Bangladesh and capitalism
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-05-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
Such of the coverage of the horrific disaster in Bangladesh, even from the serious media, has been simply obscene.
ITN reports that Britain is giving more aid than any other European country and complains that we cannot go on carrying this burden for much longer. The Times, Independent on Sunday and countless tabloids, when they find time to even consider the tragedy, pour out vicious little diatribes about the inefficiency of the distribution network in Bangladesh, the bureaucracy of the government, the corruption whch prevents aid reaching the right quarters, the venality of politicians.
There is some truth in all that.
"The emancipation of the working class-is also the ensemeation of all haran beings without istinction ol sex on Karl Unge is a PO Box B23, London SE15 4NA HE CASER ENC we 9*796.
Machine for-space pr--apaeico0 aces Editor: John UTMatony Pubtished by WL Publications Li Pd Bex 823, London Shive Printed by Tridant Press Schadridg Registered as a newspaper at the Most UMna bles_do not necesarily calect the views of Socialist Organiser and are in are capacity bescotherwa stated But what are the prove?
The main port in Bangladesh, Chittagong, was destroyed in the cyclone: the links between the country's interior and the coast were eroded; and the entire communications system broke down. To complain of an inefficient distribution network in such circumstances is a sick joke, especially from a country whose transport system was recently paralysed by some mild snow.
Some of the most patronising and hypocritical journalism has been that which arrogantly portrays all Bengali officials, politicians and even ordinary people as inherently corrupt, incompetent and selfish.
Political squabbling, it seems, is the real problem. It is this, "more than cyclones, floods and tamine which is likely to kill oft democracy and finish Bangladesh as a country. The national good is not an important lactor in Bangladesh; self-interest tends to take control." The same writer, in the Independent on Sunday, tells us of a Mr Kamal Hussain, who is unusual among Bangladeshi politicians" . Why? *He makes a proposal not to draw political blood but because he believes it is in the best interests of the country". In our book that makes him unusual amongst politicians of any country.
Self-interest and pointless ly unique to Bangladesh, and anyway, for all this moderate, sensible rhetoric, British liberal journalists would be the first to howl if Bengali parties did unite, bury their differences and create a one-party state. Then the cause of incompetence would be totalitarianism.
So what's the problem - they haven't got a full democracy, or they have too many parties and debates? It can't be both!
Then there is the claim that *it is in the nature of Bangladeshis to expect aid as a right". The Thatcherite idea that the poor and unemployed in Britain are spongers and that we have a dependency culture is transferred to a world stage and the poor become the biggest cause of their own misery.
The truth is, however, that capitalist governments understand the importance of international subsidy and aid when it serves their own interests.
US aid to the Contras in Nicaragua knew no bounds, aid to Pakistan, a richer country than head, and perhaps most disgusting the biggest part of US aid money goes to Israel and is spent mainly on arms. Only when it is called upon to relieve misery do commentators find aid dependency dangerous.
Il this fog is created to avoid will, honesty, competence or experience by individuals can overcome the real problem - abject povertyInstead of looking for solutions to the poverty, the media give us, at worst, repeated attempts to blame the people of Bangladesh (or Sudan, or Ethiopia) and at best attempts to convince the good people of the civilised and efficient West that, despite the obvious failings of these feckless people, we should demonstrate our superiority and compassion again through large personal donations.
There is corruption in Bangladesh, and there is a less efficient and more easily corrupted civil service than in Britain, or rather our corruption is regularised and institutionalised for senior civil servants, through patronage, nepotism and honours.
Our civil service exists in conditions of general plenty, job security, pensions and "reasonable" wages. In Bangladesh there is chronic poverty, no job security, and great scarcity. The ability to obtain the most basic of resources is a life and death power to many people. Lowlevel corruption thrives in such conditions. The poverty produces the corruption and inefficiency, not vice versa.
Bangladesh exists on the margins of the world economy. Once part of the Raj, stripped and plundered by Britain, it was left with no developed infrastructure because its potential profits were considered unworthy of such investment. Then the basis for the religious partition of Bengal (into Muslim East Bengal, now Bangladesh, and Hindu West Bengal, now part of India), was laid down by the, presumably efficient and uncorrupt, Tory leader Curzon. or this because events like e receive no analvsis and. in of this because events like those in Bangladesh represent the most fundamental challenge to the current capitalist triumphalism. The market is supposed to have solved all the major economic problems of history. The idea of any alternative economic system has been discredited.
Bangladesh. and the reaction to it, brings home to a fresh audience the urgency of such an alternative. It also confirms a central aspect of capitalism which Marx pointed to 150 years ago — just as capitalism increases its absolute wealth and riches, the relative misery and poverty of the mass of people becomes greater and sharper.
When you think you have killed off socialism, it becomes vital to rubbish the idea that events like Bangladesh indict capitalism in any way. That is what produces the obscene commentaries of recent weeks.
Edittomal Board Grehem Besh Malli din Dener erny-tegeton Jatin derien (Ufon miy BilmakSections)
Eric teflersMP Dorath y Macendo LoBI Maninio Jbhn Metroy Johnak|ichbson Peter-eNiK Members of the Advisory Committee are ПрИМІТ e hoRdEroesa y rotaren orgse to the abewr arY'sı witch-hunt againsrl Socrt broaniser VIews expressso in BricIes Br the responsibility of the authors and not of the Advisory Editorial Board.
Scan page 4
BEHIND THE NEV Socialist Organiser No. 486 page 4
----- pull-quotes -----
A the central issue. No party system, no amount of good-