Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The essence of proletarian military policy

Socialist Organiser no. 485, 10 May 1991 · scan pp. 14–15 · about 1,418 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

Henry Newman's letter little orno knowledge of jazz atsen beard am com and its history, Jim cleverly aF's cali for same mer builds up an appetite for it. comene ot Lis contemHe belleves in getting to the porary British jazz scene, but 9 HWAr-- within tikc *Jim bones of people. He does not Chis -stavad: C-TEORMe IT: 10% Denham Appreciation patronise.

Sia wet iny-. ine I's Ci PNE S*ONN XIE--S younger weters with lots Підні ва Jim, it seems, is not too far e of can benie from the top of the Queen's Swiaie Coerwge-s-mest AUDI pAet -i Ns paso LOHM HIMA mited Vws/@CAMens 4 MN14.0.... from the unfair criticisms respect for his "childhood steppen -Inte Jim's The makes his reader feel the roa-onbedaa to join "bip" comunida. SHIKSEN Sig: los sadr-he-sies use lump labour and the threat of the blacklist to impose their domination over the lives of building workers.

Building DLO managers and workers come from this same background, SO don't be surprised when workers hesitate to go on all-out strike, which was based on a 9 vote majority by only one of the trades unions concerned.

Yet you seem to think that a two-day strike was a retreat. We also would have preferred, and did originally recommend, a longer strike. However, our members make their own decisions.

Despite your talk of a serious set back, and defeat and retreat, we would maintain that a fight was led by the shop stewards' committee, which, despite the deliberate manipulations and delors bicists ee ofed int (1) The reinstatement of 24 sacked apprentices.

(2) The return of El million of our work which was previously sub let to contractors.

(3) Talks with employer over our claim of their preferential treatment of contractors.

Those 70, not 320, of our members who were sacked will be continued to be supported by the stewards committee. Indeed, protest actions will be continued, as has happened since the end of the strike.

Our criticism of your articles is not sectarian. We recognise the valid work done by many Socialist Organiser supporters in the struggle against -the employers. Our criticism is that articles by labour movement organisations must be (1) factual and objective; (2) recognise all aspects of the struggle and not just see defeats and victories; (3)

Having read Comrade - Cleary's review of the latest Stalinist work about the war in the 14 March issue of Socialist Organiser, I must voice a strong criticism of his interpretation of the Proletarian Military Policy and of its application in Britain, which he justifies and claims was the policy of the WIL and the RCP.

Here we have a case of a cuckoo dropping its egg into the nest of another species of bird. He claims that their policy "was as near to 'revolutionary defen-mat 12z-2 ABBI altaat hinl ow *ReS"

Fermhpme 01 -15cism' as you could get short of announcing it." It is interesting in this context that he "revolutionary defencism, Puts quotation marks — why, I don't know.

Either the policy was revolutionary defencism de facto, (whatever that might mean in a major capitalist country participating in an imperialist war) or it was not.

One gets the impression from his argument that the proletarian military policy arose with the occupation of France and the conflicts within the British capitalist class. However, the contrary is true. The basic argument for the Proletarian Military Policy was presented in the Transitional Programme. It was a universal policy and a universal tactic (aphonestly, riage -mab Ma bees (S—Omm-se plying to the United States as well as Britain) and was the source of contention throughout the Trotskyist movement.

The programme declares: "a correct policy is composed of two elements: an uncompromising attitude on imperialism and its wars and the ability to base one's programme on the experience of the masses themselves".

The rest of the section goes on to deal with it. On the question of defencism it makes this statement: "If we first bind our own (capitalists) hand and foot....; if the workers and farmers of our country become its real masters; if the wealth of the country be transferred from the hands of a tiny minority to the hands of the people; if the army becomes a Maybe Henry Naes 1 Han COnsid ar wis#n BmWC--N 173 Jennen ons hvad weapon of the exploited instead of the exploiters" , then would be defencists - ie the defence of the workers' state after the overthrow of the capitalist class.

It carries on with the following statement: "It is necessary to interpret these fundamental ideas by breaking them up into more concrete and partial ones, dependent upon the course of events and the orientation of thought of the masses" . Herein lies the core of the tactic of the Proletarian Military Policy, a policy directly related to the working class with the aim of raising the level of political consciousness of the working class to the level of the struggle for power.

Precisely because we are Marxists and not Blanquists, and precisely because we believe along with Marx that the emancipation of the working class is the class conscious action of the working class itself, this concept determines our tactics and action.

Unlike the sectarians, who give an ultimatum to the working class, or the reformists, to whom the movement is everything and therefore principles and policy do not count, we recognise the interplay of both.

This was the essence of the principled political position of the Proletarian Military Policy combined with the development of the political action and consciousness of the working class: not ultimatism, but explanation and participation with the oppressed in its political development towards the struggle for Sam Levy, London E7 Saturday Socialist Mc Leeds Saturday "Socialists Election", I meeting. 8. Houghton Street, Aldwych Thursday 23 May "The Struggle for Socialism" Sheffield SO meeting. 7.30, SCAU, West Street "The General Election", Nottingham SO debate between a member of the Green Party and Jim Denham. 8.00, Internation Community Centre, Mansf Road 1 June rement AGM, 3 June and the Genera lanchester SO I0, Town Hall Saturday 8 & Sunday June "Resourcing the Future" conference organised by the Red Green Network. Kingsw Princeton College, Sidmouth Street.

Saturday 6 & Sunday 7 July Middle East Peace Conference, organised by Socialist Campaign Group MPs, London

Scan page 15

ube: no jobs for sale. The Chernoby!

numbers game and the smaller TSA book- necessarily be a sell-out, it sell-out, it appalling incompetence and Central Line guard s Socialist Organiser:

goes to press, the state of play in the Tube dispute remains unclear.

At management's request talks have been going on with the RMT union since last week at the government conciliation service ACAS. This followed a 2:1 ballot vote to strike against cuts, by RMT and the smaller TSSA ing clerks' union.

The cuts were drawn up by management to deal with the €100 million plus budget deficit caused by their financial incompetence. The length of the talks and the way management initiated them suggest there is some willingness on management's part to compromise.

At the moment RMT is considering a deal details of which remain secret. While a deal would necessarily be a sell-out, it would be criminal to use the 2:1 vote for strike action as a bargaining tactic to cobble together a plan which makes minor concessions while retaining the essentials of the cuts programme.

No-one has the right to sell jobs und safety. There is public support for Tube workers taking action in defence of jobs, services and safety.

RMT should go on the offensive against management's members of the train driver's union ASLEF, who must be won to not crossing RMT picket lines.

• STOP PRESS: A deal has been worked out at ACAS which includes significant concessions by the bosses on promotion and transfer arrangements, working parties, and the machinery of negotiation. But 800 jobs are still to go. The deal must be put to a ballot. Full analysis next week Les Hearn's Socialist Organiser No. 485 page 15 negligent authority is not helped by exaggerating their crime (which is large enough anyway). What is needed is an independent investigation into the number and causes of deaths in the region, into the causes of the disaster, into ways of reducing the future damage and into making sure such a thing does not happen again.

he prestigious medical.

publication, The New England Journal of

----- pull-quotes -----

appalling incompetence and for unity in action with

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 485

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →