Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

"The time that tries our souls"

Socialist Organiser no. 483, 18 April 1991 · scan pp. 3–5 · about 3,027 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

fought back, and, eventually, they won.

At the final surrender of the British Army to the victorious "planned" collectivist foundations Americans at Yorktown, the British of socialism had been laid. History Army hated chose tone an had gone further ahead in those appropriate tune, World Stalinist societies. They were "postTurned Upside Down". That is capitalist" what it was. Even some of those who insisted In our time the souls and minds that they were "state-capitalist" -of socialist men and women are notably Tony Cliff of the SWP being tried. The world of nevertheless believed that the conventional "socialism" has been Stalinist state-monopoly economies turned upside down and inside out. represented the furthest advance of Generations of socialists have capitalism. In this view, too, been repelled by the horrors Stalinism was on the high road of history — if not "post-capitalist", of capitalism then certainly "ultra-capitalist" exploitation and squalor in the Now it has been shown beyond metropolitan countries, its serious dispute by the events in the murderous cannibalism in the Third USSR and Eastern Europe that the World, its ineradicable drive to Stalinist social formations were reduce all life to pounds, dollars historic cul-de-sacs - not the and cents. highways but enormously wasteful For decades most of those who lost paths and byways of historic rebelled took as their model of an development. alternative to capitalism the Millions who believed themselves Stalinist states. to live in a partially socialist world Many even of those socialists now wake up to the truth that a who aimed only to rub the rough socialist world remains entirely to edges off capitalism, to reform it, be won. were influenced by Stalinist models. et, from the point of view of Most of those - Trotskyists Marx's ideas, in terms of the who bitterly criticised the Stalinist system and advocated working- real tradition of Lenin and class revolution there still believed Trotsky, all this is old truth. that in the Stalinist states the There was never good Marxist reason to believe that the Eastern Bloc represented either progress or "The-ensen socialism.

class is also the emancipation of all Lenin and Trotsky never believed human beings without distinction of that socialism could come from sex or race. isolated, backward, statified Karl Marx societies, developing in the wake of the advanced capitalist world under - Organiser the whip, the club and the gun of PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA merciless slavedriving dictators.

Newsdesk: 071 639 7965 They held to the basic idea of Inested nonseportsm wondar Marxists that socialism comes out Editor: John O'Mahony of and after advanced capitalism, Published by WL Publications Ltd, which paves the way for it, creating PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA the working class and preparing it Printed by Tridant Press, Edenbridge - by way of the class struggle - to Registered as a newspaper at the become the ruling class.

Post Office Socialism, Lenin and Trotsky knew and said, was impossible in Articles do not necessarily reflect the the USSR. What was possible was views of Socialist Organiser and are in that the workers could take power остинессм ineseeerwie there, and act as international Asia ted pioneers for revolution in the advanced capitalist countries were ripe for socialism.

The Russian workers took power, and fought off capitalist invasion and sabotage to hold it. The workers in France, Italy and Germany were defeated. The workers' republic was isolated. The Stalinist bureaucracy emerged around the state machine and, through a very bloody counterrevolution, displaced the working class as rulers. movement based on Everywhere the Russian Stalinists and those, in China and elsewhere, who followed their example, created slave states for the workers and farmers. That those societies represented workers' power, or socialism, or even real progress, was always an illusion. Now it is gone.

Now international capitalism celebrates its triumph. And American capitalism has celebrated the freedom it gained from the collapse of the pretensions of its imperialist competitor, the Ussk, by bombing Iraq back into the 19th century.

t is good that the poisonous illusions have gone or are going.

BIt is good for socialists - it is immense progress! - that those who rebel against capitalism should be forced to move in their minds from a world of delusions and pretences to the real world.

Socialism has lost nothing real. We have gained the beginning of emancipation from the crippling myths and lies which for decades did as much as the force and strength of capitalism ever did to derail the socialist movement.

In fact the ground is being cleared for the redevelopment of a real socialist movement based on the genuine ideas of Marx (and of Lenin and Trotsky too).

That does not make the collapse of the old "socialism" held to by so many any the less painful and disorienting now. The pain and disorientation is made all the more deep because the outright reformist currents of socialism in countries like Britain have also collapsed.

Neil Kinnock's Labour Party today does not even pretend to pay lip service to the goal of seriously reforming capitalism. The idea of replacing capitalism with something better is proscribable heresy in the Labour Party today. It is the same with similar movements elsewhere.

There is a common root to the T collapse and crisis of both the Stalinist and reformist wings of socialism: the power of the bourgeoisie.

On a world scale, they kept the advanced areas of the world economy and have successfully sat out" the Stalinist revolutions. In countries like Britain, even when the working class forced big reforms on them, they kept both the commanding heights of the economy and the power of the state machine (permanent civil service hierarchy, army, police, etc.) They have used them to take back reforms; Mrs Thatcher used the state power - the semi-militarised police deployed to beat down miners during their 1984-5 strike, for example — to defeat the labour movement.

But there was never any good reason, either, to believe that the reformists had secured permanent reforms, or the world of steady working-class progress within capitalism which some of them claimed to have won. The Marxists knew, and said, differently.

The long dominance of reformist and Stalinist socialism has led the working class to a series of great defeats and missed chances. Structural change in the working class itself has shaken up the traditional labour movement. In turn those changes have led superficial and ignorant people to claim that the working class itself is disappearing.

Capitalism cannot exist without a working class to exploit! The working class has undergone vast structural change time and again in its history: the workers who built history's first mass working-class weavers, cotton spinners, and similar people. Their descendants moved to different occupations; few of them changed their class position of being wage-labourers, To page 7 Advisory Green Bash Madlinic Dener TernysEegleton Jatin Haria (Labour Party Black Sections)

Eric Heffer MP Dorothym encou Der Marino bhn Microw John Nicholson Peter Tatchell Members of the Advisory Committee are draw in from orpada primit left who are opposed to the Labour Par is witch-hat against Social Organiser. Views expressed in articles are he responsi ilityrol the authorse no me thel Advisery Elitonial Board

Scan page 4

So what's this? a Sun scare-story about nasty, greedy unions threatening to eat babies and bring the nation to its knees. Nothing new about that, of course. Except th this time the chief culprit is the previously moderate EETPU electricians, where Eric Hammond is preparing Perhaps the Sun was trying to suggest that the imminent retirement of good old Hambo is the reason for the EETPU's terrifying change of character. If so, they couldn't be more wrong. Under Eric Hammond, th electricians regularly threatened industrial action over thi annual power industry pay claim. Usually they didn't have to deliver (the threat was usually sufficient to get a satisfactory result). But they were always deadly serious The reason is simple - too simple, perhaps, for the Sun and a good few people on the left, to grasp — the power workers are the EETPU's ace in the hole. Withou them the union would be virtually impotent and all the no-strike deals and single union arrangements in the world wouldn't persuade anyone (least of all potential. members) to take the EETPU seriously. Being seen to flex muscle and deliver the goods is more important for hardened, right-wing exponent of "business unionism" than it is for your run-of-the-mill TUC New Realist.

Thus it is that the EETPU has once again thrown down the gauntlet in pursuit of a "substantial" pay clai in the power industry. Members of the EETPU and the four other unions involved (GMB, TGWU, AEU and UCATT) have voted by 64% to 36% for all-out strike action if the employers don't increase their 8% offer And no-one campaigned harder for a strike vote than Bro. Hammond and the "scab" EETPU. The Sun can't understand it and neither can all those left-wingers who campaigned hard to get the electricians expelled from the TUC and who still (occasionally) call for the union to be "ostracised" from joint action with TUC affiliates... M sion of the EETPU also argued very strongly any of the same people who argued for the expulagainst the idea of a national minimum wage. I won't, here, go into the details of their case against the minimum wage as it is very difficult to do full justice to Enough to say that last week the TUC General Council threw its weight behind a proposal for public sector workers and major private-sector employees to have their wage settlements fixed on the basis of a "national assessment" at the start of every year. This is, to all intents and purposes, the scheme put forward last year John Edmonds of the GMB and Alan Tuffin of the The Independent on Sunday's City correspondent, Robert Preston, describes the plan as "a more creditable plan to provide a permanent cure to the particularly British economic illness than anything offered by the political parties or the CBI". Preston goes on to berate the Labour Party for clinging to the idea of a "national minimum wage, which would be inflationary"

It looks like the next big left vs right fight at the TUC will be between supporters ofthe Edmonds/Tuffin plan and supporters of a national minimum wage. There can be no doubting which side the left will be on — but will all those "left" opponents of the minimum wage now Organiser Renate Hurtgen of the IKG (Initiative of Critical Trade Unionists) in Eastern Berlin, gives a sober assessment of the trade union movement in East Germany in this he Sun newspaper interview with Angela Klein, likes the EETPU. INSIDE translated from the Cologne And with good newspaper Sozialistische reason: it was the THEE UNIONIS Zeitung. Instead of new scabbing and treachery of trade unions emerging there, the EETPU leaders that the hulk of the old ensured the success of government-run unions (the Rupert Murdoch's union- FDGB) has been taken over busting operation against by the West German-based the printers during the unions. move to Fortress Wapping. For a while, EETU general secretary Sleeper Eric Hammond became a Sun hero with his own nickname, 'Hambo' (geddit?), should perhaps mention that I draw my information from weekly or twice-weekly meetings with up to 60 colleagues from East and West. to retire as leader".

Over a period of many weeks a certain picture emerges, but no detailed empirical proof of what I'll say.

The first activities here by the Western trade unions, strikes in refuse collection, etc., were received with great enthusiasm: "The Western unions know how to do this about it. sort of thing" . The mood did not last, however.

In the Berlin district committee of the DGB I now hear worried voices: the members in the East are running away, they are leaving or not joining.

There are not only political reasons for this development; the trade unions also are not getting -to grips with it organisationally. One example: in the Charité a big hospital in East Berlin) a large group of workers wanted to join, six months ago. The union was not in a before midnight on 24 April. position to collect membership contributions other than standing order through the bank. The workers, however, still did not have bank accounts.

The union made such a bureaucratic fuss, and despite that found no proper way to collect the contributions, that the 50 or 60 people involved said: thanks very much, we won't join then.

There are also justified exvery stupid line of argument. pressions of dissatisfaction because the Western unions obviously have no programme at all for the unemployed. My impression is that it is mostly workers on short time who are leaving UCW, for a new "Social Contract". the number of members from There is a figure given for the FDGB [the old East German state-run unions] which have come over to the new unions - 60 per cent. That is, however, a few weeks old, and in the district committee T'vé been told that no-one has an overview..

There is a second indication. The unions need a certain income from the membership to be able to operate. Because wages are so admi tha. ihey were wrong? low here, not enough comes in. Even the per percent is not enough to keep the union apparatus in the East going. I start from the assumption, however, that the per percent figure is not accurate.

The colleagues in the workplaces report unanimously that the unions, to their astonishment, have put more initiatives into the building of works council structures than into shop stewards structures. With us, of course, the system used to be different; the union with its workplace union leaderships was built up in close relation with the enterprise. That is no longer the case. The workforce, however is not informed about the new structure.

It cannot all be blamed on the bureaucracies. It also goes together_ with a widespread trade union weariness, at least as regards people being ready to take on functions.

There are just about people for the works council, because it brings a certain job protection which trade union functions do not. Relating to the trade unions as service organisations, which exists in the. West too, is much more evident here.

After the FDGB congress at the end of January last year it was obvious to everyone that it was no longer viable. The DGB [German TUC] used the neat formulation, with raised eyebrows: "The FDGB no longer corresponds to our criteria"

So the single trade unions [ie. Western unions extending to the East, forming single West-and-East organisations] got going. They went to the former functionaries, the reform-minded ones of course. Those were then properly schooled in the direction of works council activity.

I know umpteen people from our former work as *Initiative for independent trade unions" who previously had tried to build groups outThe homeless of Liepzig Harry Tisch, the former leader of the FDGB. Tisch's conspicuous spending of union funds on his own lifestyle symbolised the corruption of the state-run union federation side the FDGB - many have gone into the works councils. That was apparently true across the board.

To be sure, most of the old functionaries have been taken over by IG Chemie [the Western-based chemical workers' union].

The results in the workplaces vary. It depends on the personal integrity of such functionaries.

What I heard about it is filtered through the fact that the people who come to us and give us information are critically engaged. They are, of course, disappointed, and say:. the works councils do what the workplace union leaderships [of the old state unions] did before, and they are more oriented to the interests of the management than to those of the workforce.

But since it is a selection of people who come to us, I'm not sure how widespread this opinion is.

A mixture has developed in the apparatus. The setting-up of the higher structures is not yet complete. They still lack people for it.

The cleverest of the bureaucrats already have the legitimate feeling that using only the Westerners won't work, they lack the overview; they still need few with "East-feeling"

To generalise, you can say: most work is put into the development of administration and of works councils, while the workforce and local levels of unions are still nonexistent.

That, of course, also shows that the unions do not rest on a specially powerful rank and file, but on a rank and file which is resigned to things coming from above.

I don't accept that we've had more success than the left in the West. I'd like to say something about this. It's not a matter of an abstract principle, and a lamentation about the fact that the rank and file is taken into account too little.

1 believe that if the Western unions, with their classical view of themselves, do not abandon their anxiety about rank and file activity, then they will fall flat on their faces.

Take the silly business I mentioned earlier about the union contributions. Their organisational structure does not even function in a society where, for example, bank standing orders are unknown. That is beginning.

And it is beginning in an industrial situation where it is more a matter of sackings than of a distribution of the enterprise's profits: such structures simply don't get a grip any more.

[The interviewer said: However, the strikes, demonstrations, perhaps also workplace occupations, in the last period have been led by the unions..."] I'm not quite sure about the workplace occupations. There are various indications that these activities have partly bypassed the unions.

For example, the works councils marching to the Treuhand [the government agency for privatising the East German economyl was

Scan page 5

NE niser No

----- pull-quotes -----

"In fact the ground is being cleared for the redevelopment of a real socialist

the genuine ideas of Marx (and of Lenin and Trotsky too"

movement, the British Chartists of the 1830s and '40s, were handloom

s final flex Ham

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 483

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →