Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The start of Czechoslovakia's small privatisation"

Socialist Organiser no. 482, 11 April 1991 · scan pp. 11–12 · about 1,378 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

slovak government's aclav Havel's new Czechoplans for property are divided into four parts: * The "restitutión" - returning property to former owners, * The "small privatisation" - an auction of about 100,000 shops and services to Czechoslovak citizens, * The break-up of the collective farms, * The "large privatisation" — selling off of state enterprises to foreign capital, with some limited coupon scheme for the population.

The small privatisation started with 16 auctions in Prague on 26-27 January 1991. The restitution process threatens to re-allocate many small shops and enterprises earmarked for the small privatisation. However, nothing is to be allowed to delay the small privatisation, which is an important symbol for the government.

The small privatisation, along with the coupon distribution in the large privatisation, is to be the population's share in a deal largely conducted between the bureaucracy and foreign capital (the large privatisation). For example, 10% of Slovak petrol pumps will be sold or leased to citizens, 40% sold or leased to foreign companies, and the rest maintained, by the present bureaucratic enterprise!.

he privatisation of a large number of enterprises generates a lot of cash. Where does this money go? It does not go to the enterprise previously owning the privatised unit. The money raised is controlled by the Ministries for National Property and Privatisation. These bodies use the money raised first of all to pay themselves.

Official statements suggest, at some point in the future, the transfer of a part of the funds to act as a state guarantee on loans to private entrepreneurs. At the moment, however, the money is simply paying the day-to-day expenses of a growing section of the bureaucracy.

Emigre economist, Milan Zeleny argues that the privatisation "drains away capital from the entrepreneurial sphere, where it is needed, to the state coffers where it ALLAN Slow road to the free market completely useless**2 It is indeed interesting to note that the Czech Privatisation Ministry has always been vehemently against any lease of enterprises to private entrepreneurs, a measure which could have enabled a much wider participation in private enterprise, and the accumulation of small amounts of private capital, but which would of course have raised less money for the state.

The local bureaucratic/mafia groupings managed to exclude their enterprises from the privatisation in several ways.

One enterprise even applied for exception from the privatisation on the grounds that they were intending to transfer the workshops in question to a collective of disabled people.

Many enterprises quickly took on apprentices, since enterprises where apprentices worked could not be included in the first round of the privatisation process.

Some enterprises or workplaces unilaterally declared themselves to be state joint-stock companies. This was not a movement for workers' self-management, even if it was supported by workers opposed to private enterprise. It was a legalistic manoeuvre of the managers alone. There is no evidence of workers taking action they saw as defending their enterprises against privatisation, such as barring entry to valuers, prospective buyers, or new "owners"

Many of these "independence" declarations have been ruled illegitimate by the privatisation ministry. Only the ministry has the right to create state joint-stock companies, the legal form into which a bureaucratic enterprise must be transformed before shares in it can be sold.

Many local governments opposed privatisation of services under their control, in some cases virtually boycotting the privatisation commissions. auctions were not usually he main winners at the present. These winners were certain groupings in the bureaucracy-mafia, whose gains are measured in terms of the number of enterprises they managed to exclude from the privatisation. The mafia Bush spins a yarn to Vaclav Havel now has several months to find a way of removing its favourite smaller enterprises from the open privatisation process altogether.

As a result of all these manoeuvres, the district privatisation commissions* and ministry have demanded, and will certainly receive, greater powers to overrule and defeat opposition from enterprises and employees to their work in the tuture.

The small privatisation so far is hardly a victory for the nascent Czech bourgeoisie. The tirst 16 enterprises auctioned in Prague brought in some ten times their starting price. This seems due both to their central Prague location, their nature (including antique and clothing shops) and their low starting price..

Given such prices, it is not surprising that only one enterprise passed into the hands of an independent Czech entrepreneur not acting as an agent for a foreign interest . Some foreign residents operated through Czechoslovak agents, while some, mainly Viennese, foreign entrepreneurs of 11 Mi Czechoslovak birth, were able to buy openly. Ordinary citizens were quite simply unable to compete financially.

iberals, even left supporters -oke deputy a pr director one the state press agency (CIK) Petr Uhl, have centred their defence ot the government around the necessity - to break up the bureaucratic monopoly over retail?.

It is however already clear that private sector interest is in restaurants and city-centre shops. In a large majority of auctions of food shops away from the centre of Prague, only one or two bidders take part in the auctions® The most plausible reduction in price and increase in service for the working population comes not from Uhl's corner grocer, but from the west-European supermarket chains. The Czech Commerce Ministry has long been negotiating with the aim of withdrawing some 10% of food shops from the small privatisation for sale direct to those western buyers able to give certain guarantees.

Stepova's openness provoked government concern, but there has been no theoretical challenge to her assertion that such a move to foreign domination of the retail system "is inevitable sooner or later, and we just wanted (with our plan) to save the population time and money"9 Given the crisis in the food retail system, many suppliers have started selling a part of their produce direct, from stalls or lorries. Despite the appearance of chaos, this trend may be forcing some retailers to drop their prices!?.

he small privatisation was originally conceived, against the opposition of the Klaus clique, as a protected redistribution of national property to an emerging middle-class layer, of citizens.

Different variants of this scheme allowed for collectives of employees to have the right to purchase or lease their workplace before it was placed on the market, or for cooperatives of citizens to form with the aim of taking over village services, or other enterprises of their choosing.

However, with the growing alignment of the bureaucratic centre to international capital, its desire to create large private capital at the expense of small, and its hostility to any kind of collective ownership, have increased. The small privatisation project has been assimilated closer and closer to the large privatisation.

On an ideological level too, the introduce people to the hard reality of the large privatisation, in which private individuals will be almost completely excluded.

The bureaucracy will get its injection of cash from the liquidation of national property. The Czech ministry of privatisation, along with Vaclav Klaus's federal finance ministry, will continue to grow in power. Their tight control of the destatisation process will continue to strengthen the legitimacy of their "white communism"

There will indeed be some sort of private sector, though so far only in commerce and services. What there will not be is any real introduction of competition and price competition among the shops ordinary people use. The cheapest food will continue to be that you buy off the back of a lorry.

Ecoservice No.22, November 30.

Ceske noviny, 30.1.1991.

Czech Privatisation Minister, Tomas Jezek, interviewed in Mlada fronta dnes, 31.1.1991.

These commissions, each of 15-20 members, were named by the minister. According to one report among them are lawyers, economic workers. entrepreneurs, someone from the town council, town-owned enterprises. and someone from a bank or savings bank". (Jiri Leschtina, Mlada fronta dnes, 31.1.1991.

Ecoservice, No.20, 29.1.1991.

This claim came from Vlasta Stepova. Czech Minister of Commerce and Tourism, quoted in Rude pravo. 31.1.1991.

See Interview de Petr Uhl: la situation dans le forum civique, interview by Slavyna and Adam Novak, 21.1.199. Ecoservice, No.23, 13.2.1991.

Zemedelske noviny, 24.1.199T.

See my "New behaviour of food producers and retailers", Ecoservice. 5.2.1991.

Scan page 12

Organiser

----- pull-quotes -----

soft, acceptable option of the small privatisation has served to

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 482

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →