class is very bad indeed. It was not helped by the large and expensive mansion "fit for a president" she built in Soweto, or by her attempt to profit from the copyright Winnie remains defiant as Nelson contemplates the future on the Mandela name or by her arrogant pronouncements such as her infamous "necklace" speech in which she informed the world that the people would rise up when she "gave the word".

Nevertheless, it would be a mistake indeed for the left to allow Mrs Mandela to be turned into a scapegoat for what. went wrong with the ANC's pseudoinsurrectionary struggle for "people's power" in 1984-5, We are not dealing with the "excesses" of Mrs Mandela, but with some of the more grotesque consequences of a flawed political strategy.

A strategy seeds of the present bloody carnage that is ripping the townships apart.

In the mid-1980s the ANC raised such slogans as *make the townships ungovernable" , and "no education before liberation" • The aim was to create such chaos and mayhem as would force the government to negotiate with the ANC.

But who were the victims of the chaos? As the left wing academic journal Work in Progress put it at the time: "Undisciplined comrades, often acting with no organisational basis or mandate, have divided the communities, setting workers against the unemployed, children against parents, trade unions against community groups.

"Some of the tent boycotts have been enforced with a high degree of anti-democratic authoritarianism. The youth have often acted without the organisational structure necessary for democratic decision-making, and without adequate mandate or consultation. Recourse to 'discipline' — 'necklacings' beatings and other punishments — has come too easily to a group which often lacks a mandate to act on behalf of a constituency.

Stompei was not the only victim and he was an especially charismatic activist.

Mrs Mandela was a vocal champion of the "necklace" and of the rather injudicious use of "people's justice". She delivered political statements without any mandate and "called upon the people" to follow certain lines of struggle with little concern for the norms of democratic decision-making. Her elitism certainly alienated many trade unionists accustomed to the ideas of accountability and participation.

When she spoke at a number of trade union congresses advocating adoption of the Freedom Charter (the ANC's basic programme) and at the miners' conference advocating a united front between the mine owners and the mineworkers against the state, many workers were resentful at having her views imposed upon them.

But this resentment should not simply be turned on Mrs Mandela. Rather it should lead to some serious rethinking in the broad liberation movement.

Coming to terms with Winnie Mandela will involve the ANC coming to terms with its own past. The organisation is now paying the price for the rather narrow political base it built for itself in the townships.

The "workerist" trade union left, who in the mid-'80s focused on building democratic, accountable structures in the workplaces and communities, and criticised the ANC's reliance on "the comrades" have had at least part of their analysis negatively confirmed. The tragedy is that the trade union left abandoned the terrain of politics to the ANC and their pseudo-insurrectionary sloganising.

For us here in the solidarity movement the fall of Mrs Mandela should be a timely reminder where uncritical admiration of leaders may lead, particularly when those leaders are unelected.

Perhaps one day people will name roads, parks and meeting rooms after Stompei Mokhetsi.

SUAKI controntanon with pw ice.

At least seven police cars Tuesday 12am to Thursday the general SCLUne ue moce En SAINI 11 Mig

----- pull-quotes -----

hot e uretbo ini eni es hat ie protestbanamn The- police- -sheo kre ae and business community feel

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 486

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →