Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

By their heroes ye shall know them

Socialist Organiser no. 482, 11 April 1991 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 1,605 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

TIDE Sean Matgamna This year's markedly muted celebrations in Dublin to mark the 75th anniversary of the Easter Rising, and of the martyrdom before the British firing squads in Dublin and on the gallows in Pentonville Jail of the founders of the Catholic Irish state, reminded me how starkly people, classes and nations may change their heroes.

From Lenin to Yeltsin is a long way down... The descent from Wolfe Tone to lan Paisley is even longer and steeper. In Britain it isn't "mainstream" any more to think much of the World War 2 heroes whose very stiff-upper-lip exploits held our attention for a generation after the war, filling the movie screens, books of memoirs, novels and boys' comics. In part this change is the natural result of the distance that comes with the passing of time and of generations.

"Pagan myth and Christian myth were merged and fused with ancient and modern history - and with the histor of Christianity, in which the frish have played and play a big part - to create a powerful messianic Catholic Irish nationalism. "

Of a different order is the changing public attitude in the Twenty Six Counties to "the names that stilled our childish play" - the heroes of Catholic Ireland's struggles for independence in the first quarter of the 20th century. This is icon-smashing with a vengeance! The blind, panicky vengeance of Ireland's huckster bourgeoisie, to be exact.

For many decades they endorsed and propagated a version of the story of Ireland's unequal contest with England, burnished into a splendid epic legend. The long halfforgotten myths of ancient pre-Christian Ireland — such as the story of the young champion Cucullain - were rediscovered, refurbished, and woven into the fabric of living history by men like Padraig Pearse. They took heroes like Cucullain, the great warrior who died on his feet, having tied himself to a tree to face his foes, his wounds staunched with moss, and Jesus Christ in Gethsemane and on the cross, as their inspiration for the lives they expended in political action.

Pagan myth and Christian myth were merged and fused with ancient and modern history — and with the history of Christianity, in which the Irish have played and play a big part — to create a powerful messianic Catholic Irish nationalism. And, naturally, Irish nationalism also drew into itself much from the currents of romantic nationalism with which Europe was saturated for the first half of this century.

And whose history was this? What A had all this struggle led to? To the rule of the miserable Twenty Six Counties' own pocket bourgeoisie — who lived on after their apotheosis as exporters of farm produce, and exporters, too, of generation after generation of Ireland's young!

As we used to say, arguing for socialism, anything less than the Workers' Republic was a grim mockery of the long struggle of the common people of Ireland embodied in our history, and represented even in the mythological version of it. The Ireland of the bourgeoisie was a grim mockery indeed.

In fact, it was never their history. All, that should be said about the true worth of the bourgeoisie and of their ancestors in the struggle of the great mass of the disinherited Irish people was said by one of the Jacobin "United Irishmen" leaders, Henry Joy McCracken, 200 years ago: "The rich always betray the poor"

So they did. So they do. Immediately after the 1916 Rising, which was to become the keystone of the Irish bourgeoisie's myth of its own origin, the Dublin Chamber of Commerce passed a "loyal" resolution denouncing the Rising and branding it as a form of "Larkinism" (the name then of Irish working-class militancy, which had fought the bosses to a standstill in an eight month industrial conflict in 1913-14).

After most of the 1916 leaders had already been shot, the Irish Independent - today the organ of Fine Gael, one of the two main Irish parties - editorialised to encourage the British military authorities to go ahead and shoot the badly wounded "Larkinite" James Connolly. They had scores to settle It was never really their history: only the myths were theirs, and they gloried in them, preening themselves, dressing up like baboons who have broken into a theatrical prop room.

The disgusted pseudo-aristocrat Yeats, believing in noblesse oblige, had got their measure during the 1913 lock-out and strike, when they starved the workers and their children in an attempt to break their union. What need you, being come to sense But fumble in a greasy till And add the halfpence to the pence And prayer to shivering prayer until You have dried the marrow from the For man was born to pray and save; Romantic Ireland's dead and gone, It's with O'Leary in the grave.

It was a sort of warning to them. And then, when the war of independence was over, and the bourgeoisie had seized control over the popular mass movement, divided and suppressed it, and assured their own rule behind the legal and ethical walls of the Catholic state they built - then, in safety, they could indulge themselves, not noticing the incongruities Yeats pointed to so bitterly.

ifty years or so it lasted. And then the -North blew up. The official CatholicIrish myth had it that "the North" was -just a matter of British imperialism and "British-occupied" Ireland, nothing to do with the other Irish bourgeoisie, the one enmeshed in the collapsing myths of the British Empire, and the Northern farmers and workers who followed them.

It had no grip on reality. Neither had the Irish bourgeoisie. Their interest in Northern Ireland collapsed, and so did their myths.

Perhaps the moment of sobering up came in 1970 when Prime Minister Jack Lynch put two of his Cabinet ministers (one of them the present Prime Minister, Charles J Haughey) and an Army officer, Captain Kelly, on trial for "gun-running" to the beleaguered Northern Catholics! (They were acquitted). According to the Constitution Lynch was pledged to defend, the Six Counties was part of his government's "national territory". It still is, officially.

"Like the Irish bourgeoisie for so long, many socialists have lived for decades in a world of inappropriate myth and misunderstood reality. too has collapsed.

But Lynch didn't believe it. The bourgeoisie didn't either. Like the sobered adolescent whose day-dreaming has brought him close to disaster, they turned tail and extravagantly repudiated their former view of themselves. Now Romantic Ireland really was Liberty Hall, Dublin, 1916. This is the headquarters of the Irish Transport and General Workers' Union, and of its military offshoot, the Irish Citizen Army (seen in the photograph). The Army began in 1913 as a strikers' army to stop the Dublin police breaking the heads of striking workers.

James Connolly, acting general secretary of thi ITGWU, led the Citizen Army into the Easter Monday uprising to win independence from Britain in an all-Ireland Republic. Connolly, badly wounded, was shot propped up in a chair on 12 May 1916.

Thereafter the nationalist segment of the Irish labour movement was taken in tow by middle class nationalists. The labour movement had long been divided on Green and Orange, Nationalist dead and gone. It has been succeeded by an age of the cold revision of history. Like pikes and guns, heroes such as Pearse and Connolly had been found to be dangerous things. They have been cut down to size.

The Irish bourgeoisie has finally adapted to reality!

From Pearse and Connolly to the grasping millionaire CJ Haughey — a son of Catholic refugees driven south by pogromists in the early "20s — and his rival, Fine Gael understudy Blue-shirt Bruton, that is the history of the modern Irish bourgeoisie in a nutshell! It is a long, long way down. This Easter's commemoration service sums it up nicelyLike the Irish bourgeoisie for so long, many socialists have lived for decades in a world of inappropriate myth and misunderstood reality. That too has collapsed. and Unionist, lines (the majority of the Irish working class was Unionist not Nationalist).

The southern Irish labour movement played a big role in the war of independence, as soldiers and organisers of political strikes.

In early 1919 striking workers organised a soviet in Limerick city, and for a while controlle parts of the city, issuing travel permits, even printing their own money!

But the Irish labour movement, crippled and inhibited by its own divisions along Unionist/ Nationalist lines, did not play the politically independent role it might have played.

The Ireland they wound up "serving" was a bourgeois Ireland, which is not what James Connolly and his comrades had fought to win.

In Ireland, those who know what Pearse and Connolly and the Fenians and their predecessors really stood for will disentangle it from the bourgeois collapse, as they disentangled it from the grotesque parodies of it the bourgeoisie used to brandish.

And in the world of international socialism, the serious revolutionaries will disentangle the true socialism — working class liberation - from the Stalinist and other myths, fantasies and alien ideological encrustations. We will continue to do now, when so much has collapsed, what we did in the days when all sorts of freaks and horrors paraded around the world eagerly proclaiming their own horrible deeds to be the essence of socialism.

In both cases the collapse of the debilitating and imprisoning myths and fantasies is good because the way is thereby cleared for the truth.

Scan page 11

4sset-stripping in Eastern Europe Socialist Organiser No. 482 page 11

----- pull-quotes -----

WE SERVE NEITHER KING NOR KATSER BUT IRELANDI

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 482

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →