Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The road to

Socialist Organiser no. 484, 25 April 1991 · scan pp. 10–13 · about 4,719 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Thatcherism was firmly based on the City, Treasury and the CBI Joh his Party In Mellroy continue series on the Tory he ingredients of Thatcherite policies should be familiar. In political terms, Thatcherism owed its provenance broadly to the same disillusionment with the methods of the post-war consensus as a viable means of reversing Britain's economic decline as had fuelled Heath Mark I 1970-72, the betrayal of that approach by Heath Mark II 1972-74, and the consequent failure of both Heath Mark 1 and Heath Mark II.

It was the response of the Party to Heath's failures (as well as internal disarray) which enabled Thatcher to become leader of the Party.

It was the responses of the electorate to the failure of Labour's policies 1974-79, seen by the conservative right as cut from the same corporatist cloth as the later Heath, which enabled Thatcher to become leader of the country But Thatcherism was different in important aspects from the experiment mounted by Heath - indeed Powell might be seen as a more plausible, if politically unlucky or ill adept, patron saint. Unlike Heath, Thatcher supped at the table of the New Right ideologues such as F A Hayek and Milton Friedman.

Where Heath wanted change within the framework of Keynesianism and the post-war consensus, Thatcher deduced from his failures that this was impossible. You needed monetarism, you needed to stay put when unemployment increased, you needed to build and use a strong state to create and then guarantee a free market.

Where Heath wanted to involve remodelled trade unions in the political process, Thatcher wanted both to remodel them and to weaken them more severely and cast them out of political regulation and social legitimacy.

Where Heath wanted to change aspects of the post-war settlement but maintain its framework, Thatcher wanted rid of it, lock, stock and barrel.

Where Heath was a man of the '40s in his observance of limits to coercion, Thatcher went back to the 1920s in her willingness to use force to break the working class.

Thatcher's clearer view of the kind of society or non-society, she wanted and, of course, her great determination and skill as a politician (as well as loads of luck) produced a greater integration of policy making.

With Heath - to take just one example - his macro-economic policies were out of synch with his attempt to reduce wages and his anti-union legislation. Unemployment was more than twice its 1971 level when Thatcher's first legal measures began to take effect and of course, they were more limited and carefully drafted than Heath's Industrial Relations Act.

All of this meant that Thatcherism undoubtedly represented something new. But its novelty can and has been exaggerated. There was definitely a certain continuity not only with Heath but with the policies of the 1974-79 Labour government.

hose who have over-emphasised its novelty have also exaggerated its coherence.

The Thatcherism of 1987 was not the Thatcherism of 1981 or 1977.

The 1980 anti-union law was limited not because of the Tories' cunning plan but because Thatcher was not strong enough in Cabinet and Party to impose tougher measures on the reluctant Jim Prior. Similarly, what produced the attack on Local Government was not any ideological opposition or preconceived strategy but a gradually dawning realisation that here was an impediment to attempts to slash public expenditure and a redoubt from which political opponents could mount forays against central government and suggest living alternatives to its policies.

The Poll Tax only slowly emerged after the failures of grantcutting, rates referenda, rate capping and so on.

Those who have exaggerated the novelty and coherence of Thatcherism also exaggerated its successes.

Thatcher got 43.9% of the vote in 1979, which was admittedly an excellent recovery from 35.8% in October 1974.

Thereafter, in 1983 and 1987, her share of the vote fell slightly, hardly a firm basis for the vicarious Tory triumphalism of Hobsbawm, Jacques and Stuart Hall of Marxism Baldwin, Churchill, Eden, McMillan, even the Heath of 1970, would have sneered at this kind of performance achieved in the face of a divided opposition.

We shall look later on at the details of the failure of her project and its contribution to her downfall.

Those we have mentioned failed to weigh correctly the political trajectory of Thatcherism.

In December 1990, when the Lady was already well and truly Turned, Marxism Today appeared with an article by Hall and Jacques Thatcher becomes leader of the Tory Party in 1974. She did not dispense with all of Heath's policies (presumably printed just too early) which burbled as follows: *Thatcher herself is one of the most drive for more power is remorseless - not least because it is not personally but ideologically driven: she means to use whatever kind of powers she can command for a Higher Purpose. In addition, there is still a year to go before the election timetable begins to run against her."

This profound-sounding blather is based on a failure to grasp the first principles of Thatcherism.

In fact Thatcherism was first and toremost an attempt to mount a major offensive against the working class, to break its militancy, to cut back the gains it had made since 1945, particularly ın the areas of trade union organisation, political representation, the welfare state and nationalisation so as to remove it as a barrier to economic restructuring, enhanced efficiency and greater profitability.

This attempt to decisively and fundamentally transform the balance of class forces was essentially based on opening up the UK economy - and the UK workers - to international competition via a bonfire of controls and integrating UK capital into international capital. Heath was Brussels. Thatcher was Brussels, Hong. Kong, Bonn, Tokyo, New York, We must not underestimate the growing interpenetration and interlocking of different sectors of capitalism. But Thatcherism was prepared to accept that much of mass unemployment that monetarist engender, would decisively undermine the confidence and fighting ability of the working class. The bloc of commercial and financial interests and multinational corporations would be the winners but a smaller more efficient manufacturing industry would eventually be reconstructed on the backs of a defeated working class.

While the collapse and renovation of manufacturing industry was being fashioned, Britain's balance of payments would be financed by the performance of the financial and commercial bloc in the world financial boom and the oil money given by the buoyant market in oil.

Manufacturing industry must jack itself up to the standards of Germany and Japan or simply get out of the game.

In economic terms Thatcher was an international capitalist player reluctant even to subordinate her internationalism to a more limited European base via the EEC. This would limit both her political nationalism and her economic freedom. Where Heath wanted Europe, Thatcher wanted the world.

Thatcherism was thus firmly based upon the City, the Treasury, the giant transnationals and, somewhat surprisingly, the CBI, who, apart from threatening a bare-knuckled fight at the height of the recession of the early 1980s, went along with the new project.

Some 30% of the CBI's constituents of course are not industrial companies. Larger multinationals are represented. Many CBI members welcomed the opportunity for restructuring and pushing up productivity, and the drive to weaken trade unionism.

Once Thatcherism is understood O as an economic project, the nie is essential to examine the ideology it generates.

Organised around the poles of antiStalinism, anti-collectivism, antisocialism, Thatcherite ideology inflated and tied together social anxieties, fears and phobias such as:

•concern over inflation •increasing crime •the failures of the educational system •the overweening power of the unions.

•the bureaucratic inefficiency the welfare state •the image of a Britain packed bursting with immigrants.

It agreed with what it saw as the popular sentiment that something must be done about these social ills and it suggested that a strong state would quickly get amongst them and sort things out - in short order.

Scan page 11

The battle for Orgreave, miners' strike 1984. Thatcher went back to the 1920s in her willingness to use force to break the working class.

The "nanny state" looking after citizens ineffectively from cradle to grave shifted initiative, powertul unions crippled production and individual choice. Something must be done about it. We get looked after best when we stand on our own two feet and look after ourselves.

We make best use of our hard-earned cash when we spend it ourselves - rather than handing it over to a bureaucratic, inefficient state to spend it for us. We spend it best when we spend it on our own house and our own shares.

We must concentrate a lot more on earning, saving and spending cash and less on the sexual intercourse which had started in 1963. particularly its more perverted forms. The family must be rehabilitated as the repository of decency, suppression and economic Tationality.

It was no good simply going on and on about all this, however, whilst consuming more and more double scotches in saloon bars in Mitcham, Surrey or Milton Keynes whose name, by the way, needed changing as well. Something had to be done about it, something would be done about it, and Thatcher was the woman to do it and do it now.

Stuart Hall of Marxism Today, a professor at the Open University thought all this was simply bloody marvellous.

Impressed by its novelty, he claimed that at the dark heart of Thatcherism there lay this "authoritarian populism" which increasingly colonised the proletarian psyche and constituted a new "common-sense".

Whatever his more recent disavowals, his writings urged that Thatcherism is essentially a powertul, compelling, new set of ideas which has gripped the imagination of key sections of the working class and guaranteed their electoral support for the Conservatives.

But what is really novel about the ideologies used by Surely it represents simply a foregrounding of certain relatively ancient and reactionary ideas and stereotypes which have long subsisted in bourgeois ideology and working class consciousness coexisting with contradictory social democratic and socialist ideas.

What is the evidence that those ideas - which have come to the surface often in the past — were brought decisively and distinctively to the foreground in the years between 1975 and 1990?

Looked at from the angle of politics rather than impact on consciousness, were not Lord Salisbury and Stanley Baldwin authoritarian populists? Bonar Law and Churchill surely were., Is not authoritarian populism simply "Victorian values" suitably updated? *The failure Thatcherism opens up the possibility of change in Conservative policy and this potential should not be underestimated. Bu it is likely to be less exciting and more sober than it is to the taste of those who, regressing to the mentality of primitive Trotskyism pose splits and military adventures;

Did not Thatcher at best discover ideology and authoritarian populism in the same sense that Christopher Columbus discovered America?

Stuart Hall would argue that the novelty of Thatcherism lies in its original orchestration and powerful projection of these ideas in the context of the great reach and availability of media technology.

But if that is so we are really saying little more than that Thatcher, Tebbit and Co. were forceful, imaginative politicians able to exploit to the full changes in technology and political packaging.

The claim that authoritarian populism has been "relatively hegemonic" , has won the consent of the working class, has ensured that the political leadership of the nation has been exercised in the '80s with minimal resistance and with the need for minimal coercion, is even more questionable.

Evidence from all the opinion polls and surveys, particularly the annual volumes of the Social Attitudes, a crude way of measuring consciousness, but the best readily available, demonstrates large majorities, larger than in the "70s, for social democratic rather than Thatcherite attitudes.

There is large-scale support for a «socialist-type society" rather than a "capitalist-type society" , collectivism against individualism, the welfare state, higher taxation, even trade unionism (although obviously related to its depletion in the last decade).

The striking point about the supporters of authoritarian populism is the lack of evidence they adduce for their flights into "cultural studies" Cultural studies, by the way, is Hall's academic subject, and that tells us a lot about his overemphasis on ideology.

It is true that for example, Thatcher's promise of "free collective bargaining was very important in 1979 and 1983 in winning skilled manual workers to her banner.

This bespeaks little in terms of novelty, as Heath promised the same and won in 1970 and, put somewhat crudely, skilled workers voted for Thatcher in 1979 because they believed her policies would put more money in their pockets.

The fortunes. of Thatcher's economic policy, the fact that average earnings rose faster than prices between 1983 and 1988, concessions such as the engineered 1987 pre-election boom, bribes such as the sale of council house at bargain basement prices, material not ideological factors, gave Thatcher what success she gained as the difference electorally between the South and the North and Scotland demonstrates.

And that success owed more to the quirks of the election system, a split opposition, a divided Labour Party, not a little luck, as well as these factors in building together a contradictory coalition of the vote.

This 43% patch-up represented essentially, at bottom, the vote not of authoritarian populism, but the vote of those who had done well, or thought they would do well, out of Thatcherism, or thought they would do better out of Thatcherism than they would do out of the alternatives on offer.

Economics - in the full sense of the term - is what Thatcherism has been about. Economics in the full sense of the term is the key explanation for her support in the 1980s. As she painfully discovered in November 1990, the proof of the pudding lay in the eating.

et in historical perspective, Thatcherism represents one phase in the history of Conservative Party. It is not the conclusion of that history. It is not the Party's fate. It can be modified. It can be dropped. But neither is Thatcherism the preserve of one woman or the politics of one small group. It was widely accepted by the Party and by capital as a coherent response to the problems. of capital.

