Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Those who do not learn from history are condemned

Socialist Organiser no. 483, 18 April 1991 · scan pp. 12–13 · about 734 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

Tony Benn was not always Tony Benn, as sneering Tory papers sometimes remind u! Thirty years ago he was, for a while, Viscount Stansgate, succeeding his father, a well known Labour peer.

Benn did not want to be a peer, but a peer he was, nevertheless, and, as the law then stood there was nothing he could do about it.

A commoner could be made a peer by the Queen, but no power on earth could "unannoint", make a commoner out of a peer!

It was Tony Benn's response to the trap he found himself in which first marked him out as a Labour politician. He refused to In the Labour Party it is very much the same. There are undoubtedly pressures to conform and they do bear down on most people. Their effect is not inevitable, however, and it is a profoundly patronising and demoralising message to suggest that it People whose political activity consists largely of transmitting that message bear a large part of the responsibility for the pessimism of the British left. The way to resist these pressures in the Labour Party, as in society generally, is to organise; to fight for and develop socialist ideas; to turn Labour outwards and take the lifeblood of struggle into the ideological corpse that is Labour, but above all to erect a base for political ideas which understand the role of Labour in our society and have no illusions about its potential for achieving socialism.

Our project is to transform the labour movement, to make it fit to transform society, it is an aggressive dynamic project driven by powerful ideas, the labour movement will not transform us.

nowhere near so dangerous as is There is something else to say about this "inevitable shift to the right" myth. The pressures which can pull socialists rightwards exist for anyone who has any serious contact with reformist politics. No-one is immune. go to the House of Lords.

He stood, although a peer, for Bristol seat and was re-elected.

He was still not allowed to take his Com mons seat: so he stood in the subsequent by-election, and again he won!

His model was Charles Bradlaugh, who, a hundred years earlier, had been refused the right to take his seat in Parliament because he was an atheist, but was reelected again and again by his Northampton constituents.

Benn finally forced a change in the law, shed his unwanted peerage, and with one short break, has been an MP ever since.

In the 1970s, for example, there was a tremendous mood amongst the trade union and Labour left to resist British entry into the EEC. The arguments were overwhelmingly nationalist (we should look after our "own"

jobs, "our own" industries, a European parliament would be less sympathetic to Labour-type reforms than Westminster) and should not have affected the revolutionary left who, throughout the 1960s, had been neutral on the issue.

Capitalist market conditions would govern whether Britain was in or out of the BEC, only the names of some of the dominant employers would change. The pressure was great, however, and because of the big industrial struggles of the early "70s, much of the revolutionary left, particularly the SWP (IS), had developed a pattern of serious work in the trade unions. One after another, Britain's revolutionary left organisations capitulated to the nationalist arguments of the anti-European reformists. The SWP led the way. British withdrawal from the EEC became an accepted "socialist" policy.

Socialist Organiser resisted the pull. We still regard it as far more important to develop a working-class strategy for unity across Europe to respond to the bosses"

market than to support British economic sovereignty. The pressure to concede an important political idea existed and exerted its influence on the entire left in the 1970s, on the SWP just as on the forerunners of SO.

Our different responses came above all from the state of our politics, our relative ideological strength and our seriousness, not from the secondary matter of whether we are organisationally separate from the Labour Party.

Electoralism, of course, holds many traps for people like us, who take elections seriously, but it is nowhere near so dangerous as is opportunism for socialists who don't take basic political ideas seriously.

Scan page 13

THE CULTURAL nise

----- pull-quotes -----

«Electoralism of course holds many traps, but is

opportunism for socialists who don't take basic political ideas seriously."*

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 483

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →