Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Unearthing what Marx really meant

Socialist Organiser no. 483, 18 April 1991 · scan pp. 13–14 · Colin Foster · about 846 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

Book Colin Foster reviews Marx's Theory of Revolution, volume Critique of Other Socialisms, by Hal Draper {Monthly Review Press, £9.50)

ritique of Other Socialisms, volume in Hal Draper's monumental study of Marx's The fifth and other volumes planned in this ever-expanding work seem condemned never to appear. The project was started by Draper in old age, after four decades of activity in the Trotskyist and neo-Trotskyist movement; he died in January 1990, after finishing all but a couple of details of this volume.

Most of volume 4 is about Marx's critique of anarchism (as represented by the French advocate of a society of small cooperatives, Pierre-Joseph Proudhon, and the Russian advocate of "pan-destruction", Mikhail Bakunin), and of "state-socialism" (as represented notably by Ferdinand Lassalle, German socialist whose main agitation was • for Bismarck's government to provide state aid to worker cooperatives).

A lot of the volume is only more detailed recital of what has already been outlined in a previous volume; moreover, Draper's self-imposed limits on his work press particularly hard here. Draper aimed to limit himself to accurate exposition of what Marx wrote, rather than new discussion of the substantive issues covered by Marx or disputes about the application of Marx's ideas to later developments; here this means exposition of Marx on Bakunin, or Marx on Lassalle, with only minimal references to the relevance, for example, of Marx's critique of "state-socialism" to the pretensions of Stalinism.

The relevance, however, is pretty clear; and the whole four volumes remain well worth reading - conscientious, superbly written, and often witty in their demolition of academic "Marxology"

Volume 2 (The Politics of Social Classes) is a good introduction to Marx's politics. It shows that Marx and Engels were the first socialists to appreciate the importance of the trade union movement, and that — contrary to much writing about their antipeasant" attitudes — they were also the first socialists to try to work out a policy for the peasantry. It covers their analyses of the middle classes, and their changing ideas on how the working class should relate to middle-class revolutionary movements.

Volume 1 (State and Bureaucracy) has two distinct sections. The first follows through Marx's development from radical democrat to communist, emphasising that, unlike almost all others of the day, Marx's communism or socialism embraced and included radical democracy. The second traces Marx's analyses of particular states. Its chief argument is that Marx admitted, and indeed frequently used, the notion of a bureaucracy being a ruling class. This argument is related to Draper's own view of the Stalinist states as *bureaucratic collectivism" , though Draper, respecting his self-imposed limits, does not draw out the implications.

Volume 3 (The Dictatorship of the Proletariat) is devoted to proving one proposition, and one proposition only: that by "dictatorship of the proletariat" Marx meant only the rule of the working class, no more, no less. The term "dictatorship" did not imply that the workers rule would be "dictatorial" in the modern sense; nor did it refer to some special "dictatorial" form of workers' rule. Even though Marx was well aware of the need for revolutionary regimes to use force, his use of the term "dictatorship" was not meant to signal that need.

The book proceeds by exhaustively amalysing every use Marx ever made of the term. It shows that the word "dictatorship" did not have the same connotations of uncontrolled state repression when Marx was writing as it has now; it argues that Marx used the term mainly to help explain his ideas to the Blanquist current in the socialist movement of the time, counterposing his dictatorship of the working class to their "educational" dictatorship of a socialist minority.

A companion volume by Draper (The dictatorship of the proletariat from Marx to Lenin) demonstrates (convineingly, to my mind) that all the classical Marxists, including Lenin and Trotsky but possibly excepting Rosa Luxemburg, were to some degree or another confused on this point.

The introduction to volume 4 does not tell us how far Draper had progressed before his death in his work for the subsequent volumes, nor whether he left substantial fragments in publishable form. It is to be hoped that he did. Moscow anti-semites say what some "lefts" say here: "Zionists and Nazis one"

Tuesday evenings. Part one traced it back to the poisoned springs of Christianity.

The image conjured up of the cross turning into the swastika will have offended some Christians. It was no offense against historic truth.

They did offend against historic truth when they presented Karl Marx denouncing "Jewish capitalism". Marx shared in the stereotyping common in his time: ideas like "Jewish capitalism" have taken on a distinct: modern meaning which they did not have and could not have had for Marx.

Nothing is gained by such muddyi and blurring and anachronismmongering.

Channel 4's season of Banned material is fascinating, bringing the banned of yesteryear, films and TV shows. Unfortunately, the banned and hidden of today is still banned and hidden...

Scan page 14

It's moved on since 1940 Organiser

----- pull-quotes -----

Periscope ex Bloomstein's series on

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 483

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →