Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Good luck, Andrew Neil!

Socialist Organiser no. 483, 18 April 1991 · scan p. 6 · about 457 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

IN HE fattersley... (Photo: John Harris)_ PRESIS-GANG DANY Jim Denham ike me, you have probably almost forgotten about the Peter Wright Spycatcher affair. A shambling old Australian with a big hat was very upset about being deprived of his pension from M15 and decided to write a book about the dirty deeds of the cloakand-dagger brigade.

Wright's revelations included the claim that Maurice Oldfield, the former head of MIS, had been a Russian agent. More interestingly, from our point of view, were his accounts of plots to discredit Harold Wilson and plans for military coups against the Wilson government.

When the Guardian and the Observer attempted to publish extracts from Wright's book in June 1986, the government immediately sent the Attorney General out to get "temporary" injunctions banning publication. In July 1987, co-inciding with the book's publication in America, the Sunday Times and the Independent both published extracts.

The two papers were promptly hauled up before the Law Lords who decided (by a 3-2 majority) that further possibly be in contempt of would court because the litigation against the Guardian and Observer had still not been settled.

It amounted to a holding" injunction, justified (in the words of the Law Lords) on grounds of the balance of convenience". To most people it looked more like a desperate attempt by the state to suppress embarrassing information. An element of farce was provided by the fact that the book was freely available in America and enterprising Arthur Daleytypes were selling it fairly openly in Britain.

Andrew Neil and Andreas Whittam-Smith huffed and puffed about "freedom of the press" but neither the ST nor the Independent published any more extracts. • Last week the Law Lords ruled that the Sunday Times and its editor were guilty of contempt in 1987. In effect, this means that all media organisations can be silenced by an injunction against just one paper. "Public interest" considerations were dismissed.

An identical decision by the Court of Appeal in 1987 banned all media coverage of a report into the West Midlands Serious Crime Squad by Walsall Council, after the Police Authority obtained an injunction against the Council.

The British reter wrignt made the neadlines in Spycatcher was banned much loved by us on the left. "Radical" Labour MPs can always be found to support any proposed legislation aimed at curbing various "excesses" *invasion of privacy"" "bias" , etc, etc.

The grievances are real enough. But the Spycatcher affair and this latest, outrageous, ruling should alert us to the need to defend "freedom of the press" even when that principle's champion takes the unattractive form of Mr Andrew Neil. I for one wish him well when he takes the case to the European Court of Human Rights.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 483

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →