Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

How does the SWP do it?

Socialist Organiser no. 484, 25 April 1991 · scan p. 14 · Chris Reynolds · about 756 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

Hussein. The Kurds are paying for this policy their lives.

Iraq invaded Kuwait to expand its power in the region, increase its revenue and divert internal opposition. The US went in to dent an over-ambitious regional sub-imperialist power and to protect its oil supplies. The war was reactionary on both sides.

If the war was about Iragi national rights then why did thousands and thousands of Iraqi conscripts refuse to fight and surrender? The Iraqi conscripts saw the war for what it was. They did not want to die for Saddam Hussein.

The tragedy is that the soldiers in the coalition armies did not do likewise. The tragedy is also that military defeat and collapse did not lead to a revolution in Iraq and justice for the Kurds.

Tony Dorman Manchester pression of gay self-confidence and strength? If it is, then it would be wrong for us to make a political objection to its use. now with ow do they do it? - During the Gulf war I Socialist Worker changed its line from hostile both to US intervention and to Saddam Hussein, to support for Saddam because he was 'playing an anti-imperialist role", and then to simple pacifism.

And each time it made the change without any visible process of discussion or dissent among the SWP members who sell and sus tain SW.

The same magic is worked even on political issues directly connected to immediate activity. On the poll tax SW shifted from arguing that only trade union boycotts could be effective, and community campaigning was a waste of time, to arguing that community campaigns could win after all. Again, there was no visible process of raising objections to the old line, debating, and finding new answers.

How do they do it? A clue can be got by close reading of a recent SWP circular, "Time to dig roots".

The circular explains: Forums where someone gives a talk on basic socialist politics and practical announcements are made. Detailed, serious and critical examination of SW's politics is not on the agenda:

I don't know whether the old branch committees discussed any political issues seriously. I doubt it. The entire culture of the SWP would weigh heavily against it. But at least the possibility was there. Now it is gone.

Between its branches andl its small Central Committee, the SWP - as far as I know - has very sketchy struetures. The result must be that virtually all political debate is confined within the Central Committee.

The Central Committee relates to the SWP members as a "monolithic" unit -information about differences within the CC seems to exist only in the form of rumours - so the members are atomised individual consumers of "the line" which comes down from the Central Committee.

The SWP does have a yearly conference. But - a the pre-conference bulletin for their November 1990 conference put it - "the practice of sending resolutions to conference has virtually ceased". The conference, as far as I can see, i: only a forum for a couple o hundred leading activists to comment on and amend the Central Committee's pro-m posals.

This ultra-centralised operation has developed bit by bit over 20 years.

Rational debate between SWP members and political currents outside the SWP has also atrophied - thank: to many years of sectarian tactics - and the internal and external processes reinforce each other.

Debate always carries

costs. But the SWP's costcutting exercise, like so many others, is short-sighted. It produces irrational, unstable politics, aric an organisation unable to argue those politics. Isaac Deutscher's description of the Stalinist parties in their ultra-left period in the early *30s becomes more and more relevant.

*When the European communist went out to argue his case before a working-class audience, he usually met there a Social-Democratic opponent whose arguments he had to refute and whose slogans he had to counter. Most-frequently he was unable to do this, because he lacked the habits of political debate, which were not cultivated within the party, and because his schooling deprived him of the ability to preach to the unconverted.

*He could not probe ade quately into his opponent's case when he had to think all the time about his own orthodoxy and to check perpetually whether in what he himself was saying he was not unwittingly deviating from the party line. He could expound with mechanical fanaticism a prescribed set of arguments and siogans; but unforeseen opposition or heckling at once put him out of countenance."

----- pull-quotes -----

EMEON THESIEFIT

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 484

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →