Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

"Things stronger than parliamen

Socialist Organiser no. 482, 11 April 1991 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 1,321 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

"There are things stronger than Parliamentary majorities", said Ireland far outweighed the damage that would probably Conservative Party leader, Andrew Bonar Law, as he campaignet For the Conservatives, unlike some Labour Party leaders, obe- was defeated in the House of Lords - and a third in 1! dience to laws made by Parliament has never been absolute. If the Lords' power to block legislation permanently had i they can secure their interests in accordance with Parliamentary removed. The Liberals depended on Irish Nationalist Ma formalities, well and good; if not, they will use other means.

That would certainly be true if a socialist majority were elected fo Parliament and threatened their wealth and privilege. It was to "buy out" the landlords and transfer the land to Iris true even in the Home Rule crisis of 1912-14, when the stakes for farmers. The Conservatives supported this process. Theportant of the Land Acts, the Wyndham Act of 1903, Ireland seethed with discontent - and after the Great Famine of For almost the whole 19th century, British-ruled Catholic position to Home Rule had been eroded. But the Protethe 1840s with open rebellion. In the 1880s the Liberal leader W.E.Gladstone became convinced that the only answer was to and again by anti-Home Rule agitation over three decat grant Ireland Home Rule, i.e. self-government under the British increasingly alarmed by Gaelic-Irish nationalism, was m them to oppose Home Rule. The opposition to Home F His first Home Rule Bill, in 1886, split the Liberal Party, creasingly slid over into the demand for the north-east "Liberal Unionists", led by Joseph Chamberlain, went over the Conservatives, forming the "Conservative and Unionist members, the Ulster Volunteer Force, was recruited to / cluded from Home Rule. An armed force which claimeBut Gladstone, and with him a sizeable section of the British. capitalist class, remained convinced that the cost of holding on against Home Rule for Ireland. the Conservatives were much lower.

Empire.

Party" that demand. from Home Rule for Anglo-Irish landlord interests.

The Liberals introduced a second Home Rule Bill in 1 their majority in the Commons.

Meanwhile successive Acts of the British Parliament!

By 1912 much of the material interest behind Conser (Anglo-Scots) community in north-east Ireland, stirred Nearly half a million of them signed a "Covenant"

Tory leaders backed the Ulster Unionists. F.E.Smith

Scan page 9

Belfast rally that this was *one of those supreme issues of conscience to which the ordinary landmarks of permissible resistance to technical laws are submerged". Bonar Law said: "We are dril ting inevitably to civil war... If Ulster resists we will support At the Curragh military base, British army officers declared that they would resign their commands rather than be used against the Ulster Unionists. The Liberal Government gave them The crisis was ended in August 1914 by the outbreak of World War 1. The Liberal Government seized the chance to suspend thi After the World War followed an Irish war of independence. and, eventually, Home Rule both for southern Ireland (where it quickly became real independence) and for a new partitioned-off state of Northern Ireland (ruled for 50 years by a one-party regime of the Unionist Party, then still an integral part of the The result was a mess, the price for which is still being paid today. A victory for the Liberals' Home Rule plan in 1886 would surely have brought less suffering. Yet it was the Liberal Party llow - it er 1918 was conditioned by the -elopment of the world economic sis and the need to counteract 1 fashion the growing electoral ver of Labour - given that the › threats were confronted by two ties which split the bourgeois vote between them - and the industrial power of the unions which peaked in the immediate post-war years.

In power for 17 of the interwar years independently, as the increasingly powerful force in the 1918-22 coalition with the Liberals and as the strongest party in the 1931 National Government of Ramsay McDonald, Conservative policy development was limited, tentative and defensive, conditioned by the requirements of the different sections of capital in a world depression.

In the 1920s, there were few innovations and Conservative policy oscillated between conciliationist one nation tendencies personified by Baldwin, and a "class against class" confrontationist emphaisis personified by Churchill.

The interpenetration of the two tendencies when the system required staunch defence against the challenge of Labour, can be seen from the fact that it was the statesmanlike Baldwin who ruthlessly inflicted the traumatic defeat of the 1926 General Strike, following up fast and furious with a policy of wage cutting.

And of course, the 1927 Trade Disputes Act which outlawed secondary action and picketing as well as trade unionism in the Civil Service and introduced "opting in" instead of "opting out" of the political levy to financially disable the Labour Party.

The orchestration of "soft" and "hard" is evident from the way this was accompanied by attempts to ingest the leadership of the newly weakened unions through means such as the Mond-Turner talks -surely a better example than foxhunting of the unspeakable in pursuit of the inedible.

The mechanisms of planning and state intervention developed during the war of 1914-18 were swiftly dismantled and the 1920s witnessed the return under pressure from the Treasury to financial orthodoxy, balanced budgets and a return to the Gold Standard - the mechanism which related national currencies to each other.

The drive of policy was to restore free trade and the UK's relatively strong pre-1914 international position. But whilst the Conservatives' policies favoured the City and the finance houses, export industries were hit as their products were made more expensive on world markets. The consequent sustained high levels of unemployment meant that the price of the world crisis was paid for by sections of manufacturing industry and sections of thr working class.

In 1931 the Conservatives who had outmanoeuvred and marginalised the Liberals in a war of movement since 1918 were able to utilise the Labour leadership around McDonald and Snowden to orchestrate through the National Government cuts in real wages and unemployment benefits.

But the world picture stimulated a pallid reflection of other countries in a limited and gradual abandonment of laissez-faire doctrines. The government came off the Gold Standard and introduced tariffs to protect the declining industries, based on the Import Duties Act 1939 Neville Chamberlain proclair achieving everything his fath campaigned for three d earlier.

The turn to economi tionalism prompted by the depression and trade war con with a foreign policy of first tionism and the appeaseme motivate the Second World V was combined with efforts courage cartelisation anc reorganisation of industry ticularly shipbuilding. Some therefore seen in the pos period an erosion of laisse: and a greater reliance on sta tervention which primed the servatives for the changes ‹ 1940s and 1950s.

The limited nature o response, however, can be se comparisons with policies in t (or even Germany) and the fil jection of radical policies for ing the crisis such as those pro by Oswald Mosley when i Labour government.

The successes of Baldw engineering a growth in mar turing industry from the 1930s, in broking between fi and industrial capital and in p ting sections of the working from the worst of the Depre meant that, like Thatcher, bu far superior fashion, he was a construct a successful ele coalition. In the 1935 General tion, the Conservatives won I 12 million votes, represe almost 54% of the total vote, I eleven points more than Mrs. cher was ever to achieve.

NOT Labour election poster which ned as er had écades naworld abined isolaent to Var. It to en1 the parhave t-1931 z-faire ate inConof the f the ten by he US rm re• solvffered n the vin in aufacearly nance rotecssion, It in a ble to ctoral Elecnearly nting nearly That-

----- pull-quotes -----

defied the law isurrection and laissez-faire ary majorities"

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 482

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →