Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The Tories consensus

Socialist Organiser no. 483, 18 April 1991 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 1,193 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Beme adige, Keş es aed mathoman satiom Hugh Gaitskell, Labour Party leader from 1955 to 1963, represented the Labour John Mellroy his series on party heir electoral reverse in 1945 is usually seen as the occasion for the revolution in Conservative politics which produced the new post-war welfare Conservatism of Butler and Macmillan.

However, the Conservatives had already accepted the Beveridge Report arguing for the need for an efficient system of social security, the need for a new state provision of health, and introduced the 1944 Education Act as part of the policies of the wartime coalition.

There was not a great deal to choose between the policies of the Conservatives and the platform of the Labour Party in the 1945 general election.

In accepting the need for the state to intervene to a greater extent than hitherto, to influence employment levels and guarantee the supply of healthy, well-housed, well-educated labour to capitalist production, and rationalise capitalist organisation — as well as thus legitimising capitalism as a fair and decent side of the consensus politics called "Butskellism"

he piaty of system - the Conservative Party were responding generally to the same social pressure as the Labour Party. These were essentially the radicalism induced by the war, the example of wartime policies, the disillusion with the policies of the inter-war years, the fear of revolution and the exanding Empire of Stalinism.

Moreover, many of the changes were initially limited - for example, the ideas outlined by Beveridge for the welfare state and by Keynes for intervention to regulate the economy were far narrower in scope than what was to become practice in the'50s and '60s. As RA Butler put it, invoking history: "As in the days of Peel the Conser1214 vatives must be seen to have accommodated themselves to a social revolution."

More specifically, the Conservatives were responding to a crushing and suprising electoral defeat. This produced, or strengthened, new thinking in key policy areas, led by figures such as Butler, Macleod and Maudling, who based themselves on the Conservative Political Centre and the Research Department.

Over the longer haul the new Conservatism was the product not so much of 1945 as of the post-war economic boom taking off from the late '40s, and the marginalisation of the Liberals gave the Conservatives, now the capitalist party, plenty of room for manoeuvre.

Labour's propaganda in the 1951 general election claimed that Winston Churchill would lead a return to the 'thirties.

Instead, the administrators of Churchill and Eden accepted most of Labour's reforms. All sections of capital in a situation of large-scale expansion of the world economy could live with them. Many could benefit from them. For some they were essential.

But they would not take the reforms further. In some cases there was a paring at the edges, as with the de-nationalisation of steel, and in some cases a reversal of forward planning, as with the move from council housing to the private sector; in some cases, as with the NHS and the welfare state generally, there was a qualitative expansion of the structures and services laid down by the government. The Conservatives accepted that unemployment levels of more than 500,000 spelled electoral disaster and intervened to stimulate demand as Keynesian market management became the new orthodoxy.

Kelationsnips with ine unions were good indeed. Many in the TUC favourably compared them Waltere Concon 55l and Walter Monckton was The Tories continued the disbanding of Minister Harold Macmillan in Swaziland, and full independence in 1968 remembered as a model Minister Labour.

In foreign policy the Conservatives continued Labour's dismantling of Empire with only the bitter, but swiftly disavowed, hiccup of Suez.

Both parties subscribed to a broad consensus in which there were important differences of emphasis.

Capitalism would continue as *the mixed economy" with selective nationalisation producing cheap efficient infrastructure and subsidies to private enterprise, an enlarged welfare state, full employment and a fairer distribution of income - though less so after the 'forties.

The argument now centred basically not on what kind of system but on which party was best 'Conservative success derived fitted to manage post-capitalism (as the Labour right saw it). The class struggle continued, but it was more muffled.

Pundits pontificated about the "End of Ideology" and Harold Macmillan's social democratic Conservative Party of "the middle way" won the 1959 general election on the slogan "You've never had it so good"

Based on the expansion of the world economy, Conservative success derived from the Party's ability to produce increased living standards and project itself as an efficient economic manager.

Its mass vote in the thirteen years of Conservative rule between 1951 and 1964 remained firmly based on the professional managerial and clerical groups - many of whom were of course working class. But it depended crucially on around a quarter of the manual working class voting Conservative - and here the Conservatives were successful in developing the tradition pioneered by Disraeli with cross-class support. Eden won 49.7% of the vote in 1955 and Macmillan only fractionally less in 1959.

There was one big problem. In the years after the war industrial productivity in the UK was half that in the USA and Germany, and its share in manufacturing exports from the advanced economies dropped from 25% to 10%. The guarantee of full employment produced strong unions.

The expansion of the welfare state was financed by increased taxation. This in turn produced pressures from the workers to make up their losses through increased wages. As international economic competition intensified through the '50s and '60s so did the UK's decline.

The cold war compromise and the acceptance by both parties of a position as junior partner to the USA imposed costs in terms of military expenditure and cut the UK off from the development of a European alternative. The East of Suez role and the interests of finance capital imposed costs in terms of the outward flow of capital and defence of the pound as an international currency.

Increased awareness of decline pushed the Macmillan government by 1961 to look to increased state intervention in an attempt to modernise British industry and make it more competitive and efficient.

This centred on a mild injection of planning and attempts to influence the processes of industrial relations and wage determination. The focus was on attempts to cultivate closer links with the unions and employers through the National Economic Development Council and the National Incomes Commission.

Chancellor Selwyn Lloyd's pay pause signalled the beginnings of the end of "voluntarism" in which collective bargaining between unions and employers was left to regulate industrial relations.

But economic problems, social scandals such as the Profumo affair, and the presentation ot a compelling alternative project of modernisation by the Labour opposition led by Harold Wilson, contributed towards the downfall of Macmillan.

It was a tribute to the political sway the Conservatives exercised that they lost the 1964 election by only a handful of seats.

Scan page 11

Ted Heath becomes Prime Minister in 1970. His proto-Thatcherite "Selsdon" programme was to end in fiasco N PERSPECTIVE Socialist Organiser No. 483 page 11

----- pull-quotes -----

from the party's ability to produce increased living

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 483

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →