Where is the SWP going?
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-04-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
essentially arguments about how dif- As it was, the war shook many Arab ferent sets of capitalists are to main- governments. A longer ground war, tain their profits. It should not be our which could have been waged by a concern to argue one way or the other, genuinely revolutionary army rather for either way the profits are made at than demoralised conscripts, could The breathing space prov- in any SW publication today ided by the presence of Brit- In the latest issue of Ser ish troops is short but vital. Barie-they demonstrate the content of their Those who call for the imm- anti-imperialism. During the Iran-Iraq war Khoediate withdrawal of the their death by the use of the "huntert tave'. Is troops before the men behind this what they mean by "flexible tactics'?
Martin Thomas reviews the history of the Socialist Workers' Party.
The events of the 1980s, and the collapse of Stalinism in Eastern Europe especially, have shattered illusions on which much of the left has nourished itself for decades.
The left must rethink, reorient, rediscover habits of serious debate. This article makes a start by looking at the ideas of the Socialist Workers' Party, the largest faction on the left.
In the '50s and early '60s the Cliff faction, the group which would take the name SWP in early 1977, was very different from what it is today. It had a coherent (though false) picture of the post-war world.
Western capitalism had achieved stable expansion through the "permanent arms economy": permanent high military spending kept the economies permanently pumped up. The arms race also defined the nature of the USSR: it was state-capitalist because of the "competitive accumulation" forced on it by the arms race.
Third World revolutions would create new state-capitalist systems. Those revolutions would not bring progress, nor were they a threat to capitalism. Imperialism had been the "highest stage but one" of capitalism, in the words of a famous article published in 1962. It was finished: it had been replaced by the permanent arms economy.
The economic function of imperialism, so the Cliffites argued, had been to provide fields for investment of the excess capital of the metropolitan countries, and now the arms economy did that instead.
Much of this argument was in point-bypoint counterposition to the ideas of the so-called "orthodox Trotskyists" (mainly the groups that would become Gerry Healy's WRP and Militant). The Cliffites were not Trotskyists, not even unorthodox ones. "Trotskyism" they said, pointing to the Healy faction, meant dogmatism, crisismongering, and a fetish of "leadership" Nor were they Leninists. Again, they pointed to the Healy faction. "Leninism" meant intolerance, rigidity, the building of bureaucratically-run sects with ridiculous pretensions.
As events unfolded, and as the Cliff faction grew, it changed its view of the world — not by critically revising it, but by abandoning it piecemeal.
Not only did it quit the Labour Party: within a few years its arguments on the Labour Party were so dismissive as to make a nonsense of everything it did in the '50s and most of the '60s.
In 1968 it suddenly went "Leninist". It made no theoretical reappraisal: in effect, all it did was decide that the emphasis on building an "alternative" organisational machine which (when small and in no position to do such a thing itself it had long derided in the Healy faction was now opportune for the Cliff faction itself.
Whatever was good about its attempt to understand the world less dogmatically than the so-called orthodox" , and its accurate perception that the USSR was no workers' or post-capitalist state, was outweighed by its basic approach to politics and theory. Throughout, both in its "anti-Leninist" and its "Leninist" phases, the Cliff faction leadership has rejected Lenin's approach of fighting first for political clarity, and organising round that political clarity. Instead it has made the building of organisational strength primary, and treated ideas as things to be used, manipulated, or discarded accordingly.
In late 1971 the Cliff faction moved decisively to shut down its internal democracy by expelling the faction round Workers' Fight and instituting new rules which permitted opposition factions only as episodic groups around single issues (i.e. which outlawed across-the-board opposition).
The expulsion of the so-called *Right Opposition" (the grouping which would later Labour Lahour Worker business is good Bullding worker 1ay newages to our expense.
DEFEND the BARRICADES
the barricades can defend themselves are inviting pogrom which will hit first and hardest at socialists.
spawn the RCP and RCG) followed in 1973; the expulsion of further oppositions in 1975 and the late "70s. Since then criticism or dissent inside the SWP has been confined to tentative bleats by small groups, and, more recently, it would seem, not even that.
Is it has drawn down the shutters on debate, the SWP has also adopted an increasingly sectarian attitude to the labour movement.
The two developments are linked. In the early "70s it prided itself on building rank-and-file groups in the trade unions, on a militant bread-and-butter basis. It started to argue that the economic difficulties of capitalism were ending reformism's room for reforms and thus creating the conditions for the rapid rise in the working class of an alternative to the Labour Party.
"The 'rank and file' groups were shut down. Over a decade of operating in the labour movement only as a propagandist sect, effectively trying to build the SWP's own parallel labour movement, has followed."
It talked itself into an increasing ultramilitancy which, around 1975, lost it most of the trade unionists it had recruited in the early "70s. It then reoriented not by criticising its own underestimation of the power of reformism (a power which does not collapse automatically even when reformism offers no positive reforms), but by deciding that the working class had gone into a "downturn". The "rank and file" groups were shut down; over a decade of operating in the labour movement only as a propagandist sect, effectively trying to build the SWP's own parallel labour movement, has followed.
By now most SWP members have for The much less well equipped Iranians proved more effective fighters. In part this was because, even in distorted Islamic form, the mobilising impulse of the 1978-9 Revolution allowed far more scope for initiative and the use of flexible tactics. Only Iraqi air superiority and Western military and economic support made possible Saddam's eventual victory over Iran.
It is don that Sod lam d have hit the region like a political earthquake.
TUC - The fundam The zigzags of the Sacialist Valikers rait miner December 1966, "defertet on the question of the Commer-Farket. Bef 1971 dey had, under pressure from the-fP-and Labour Party left, chaaged to opposing Britain's entry into the EC.
In September 1969 they refused to call for the withdrawal oweritish troops trom Northern Ireland. You will find no reference to this policy meini sent hundreds of thousands of troops to perience at all of work in the labour movement aimed at convincing people and winning majorities. They have as little debate — as distinct from slogan-spouting - with other currents in the labour movement as they have within their own ranks.
The "permanent arms economy" theory T was essentially a version of the Keynesian strand of academic economic thinking, according to which capitalism had crises because of insufficient market demand, and increased state spending could overcome those crises.
It added only that the state spending would be military spending, because competition between capitalist states forced them into such military spending.
When Keynesian economics floundered in the 1970s — because increased state spending was bringing only inflation and worse economic crisis - the "permanent arms economy" theory floundered too. Expositions of the theory had always included vague assurances that the "permanent arms economy" could not stabilise capitalism for ever — for example, the level of military spending imposed by international competition might not be the desired level for stability — but the attempts made to explain the slumps of the 1970s on the basis of those reassurances were increasingly desultory. Two attempts were made to reformulate the "permanent arms economy" theory in "Marxist" terms, and then the theory was quietly abandoned.
he idea that imperialism had been the "highest stage but one" of capitalism, now ended, was also quietly abandoned. Here as elsewhere, the SWP did not criticise and revise consciously and deliberately. Instead, it drifted slowly into adopting the "anti-imperialist" conventional wisdom of the "orthodox" Trotskyists which it had once derided.
By a process of sliding from another, that conventional wisdom viewed anything clashing with the imperialism of the US and its allies — even such petty imperialism as Saddam Hussein's grab for Kuwait - as anti-imperialist, hence progressive and indeed likely to become socialist if pursued militantly enough. The Cliff faction once stood very far from such ideas. Gradually, however, it has drifted into them. —In 1967 it defined the Israeli Jews as a "nafional minority" in the Middle East who should have the same rights as, for example, the Kurds. "The only possible solution to the needs of the Middle East is the workers' and peasants' revolution aimed at the establishment of a socialist republic, with full rights for Jews, Kurds and all national minorities" (Tony Cliff, The Struggle in the Middle East). Now it insists vehemently, indeed hysterically, that progress in the Middle East can come only by the conquest of Israel.
As late as 1982 the SWP had essentially the same line on the South Atlantic war as Socialist Organiser. It opposed the war on both sides, Britain and Argentina, and rejected the argument that Argentina must be supported as "anti-imperialist" . By 1988 the SWP was supporting Iran against Iraq on the grounds that US aid to Iraq made Iran's war "anti-imperialist"; by 1990 it was backing Saddam Hussein because the confrontation with the US caused by his invasion of Kuwait must make him "play an anti-imperialist role"
he thesis that the USSR is "state capitalist" seems to be the one element of the Cliff faction's old world-view which it has maintained.
Even there the continuity is more apparent than real. Cliff's original version of "statecapitalist" theory (in 1947) considered the USSR's economic organisation to represent the highest stage of capitalism. It was the highest stage — abruptly arrived at because of the workers' revolution in Russia - of the increasing subordination of all capitalist economies to state-directed military expansion (the "permanent arms economy").
That "state-capitalist" theory was inseparable from the "permanent arms economy" theory and could not stand without it.
The rise of Stalinist states outside the USSR which visibly were not regulated economically by arms competition made this thesis dubious long ago. So did the collapse of the "permanent arms economy" theory. The downfall of Stalinism in Eastern Europe demonstrates that Stalinism is not the "highest stage" of capitalism but a primitive stage of capitalism, or parallel to capitalism.
Instead of criticising and revising the *state-capitalist" thesis, the SWP gradually trimmed away from it all the specific content which Cliff gave it in 1947, and reduced it to a mere label, nothing more than the assertion that the Stalinist systems are no better than capitalism. Thus on Eastern Europe, despite its loud boasts of being vindicated, the SWP has had very little to say other than that the change there should not be exaggerated and the free market is no cure-all.
So: some aspects of the old world-view have just been abandoned (the "permanent arms economy"), some maintained in hollowed-out form ('state capitalism'"), and others replaced piecemeal by ideas from the Cliff faction's opponents within the left (on imperialism and anti-imperialism, and on Leninism).
A printing press, an established public profile, a core of loyal activists, and the general socialist ideas which are the common stock of all the left groups, provide enough momentum to keep a political group going for a good while whatever its ideological problems. Yet in the long run a revolutionary group cannot derive sustenance only from inertia: it must win a place by providing some more or less coherent view of how the world is, where it is going, what forces will change it, and how the group itself stands in relation to all that.
The SWP no longer has view. In that sense it is moribund.
Scan page 13
We fight tke see at Knowstadk Film Lister Johnson" is about a casualty of Empire.It's the story of a black man who not only had his country colonised by the British, but his mind too.
Set in British West Africa in 1923, the story begins with Johnson in his post as government clerk to Judge Harry Rudbeck. Though none too competent, Johnson is obsequious enough to hang on to his job. He doesn't shrink from even the most shameless flattery as a way of keeping his post.
For his job is his badge of pride; he glories in it. He considers himself ynda La Plante's Prime Suspect (ITV) shows what a talented writer, producer, director and actors can do with the worn and over-used murder hunt format.
It also shows you what the cop opera format can do to a talented writer, etc.
The story interweaves a hunt for a murderer of young women with internal police polities: the cop in charge is a woman. Detective Chief Inspector Jane Tennison. That is the show's gimmick.
She has to light to ge a job no woman has done before. she gets it only after the man first put in charge drops dead.
Her colleagues harry and undermine her, unable to cope with a woman in charge: witnesses talk through her and over her head to her male subordinates.
She has a hard time. The cliches of the police show drag her down too: her partner can't take the strain.
But things come right. Reader, Wins Their Respect! an Englishman, believing that his white suit and his solar topee are enough to make him "one of them""
He's wrong, of course. The whites lump him in with all the other "natives"; they don't even hesitate to cut him loose when it suits them. But even betrayal doesn't dent Johnson's fantasies about the English. To the end, he wants them for his friends, and all his ambitions are focussed on them. He yearns more than anything to belong.
Yet he belongs nowhere. EndlessLy caught between the black culture he rejects, and the white culture that rejects him, he's a misfit, an outcast.
Johnson should inspire pity in the audience, yet somehow he fails to. It's partly his endless, off-putting subservience to the whites that alienates; it's hard to watch someone abase himself so completely.
Soon it is "Yes, boss" and "No. guy 'nor" and "the team" of happy clean-limbed young cops is clicking away • like a football team in good morale. The Manageress, in fact.
At the end, the chorus of cops burst into song for her! It is a sort of "For she's a jolly good fellow" song. But a song was what was needed at that point!
soviets e is dave TOURTON But there is more to it than that.
Johnson is really so deluded, so deep into his fantasy that he is unreachable. He shuts us out. We can't get inside his head to see what drives him, so we end up not caring all that much.
This is a great failing in the film, because Johnson is the central character, someone we need to care about if we're to care for the film.
—Yet we're deliberately kept at arm's length. There's no reason given for Johnson's dream of being white; he's like that when we meet him and he's like that at the end, a true and fervent believer in a crazy creed.
The film meanders and feels too slow all through. Characters appear but they're rarely pulled into focus. Even the ones who should register — Bamu, Johnson's uncomprehending wife, and Rudbeck, his ultimately compassionate employer If at that point they had sung variations on "Rose Marie" - the silly old stage and film musical about the Royal Canadian Mounted Police - 1 would not have been surprised - "Oh Tennison, we love you, we're always dreaming of you... * Or the Mountie song: "Give me some men who are stout-hearted men..
Hasander!
hansoming chas 958 5U019 don't make much of an impact.
The forces shaping Johnson's world are also left vague. Rudbeck is trying to build a road to encourage more trade in the area. He is opposed by the local Emir, who worries about losing control. Both of these powers impact on Johnson, who tries to balance between the two, but the issues are never made clear. Rudbeck's wife does ask whom the road building will benetit, but the question is deliberately left rhetorical.
The film is trying to expose colonialism and colonial attitudes. It tries to show the blinkered assumptions of the whites, yet also reveal the calcutations of black leaders like the Emir who did not have the best interests of the majority at Yet it's all rather limp and uninvolving, as if the good intentions the filmmakers set out with simply wilted in the blazing African sun. I The programme-makers ased dead. mutilated or decomposing female corpses as horrifying stage props rather too casually and too often throughout the two-part film. This ugly sensationalism went very badly with the blatant chocolate-box unrealism of the "Rose Marie of the Met" scenario and treatment.
Their cam fio sal the ice an SSAGE a41 ALLowin I he give Taina 1L-0ce Paul McGarry reviews When Saturday Come the alternative football magazine When Saturday Comes, the azine has recently published its 50th issue. That's quite an achievement. Most similar ventures run out of steam after a year or so.
When Saturday Comes is the best of the football fanzines, the unofficial publications that have mushroomed in the last few years.
Each club has at least one fanzine produced by its dedicated supporters, many with the selfmocking wit (a regular feature of the fanzine) most evident in their "Mission , eg Impossible" or Slough titles, Torquay United has Town, "Rebels without a clue".
Present favourites, however; are Chester's "Hello Albert" and Bradford Park Avenue's "Aye aye, Rhubarb Pie". I only hope the content lives up to the names. There are a number of general fanzines too of which When Saturday Comes is the best known.
The success of When Saturday Comes — it is professionally produced and has a large number of outlets - comes from its humorous, perceptive and critical approach. The April issue carries articles on the recent Commons report on football hooliganism, and a rejoinder to the homophobia and racism now making an appearance in some of the fanzines.
When Saturday Comes also carries a wide range of satirical pieces and a lively letters page. Its strength comes from the fact that it is written for the fan by the fan. It reflects the interests that the genuine supporter has.
As its lead explains, *the prime motivation behind the creation of When Saturday Comes was to express discontent at British football's persistently appalling treatment of its most important asset, the fans."
That discontent, high prices, poor facilities, the apparent lack of interest that most clubs have in the wishes of their fans, has manifested itself in other ways too.
The Football Supporters' Association (FSA) organises fans across the country and played an important role in the above mentioned Commons report. The recent and ongoing shambles that is passing as soccer management at Tottenham generated the Tottenham Independent Supporters' Association. And recently Preston supporters expressed their anger by occupying the pitch.
These examples show a healthy development in "the people's game". The fans want more say in how their clubs are run, want more information on how the directors invest the profits they have generated.
They want more consultation on the design and range of facilities. Socialists can only welcome such a yearning. When Saturday Comes has played an invaluable role in this movement "from below" ', here's to the next fifty!
Get WSC from Fourth Floor, 2 Pear Tree Court, London ECTR ODS.
When Saturday Gore os WSC 3SHn00 3109 10 394003
Scan page 14
Disease threatens lives of m refugees around the world.
Scuds or butter ser
----- pull-quotes -----
= EUROPE «BOSSES' -FIGHT, NOT OURS 2-
These arguments for and against entry into the Common Market art