Propaganda and the Kurds
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-04-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
comrades!
Henry Newman Birmingham that America wouldn't get away with it. But it did. And now the Kurds are paying the price.
South London That should socialists have said about John Major's proposal for a UN-protected Kurdish "enclave" in northern Iraq?
In Socialist Organiser last week we argued: "The short answer is that we should welcome it, while retaining our attitude of distrust and hostility to the 'Allies"."
Militant and Socialist Worker argued differently. Militant:
"The Kurds' leaders have appealed to the UN and the US for help...But if they [the US and its allies] had given military aid in the last few weeks the strings attached would soon have turned into a noose for the Kurdish and Iraqi peoples...
And instead? "An appeal to workers and peasants in and around Baghdad could have dealt the regime a fatal blow in its heart. The majority Sunni Moslem people in that area...
could have been won by an Iraq-wide opposition with a... socialist programme."
In other words: socialism is the only answer. Or rather, socialism could have been the only answer.
By last week the uprisings in Iraq had been defeated. The Kurds were fleeing in terror and dying in hundreds. The editors of Militant, safe and warm in London, read them lectures on how it all could have been better if they had had an Iraq-wide movement with a socialist programme, and how it would be unprincipled for them now to manoeuvre and seek lesser evils!
There is an approximate precedent for Militant's attitud in the politics of the Stalinist movement in its ultra-left "third period". After World War I, the Saarland, a corner of Germany, was cut off, with its administration under the League of Nations and its coal mines controlled by France. The Versailles Treaty laid down that a referendum should be organised there in 1935 on the future of the area.
The Nazis took power in Germany. But for a while, in mid-1933, the Stalinists called on workers to vote in the referendum for union with Germany. "A Red Saar in a Soviet Germany!" was their slogan.
Trotsky denounced this as *the cowardice of pseudoradicalism". . *Naturally we must come out for a Soviet Saar, that is, teaching the need for the conquest of power. The date of this conquest has not, however, been fixed anywhere, while the date of the referendum has been fixed quite precisely in the Versailles Treaty.
*That means that the party that fights for a Soviet Saar owes the workers an answer to the question: how should they vote in the year 1935?
"To rally to Hitlerite Germany in practice, ie. through the referendum, means, theoretically speaking, to put national mysticism above the class interest and psychological ly to conduct a really cur-like "Naturally, only traitors can demand annexation at present, for that means to sacrifice the most concrete and vital questio of the German workers in the Saar territory to the abstract, national factor."
Trotsky supported neither t Versailles Treaty, nor the League of Nations, nor imperialist France. But he lavoured a vote for continued autonomy for the Saar (under the League of Nations). And the vapid bluster which Militant offers now to the Kurdish people facing Ba'athist genocide ("*a red Kurdistan in a soviet Iraq"?) is no better than the *pseudo-radical" Stalinist response then to the Nazi threat to the rights and organisation of the Saar workers.
Socialist Worker came to the same conclusion as Militant, but less clear-cut. Its editorial offered three arguments. First, that the "enclave" idea was a old British trick: Second, tha it was not a big enough partition of Iraq and the other states ruling Kurdish populations! *If Bush, Major, the EC leaders and the UN really wanted to create a safe haven for the Kurds, they would support their demand for a homeland and create a Kurdish state."
And, third, that the "enclave" •would effectively be controlled by Turkey", which would also oppress the Kurds. What SW's attitude would be to an enclave not controlled by Turkey it did not say. Its message to the fleeing, dying people was that there was "No Solution for the Kurds"] The line here was more anti-imperialism is the only answer" than "socialism is the only answer". It was still "pseudoradical". For SW, all concern for the Kurds was apparently subordinate to getting a simple and "saleable" line against the US-British military presence in the region for use in British SO also argued that Western socialists should continue to op pose the imperialist troop presence. We did not do so by denying that the Kurds might get some advantages from an mperialist-protected enclave. but by recalling fundamental arguments.
We could not trust the US and Britain to create the "enclave" , still less to run it in line with the Kurds' interests! Even if they did help the Kurds a little, that could not outweigh the terrible things they did in the war against Iraq and are likely to do in future if they continue as imperialist overlord: in the region.
We also argued that *the Kurds" who have to operate in circumstances not chosen by themselves, with the US/British presence as a given fact — *have a right to play their enemies off against each other as best they can, and the right to take what help they can get." We called for arms to the Kurds, and for the opening of borders (including Britain's and the US's) to refugees.
SW and Militant evidently decided that such arguments were too complicated, too subtle. Trotsky once remarked that Stalin dealt with the national question, like all other questions, from the point of view of administrative convenience. SW and Militant dealt with the plight of the Kurds, like all other questions, from the point of view of propagandist convenience.
John Major - we distrust him, but is that all that thare is to be said?
----- pull-quotes -----
EMEON THESIEFT
*The line here was more 'anti-imperialish the only answer thai socialism is the only answer. It was still 'pseudo-radical'"