Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Taxing times and smear

Socialist Organiser no. 486, 17 May 1991 · scan p. 6 · about 816 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

The Fraud Squad tries to smear the Labour Party by linking Kinnock with rag •PENING 1991 MAIN CONTRACTORS: LISA PRESIS-GANG ast Tuesday, readers of the Daily Express were presented with a terrifying prospect: *Nightmare on Downing St - the scary scenario that could haunt Britain. The first 100 days in power of Neil Kinnock and Co."

The horrors conjured up by the Express included the mass exodus of pop stars, the age of consent for homosexuals lowered to 16, soaring unemployment (thanks to the minimum wage), wildcat strikes and secondary picketing (union laws repealed), demonstrations by angry parents (because "opting out" has been abolished) and the police under the control of sinister "committees of councillors""

The Express's concluding question to its readers - "Is this a vision of Britain we want for the Nineties?" seemed a little superfluous after all that.

The cause of all this excitement was a comment from Shadow Chancellor John Smith (on TVAM) to the effect that, under Labour, the requirement to pay National Insurance contributions would be extended to earnings above £20,300. The Daily Mail, whose reaction was almost as hysterical, at least quoted what Smith had said: "I don't understand why you pay on 100 per cent of your income up to £20,300 but you don't pay on it beyond that."

I must confess that I'd never realised that you didn't pay NI contributions on earnings above that figure.

Monday's Express had broken the story under the headline "Labour WILL cost more" and Political Correspondent Charles Lewington informed us that *three million people will be trade boss Charilaos Costa nt by punishing rises in National Insurance under Labour, Shadow Chancellor John Smith revealed yesterday. After months of ducking and diving, Neil Kinnock's weighty right hand man confirmed that 12 per cent of earners will fall into a trap aimed at raising t2.5 billion for lavish spending programmes."

On Tuesday the front page headline was "Labour's Brain Drain Threat" above a story entirely built around a quote from Treasury Chief Secretary David Mellor, predicting "Britain's economic life-blood of selfstarters, entrepreneurs and top professionals would move abroad as they did in the seventies under the last Socialist government" On an inside page, such irreplaceable assets to the nation's well-being as Mick Jagger, Bill Wyman and Michael Winner confirmed that they planned to flee these shores in the event of a Kinnock victory.

The next day's Daily Mail front page revealed further evidence of the full extent of the Kinnock reign of terror: "No tax cuts for five years" In a "shock speech" the Labour leader naa, apparently, made the *stunning declaration that no-one should expect tax cuts for five years if Labour was in The Mail described this as "one of the most astonishing promises of modern times"

But what have we here? Thursday's Mail quoted Norman Lamont repeating the "government aim of cutting the basic rate (of income tax) to 20p in the pound... However, in line with the government commitment to cut taxes only when it is prudent to do so, he signalled that it could take more than one parliament to reach that goal." More - than one parliament? A few years perhaps? Five years, even?

As the admirable Anthony Bevins noted in Friday's Independent, this represents "just as much of a dilution of commitment as Labour's revised statement that it would now only move 'towards' a minus 20p starting rate of income tax for those struggling to escape poverty' , over the lifetime of a parliament. For both parties, the pledge has been reduced to a hope."

And as for all that shockhorror stuff about the National Insurance ceiling, Bevins pointed out that "Labour's plan has been around since May 1989."

John Major may still be weighing his options for the timing of the next election, but as far as the Tory press concerned, the campaign well and truly underway.

ast week the Sun ran a series of front page astories linking Neil Kinnock with one Charilaos Costa, a rag-trade boss whom the police want to question over an alleged "missing" E10 million. Even the Sun admitted (in the small print) that Kinnock's "links" with Costa did not involve any business or financial connec tions. But it was clearly a damaging smear.

Then came the claim from the Sun's political editor Trevor Kavanagh, no less - that the source of the story was the Fraud Squad. Kinnock's office contacted the Metropolitan Police Commissioner, Peter Imbert, who suggested a meeting and an official complaint. Now, on Kinnock's personal instructions, the meeting has been called off and no complaint will be issued. It seems that the Labour leader doesn't want to embarrass the police.

of the World, on the basis of information and a photograph which could only have come trom a source within the police.

----- pull-quotes -----

NB. Clare Short MP was recently smeared in the News

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 486

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →