Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Life is a dilemma

Socialist Organiser no. 484, 25 April 1991 · scan pp. 13–14 · Tony Brown · about 734 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

This is Hal Draper's dedication for his last book, "Karl Marx's Theory of Revolution, volume 4: Critique of Other Film Tony Brown reviews Life is Sweet Like Leigh has got a that he is finding difficult to resolve. It is the same dilemma, re-expressed in Life is Sweet, that was at the heart of his 1989 film High Hopes.

The similarities between the two films stand out. Leigh is saying that those who profess to be political while doing nothing active lose their inner being, and that those who maintain their spirit, regardless of their overt politics and despite the times, are better able to face the future.

In Life is Sweet, Wendy and Andy live in Tottenham with their 23 year old twin daughters Nicola and Socialisms* THIS VOLUME IS DEDICATED to the student and worker revolutionaries of China who fought for workers' power through workers' democracy from below in the bravest popular upheava ever seen, against the bureaucraticcollectivist ruling regime that calls itself "Communist" , and who temporarily yielded before the monstrous massacre of June 4, 1989 Natalie. They are your typical working family, and much time, perhaps too much, is given to establishing their characters.

There is also too much of the dreadful Aubrey. The purpose of his tiresome restaurant venture can only be to satirise the pretentious eating scene. It doesn't work.

The family's foibles are amusing and readily identifiable. If nothing else Leigh has an acute ear for ear dialogue.

Andy is a gunner, even though he follows Spurs. He's always gunner do the bathroom, or the front door, but something gets in the way every time. He's loveable and easily conned.

Wendy is always cheery, looking for a laugh in every situation. Natalie is a serious minded plummer who works and saves for her trip to America.

Nicola is the fly in the ointment. Her shrillness and self-isolation masks her intense unhappiness and insecurity. She does get all the good one liners however.

She considers herself a feminist and socialist, and wears anti-poll executed by the bureaucratic-military dictatership, assassins of the people.

The association of this counterrevolutionary tyranny with the name of Karl Marx is the biggest Big Lie in listory, systematically falsified by bot!

the Stalinist world of bureaucraticcollectivism and the decaying world of capitalism, and by the apologists of both exploitative systems.

HD, June 5, 1989 tax t-shirts.

But she spends her life as a recluse waiting only for her boyfriend to come around when everyone else is at work. Her needs are so apparent you feel like yelling out for someone to talk to her, to try to reach her.

Thankfully, Nicola's lover confronts her and tells her he wants to know her not just sleep with her. This is the beginning of an intense final fifteen minutes.

Wendy and Nicola finally talk. It's vigorous and genuine. Wendy appeals to Nicola to start living, to join a socialist group, go on demonstrations, live her beliefs.

It is not one of those guilt-laden mother daughter conversations, it is an expression of love and an encouragement for hope.

It is a very moving scene. The audience feels for them. It is a human drama, and that is rare in the cinema because emotions are too often cynically manipulated, or simply ignored.

Similarly in High Hopes, Leigh captures in one scene the dilemma in his central characters, and their relationship.

They have been living together tor years. He is the political hait, pessimistic about the world and certain that capitalism is in decay, she talks less about politics and what she really wants is to have a baby.

The revelation isn't that he supposedly believes in political action yet is so pessimistic about the world that he can't face bringing up a baby, while she has the confidence to try.

It's the scene in their bedroom where she explains why the baby is so important, that you realise that their relationship hinges on his reply.

In capturing these moments Leigh provokes his audience to feel and think.

He may not be able to resolve his dilemma but to engage us in feeling for Nicola and to be moved by her plight is itself uplifting and what cinema should be about.

Maybe his next film will have the political character involved acting upon his/her beliefs and being for.

tified by so doing.

Scan page 14

Lessons of Kurdish tragedy Organisi

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 484

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →