Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Sometimes you cannot take offence

Socialist Organiser no. 484, 25 April 1991 · scan pp. 14–15 · about 842 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

(SO 482) I did think he was being a little short-sighted in his objections to the use of the word "queer".

I would question outright condemnation. This is because there are examples of "appropriation" of words and language that are used to express hatred and fear - by the oppressed - which can be progressive.

Mark's condemnation was two fold. First, that using "queer" as a strategy was ineffective: confusing to potential allies and potentially divisive. It could undermine the building of a movement against the current at*Trade Unions and Energy", conference organised by SERA. 10.30-5.30, Conway Hall, Red Square Northampton Anti-Poll Tax Federation social. 8 till late, Racehorse Inn, E3 Monday 29 April "Lessons of Iranian Revolution" Manchester SO meeting, 8.00, Bridge St Tavern "Lessons from Australia - La in Power", Islington SO meeti 7.30, Red Rose Club. Speaker Janet Burstall wardly offensive. Personally, he may find it so, but I do not think we can draw political conclusions about that. Mark implies we can.

Words and language are inseparable from social relations and as these change so language comes to have different meanings.

Take a trivial example of sexist language the word "crumpel". It is trivial, ridiculous. But at the same time it has been part of a category of sexist language which suggests the consumption of women or parts of women (eg. cherry. honey, sugar, etc, etc).

"Crumpet" is now often "Trade unions and the law, Southwark SO meeting. 7.30, Eagles, Elephant and Castle. Speaker Tom Rigby Tuesday 30 April Lambeth Against the Witchh public meeting. 7.30, Lambet Town Hall. Speakers include Dennis Skinner and Jeremy Corbyn Meeting to organise a counter-demonstration to the 'Victory Parade. 7.30, Conway Hall. Lion Square Wednesday 1 May "Socialists and Sexuality", London SO meeting. 7.30, Oxford House, Derbyshire St. Speaker Janine Booth Anti-cuts demonstration, Lambeth. Assemble 10.30, Brixton Oval. 12.00 Rally at Kennington Park. Thursday 2 "Their new wo London SO mee Lambeth Town Wednesday "Crisis in the US Forum. 7.30, LSI Holborn Thursday 9 May "Myths of Irish history" Liverpool SO meeting. 7 Hardman St TU centre Saturday 11 May "Secularism and Nationalisn seminar organised by Wome Against Fundamentalism. 11.00-5.00, Wesley House, Court increased sexual choices and autonomy.

Of course, for every single example of appropriation" there are hundreds that can only be vile and offensive in intention -whatever their context. The progress of sexual freedom and equality between the sexes is limited.

1 could, for instance, decide 1 wanted to call all women *bitches" as an expression of "sisterhood". Clearly, I would be regarded as a bit off the wall at best and probably downright offensive. You can't referm language at will.

But is it not the case use of the word "queer"

May ild order" ting. 7.30 Hall!

8 May SR", SO L :, Houghto We might object to its use in a slogan, in a particular way, tactically it may be wrong. We would certainly object 1o a political strategy that made the use of such words compulsory.

Words have no meanings other than those defined by a cultural context. It is possible for the language of "oppressors" to be at the same time self-confident, affirmative language of the oppressed. We can feel self-conscious about these uses but we shouldn't make political judgements about it. Sometimes you cannot take offence.

Cathy Nugent Southwark Saturday 1 June Socialist Movement AGM, Saturday June "Resourcing the Future" confere organised by the Red Green Network. Kingsway Princeton College, Sidmouth Street, Middle East Peace Conference organised by the Socialist Campaign Group of MPs, Lond Saturday 13 "Cancel the Third demonstration 8 & Sunday 9 & Sunday July World *We changed the routine of our work during the Gulf war because we found many of the old branch committee structures were an obstacle to reaching out beyond the party...

"We will not be able to reach out and attract the political minority if we simply slide back into a reinstatement of those old structures. Nothing would be worse than a return to the routine three hour long weekly branch committee "We suggested during the war the use of 'troikas' the secretary, paper organiser and the recruitment officer - to lead the branches, meeting for half an hour before each weekly meeting. Where these exist the work has gone forward very well. *But in reality the "troikas" have not existed in many branches..." The circular goes on to propose a somewhat revised troikatype system.

In and of itself the proposal may well be sensible.

Much of the general argu ment of the circular is also sensible. It argues for making Socialist Worker sales central to SWP branch activity, involving every SWP member in those sales, and building weekly branch discussion meetings.

But what seems to be going on here - under the common-sense proposals is the shutting down of whatever little internal discussion there was in branches.

The weekly branch meetings are in fact op

Scan page 15

ube workers vote Socialist Organiser No. 484 page 15

----- pull-quotes -----

WHAT'S ON Saturday April

Saturday 6 July

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 484

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →