Turned into shallow parody
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-04-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
Tony Brown reviews Bonfire of the Vanities Com Wolfe's novel is a story about New York. New York, the biggest, richest city in the world at the end of the twentieth century. Like Rome, Paris or London of earlier eras New York is the centre of the world, and Bonfire of the Vanities sets out to show what makes it tick.
The complexity of the city is portrayed through a series of characters who represent the Irish, Jews, Italians, Blacks and Wasps, and who live in the Bronx, Manhattan, Long Island and Queens.
Essentially it's about the corruption of politics, justice and power in the Big Apple. At the centre is Sherman McCoy, a Wasp, product of Yale who takes his position for granted.
So isolated is he by his wealth, privilege and office on Wall Street, that one wrong turn off the freeway into the Bronx brings about his downfall. Sherman, who can't survive on his $1 million a year income, makes multi-million dollar deals over the telephone, and considers himself a "master of the universe"
He is the epitome of 1980s greed, and yet he is not another Gordon Gekko. He turns out to be a pathetic creature who doesn't understand the society around him even though he reaps such privilege from it.
Sherman in the end becomes everyone's victim. But unlike older tragedy tales there is no sympathy for Sherman because it is impossible to empathise with his position in the world.
It's a rare story full of insight and depth.
Most of the main characters are "outsiders" . They have come to New York from the south, the midwest, England, other cultures and backgrounds, but are all in the end shaped by the society around them. Their actions are guided by feuds and prejudices that are almost tribal in origin.
This week a film with the same name opened. Its characters are also called Sherman, Fallow, Maria, Kramer and Reverend Bacon. But that's about as close as it gets to the real thing.
Where the book is a wry commentary on modern New York, the film is a shallow parody.
All the characters are wrong. Everything is tipped on its head. Instead of a Jewish Judge in the Bronx we have a black Judge. Instead of a boozing English Journalist we get Bruce Willis. Instead of a 40-year old "master of the universe" we get a preppy Tom Hanks.
All the major characters are stripped bare and become caricatures.
Why? Are novels simply too complex to translate into film? Is it that movies can't cope with depth? I don't think so. But whatever it is, the result is clear. Brian de Palma doesn't know what to do with the story. All the social aspects have been cut out, put in the too hard basket. Rather than getting a gourmet meal we get dished up cream cake and weak tea.
It will be interesting to compare Bonfire to the forthcoming Madame Bovary by Claude Chabrol. Bovary is also a complex book that seeks to shed light on the morality of French rural life in the 19th century. Perhaps we will see how this novel is translated onto film without the "benefits" of Hollywood financing and casting.
In the meantime, read Tom Wolfe's Bonfire of the Vanities.