America's rank-and-file organisers
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-05-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
Book Barry Finger re and File Rebi La Botz (Verso, 1990)
ccording to bourgeois Apundits movement, as labour movement is slipping into terminal decline.
Twenty years ago most major newspapers and news magazines had regular bylines by writers whose beat was the labour movement. This is no longer the case.
The politics and controversies of the labour movement clearly no longer engage the imaginations of the middle class public. Because the labour movement poses no challenge to the industrial tyranny of the bosses by means of its own forms of workplace democracy, it has lost both its attractive and repulsive force in society.
In other words, American society lost interest in the labour movement as soon as it was able to assimilate the movement itself into the American ethos. La Botz argues riews Ra ellion, by that the decline of American labour occurred when the labour bosses accepted "absolutely the right of the employers to run their companies, of businessmen in general to dominate the economy, of the corporate elite to control politics.
This book chronicles the efforts of rank and file militants to reclaim the International Brotherhood of Teamsters, the giant truck drivers' union, which is in a particularly advanced stage of degeneration. Dissidents in this union are likely to lose their jobs, their union pensions and the temporary use of their limbs.
How did the IBT find itself in such straits? In fact, it was the industrial union approach pioneered by the Minneapolis Teamster movement in the 1930s - and led by the Trotskyists, most prominent among whom was Farrell Dobbs - that put the Teamsters on the map.
What rapidly developed thereafter was a power struggle between Dobbs's "brand of radical, democratic unionism from-thebottom-up, and Dave Beck's conservative, authoritarian unionism from-the-top-down'"
But when World War Il broke out, the Teamster heads - then Democrats and ardent Roosevelt supporters — were able to convince the Washington administration that jailing their mutual opponents would be a boon to the war effort. The subsequent arrest and incarceration of the 29 SWP and Teamsters union leaders under the Smith Act" destroyed the left wing of the union.
From then on the Teamsters were mired interminably in personal corruption from the top down. Teamster boss Dave Beck was sent to jail in 1957 for tax evasion on assets and businesses amassed from. teamster funds.
Jimmy Hoffa, his successor, brought the Mafia into the union at the national level. Jackie Presser, who assumed a leadership position in the labour movement as a result of nepotism, only entered this line of "business" after his Teamster pension-funded restaurant went bankrupt.
During the relatively prosperous *50s and '60s, this corruption was shrugged off by the rank and file.
One freight hauler La Botz quotes summed it up this way: "Ah, so what if he [Hoffa] stole five bucks from me, he got me fifteen, so am I going to complain?"
Only when union heads began to refine concessionary bargaining into a high art form did the atmosphere become more hospitable for union reformers. By 1976, when the Teamsters for a Democratic Union was formed, the national union had given way on numerous fronts.
The industry had been permitted to set up non-union subsidiaries (a practice known as "doublebreasting"; allowed non-union casual hires to replace full-time union workers and made no efforts to organise the casuals; and been acceded to in a two-tiered wage structure, which segments workers and plants the seeds of disunity.
Out of this atmosphere the TDU grew from 200 to 10,000 within its fifteen year existence. This may seem modest in a union of 1.6 million. But TDU has had some spectacular victories.
It has campaigned successfully against the two-thirds rule. This had allowed the union bosses to impose contracts on memberships that had rejected such proposals by a majority of less than two-thirds.
It has won a number of impressive victories in the area of safety, protected the Teamster pension fund, and intervened to win numerous victories guaranteeing the members' rights to fair elections.
Moreover, the TDU influenced the shape of a federal governmentIBT consent decree settling a racketeering suit that charged the union leadership with being dominated by the Mafia. The TDU, without endorsing the principle of government intervention or agreeing to abide by all its conditions, steer(ed) the settlement away from government trusteeship and toward the right to vote"
As a result, the union agreed to a. government-supervised election with - for the first time - a direct, secret ballot of the rank and file.
But the TDU's most impressive achievement, as La Botz correctly states, is "its ability to attract the most idealistic rank and file reformers and organise them into a reform organisation. Rank and file opposition to employers, and to union officials who are allied to employers, is (now) constantly appearing in local unions and in particular companies"
The TDU has both inspired and encouraged the arduous task of returning the union to its membership and of remaking the union into a combative, democratic force for progressive social change.
The TDU will get an opportunity to test its vision this coming December. It has endorsed Ron Carey, a New York local president, for general Teamster president in the upcoming elections. A victory here could go a long way in redirecting the American labour movement.
Scan page 14
Socialist Organiser No. 485 page 14