Our survey demonstrates that change is likely, for the Party possesses an extended repertoire of responses and, as we have recently seen confirmed, a fast-reaching organisational flexibility.

There is not one strand of conservatism but many.

Despite the recent rhetoric of principle, the essential imperative over the years has been, as Peel stated long ago, to preserve what is essential by accepting change in the inessential.

As the old Sicilian says in di Lampedusa's The Leopard, "Things must change so that they can stay the same"

Thus, in response to different political and economic pressures, different problems thrown up by the class struggle, very different policies and strategies have been pursued.

Indeed, as the great political novelist, Anthony Trollope, remarked: ...no reform, no innovation experience almost justifies us in saying no revolution - stinks so foully in the nostrils of an English Tory as to be absolutely irreconcilable to him."

Organiser The failure of Thatcherism opens up the possibility of change in Conservative policy and this potential. should not be underestimated. But it is likely to be less exciting and more sober than is to the taste of those who, regressing to the mentality of primitive Trotskyism, pose splits and military adventures.

The dialectic of continuity and change we have examined dictates that in the first instance, change is likely to be based upon political events — the economic situation, the General Election - and in the first instance upon a development rather than a complete ditching of The dramatic changes introduced in turn by Heath and Thatcher were the product of electoral disaster and intense periods of class conflict and took some years to introduce.

Change will have its roots in the failures of Thatcherism and the leadership election of 1990 and it is to those that we will turn in the next article.

Thatcher on her way out, November 1990

Scan page 12

aniser AGAINST THE TIDE Sean Matgamna ast Sunday I made Thomas, my 12 year old son, the excuse for watching Inherit the Wind once again, on TV.

Made in 1960, this is a fine movie about the 1925 "Monkey Trial". A young American school teacher was charged, at the instigation of Christian fundamentalists, with teaching Darwin's theory of evolution; and he was found guilty.

A strange business. Stranger still was the role played in it by William Jennings Bryan, for decades America's leading left-wing populist. Three times a candidate for US President, champion of the poor and the oppressed, enemy of the monopolists and big bankers, and Secretary of State in Woodrow Wilson's government from 1912 to 1915, Bryan had long been a sort of Tony Benn in American politics.

But in the "Monkey Trial" Bryan appeared for the prosecution, who, taking their stand on the literal truth of the Bible, sought - in 1925! — to jail a teacher for daring to teach Darwin!

The case for the defence was put by Clarence Darrow, a perennial legal champion of civil liberties.

Frederic March, an actor who was witch-hunted by the McCarthyites, played Bryan as a twitchy, vain, glutinous, dogmatic, kindly and - I found — likeable old man, proud of his links with "the people" and fighting a ridiculous battle on their behalf. Privately he appeals to Darrow, an old acquaintance, to leave the people's Christian beliefs alone. Those beliefs are the best they have in poverty-stricken, closed-in lives, he tells him.

Now I know little about William Jennings Bryan and his religious beliefs, and not much about American populism.

But I read something recently which made the drama of William Jennings Bryan at the Monkey Trial" ', depicted in lightly fictional form on the little screen in Thomas's room, seem to me to be a parable about the left.

It seems that Bryan hated Darwinism the idea that animal species, including humankind, evolve through "natural selection" and "the survival of the fittest"- for reasons other than Christian fundamentalism. He hated, and had spent his political life fighting, the doctrines known as "Social Darwinism" , or ideas like them.

The "Social Darwinists" took Darwin's picture of nature and made an ideology of it for society, justifying the domination of the rich and powerful over the poor and dispossessed. It was nature's law, they said.

This version of "Darwinism" added a "scientific" gloss, and sometimes could give a messianic elan, to old bourgeois attitudes that had already produced the savage 1834 Poor Law in Britain well before Darwin published his scientific theories.

Social Darwinism said that savage prewelfare-state capitalism was the only possible, and therefore the only moral, system. It worked to stop people imagining even a welfare capitalism.

It openly stigmatised all the poor with the racial inferiority now alleged only by the most lunatic racists, and only against blacks. And those Social-Darwinist ideas were the trend of the times in the early part of this century. They had great power - because, entwined through they were with bourgeois special pleading, they were nourished by shreds of truth - and they carried all before them.

Turning observations about evolution in the wild into precepts for running society and into an ideology justifying exploitation and oppression by "the fittest" , "Social Darwinism" was indeed a nasty and inhuman piece of brute bourgeois self-righteousness. It stank with the smell of the slums and of the workhouses, and it would later stink with the smell of the racist death camps.

o Bryan had social reasons, gong "Darwinism"

He, and others like him, used religious ideas about the uniqueness of humankind, created whole by a supreme being, to assert social and political claims here and now -that men and women were not beasts, that. they should not be treated as cattle, and that all were equal under God.

T assume that the great old populist did believe in the Bible when he stood up in court to make a fool of himself in the eyes of the educated world. But Bryan thought that the "Word of God" he defended was also the word authorising the struggle for a better human society than the one American Those who do not learn from history are condemned to relive it Left: the people's militia formed by Fidel Castro's revolutionary government marches through the streets of Havana in February 1961. Two months later, in April, Castro's forces defeated an inva-sion by US-backed right-wing ex iles at the Bay of Pigs.

Castro's 26 July movement had overthrown the corrupt, rotten, despotic, unequal, US-backed Batista regime in January 1959.

The revolution, led by a small band of guerrilla fighters and pro mising democracy, national libera tion and social justice, had huge support.

But as Castro moved to nationalise US property, the US became hostile. Castro, in response, sought aid from the USSR and teamed up with Cuba's Moscow-line Communist Party. Ui til the late '60s, at least, Cuba re mained a much more free society than any Stalinist regime, and Castro and - especially - his comrade Che Guevara remained critical of Moscow dogma.

But bit by bit the regime congealed into Stalinist shape. Now Castro is a last-ditch defender of the command economy. PERSPECTIVE capitalism had so far made.

And of course it was all nonsense. Against science the book of Genesis was untenable. Bryan's stand on the Bible could only bring ridicule and discredit on him, and a measure of discredit on all his ideas. The real solution to the problem presented by the unholy alliance of bourgeois social ideas with science was to unite the proletariat - or, in Bryan's terms, "the people" - with science. Bryan went the opposite way. The left too has often opposed an evil he "parable" seems to me to be this:

capitalist system on platforms as senseless as that on which WJ Bryan tried to fight Social Darwinism. It is one of the main reasons why the left is now in disarray. It is the keystone of Marxist politics that the class struggle occurs not only on the economic and political fronts, but also on the ideological front.

What happens on the ideological front conditions and shapes what happens on the political and economic front.

For decades the left - I mean the honest, militant left — has been in disarray and in retreat on the front of ideas. Pressure from the ideas of the bourgeoisie — endowed with vast resources as they are, and aided by the reformists, with their outright bourgeois ideas — is always with us. In addition to that, Stalinism worked like a cancer within the left, appropriating, changing, perverting and internally disrupting old left-wing ideas.

Black was declared white, and not only on the level of straight lies. Goals, ends, means were redefined and redefined again, out of all recognition.

People in revolt against capitalist oppression wound up justifying or calling historically progressive systems more murderously oppressive than any capitalist oppression except Nazism in its final paroxysm. Starting with opposition to their immediate oppression, and trying to hold their own against the relentless pressure of the bourgeoisie and their ideas, left-wingers based themselves on general ideas about the world which were often blatantly nonsensical.

The prerequisite for mass socialist belief in the putrid Stalinist myths about the various «socialist fatherlands" - with their philosopher kings and their all-regimenting fascist-like states - was the need to deny what the bourgeoisie said about them. My enemy's enemy is my friend - or, in this case, workers were in effect saying of the totalitarian state and its bureaucratic ruling class: my enemy's enemy is me, therefore it is me over there too...

The clearest example in Britain today is notions - even now! - about the Stalinist systems.

And not just the Stalinist left has gone astray, but much of the would-be Trotskyist left too. On most of the essential questions about the world, the neo-Trotskyist left stood on the same ground as Stalinism.

Critically, to be sure, championing the rights of the workers, but accepting the fundamental nonsense that the Stalinist societies were a progressive alternative to capitalism.

The small, isolated, resource-starved rearguard of Bolshevism, the Trotskyist groups have frequently sustained their commitment to the struggle against the bourgeoisie by endorsing the political equivalents of the Book of Genesis, and occasionally the equivalents of the Koran and the Book of Mormon too!

The worst example I know of is the uncritical endorsement - as proof of the superiority of socialistic methods - of Mao's late-'50s "Great Leap Forward" in China. In reality that was an attempt at an economic forced march by the totalitarian state in which an unknown number of Chinese -perhaps 30 million: no-one knows for sure!

- senselessly lost their lives. Yet you will find the weighty journal Fourth International, then published by Ernest Mandel and Michel Pablo, reproducing Chinese claims of success with all the credulity of a medieval peasant listening to the words of a priest announcing a new religious miracle!

or is it just a matter of illusions in from the SWP through to Michael Foot - for decades opposed the bourgeois policy on the EC by standing on a hopeless and bankrupt little Englandism!

Many still do. Instead of endorsing any progress away from the national narrowness that bred two world wars, criticising the class nature of the emerging capitalist Europe, and seeking to serve working-class interests within that Europe, the broader left chose to "defend" working-class interests by standing on the untenable position that the British bourgeoisie itself had reluctantly had to abandon. It was, and is, ideological Luddism.

A respect-worthy and loyal working class fighter like Dennis Skinner is, on this and similar questions, an out and out reactionary compared to a John Major or a Margaret Thatcher!

The "struggle on the ideological front" is not like a physical battle, or a trade union battle, or an election. In all of those you know roughly who won and who lost. Defeat on the ideological front comes in many different forms.

It can be creeping and insidious. it can come disguised as a great new idea, or a getrich scheme. It can seem to offer big advantages and enormous price reductions on the political and industrial front; and then you find it is no longer the same political or industrial front!

"he greatest and worst defeats are those indie let are arden back to tak and the left are driven back to take refuge in old, discredited ideas.

The worst inner political setbacks occur when we are unable to deal with the problems of the real world except by the spinning of fantasies about socialist fatherlands, or by reading alien scenarios into inappropriate situations, thus, for example, transforming Ba'athist dictators or military dictators in Argentina into "anti-imperialists" • You could make a very long list from the experience of post-Trotsky Trotskyism.

The spectacular collapses of Stalinism pose a hard choice to the Trotskyist left. The truth, however unpalatable it may be, is that for decades the would-be Trotskyist movement subsisted by proclaiming the true ideas of working-class self-emancipation alongside and entwined with nonsense, some of it pernicious anti-working class nonsense. We sought reassurance, despite everything, from the world-wide social weight of the Stalinist movements.

That reassurance helped to sustain those currents of "Trotskyism" that most adroitly adapted to Stalinism, with Ernest Mandel glibly and servilely theorising the "historic process" in the same way that Karl Kautsky theorised the practice of the Social-Democratic parties before World War 1.

No more. The Trotskyist movement will now either cut loose fully, and renew itself politically and ideologically, or it will sink, still attached to Stalinism, and die. If it does not cut loose, it will deserve to die, as Bryan's poisonous populist mixture of good intentions and benighted confusion deserved to die. And did.

Scan page 13

Socialist Organiser No. 484 page 13

----- pull-quotes -----

astute and powerful of contem- porary political leaders and her

traditional manufacturing industry would go to the wall. The recession

beyond mere religious belief and reaching deeper than mere foolish Bibical dogmatism, for opposing all forms of

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 484

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →