Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Tankies versus lew realists

Socialist Organiser no. 482, 11 April 1991 · scan p. 4 · about 682 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

Stop the bigots!

"right" battle. Unlike the TGWU, the politics of the dispute are fairly clear. Unattractive (on both sides) but As you probably know, the MSF is the child of the merger mania of the late '80s, being a combination of th old TASS and the ASTMS. The two unions had very dif ferent traditions: TASS was controlled by a tightly-knit Stalinist clique around Ken Gill while ASTMS was a much looser outfit with no particularly coherent political Mine" beyond what suited Clive Jenkins' ambitions at Despite Jenkins' vanity and bombast, the ASTMS was relatively democratic, with a strong branch-based structure and a large, accessible annual conference. TASS, by contrast, was run on the sort of lines you'd expect from people who thought that Eastern Europe was a workers? paradise and Uncle Joe Stalin was one of the great The merger itself was motivated by financial problems affecting both the old unions and by the failure of the TASS amalgamation with the AEU. But it was carried out surprisingly democratically, with a great deal of consulation with the respective memberships and no less that two special joint conferences. Formal policy differences were not the main problem (Stalinists and right-wing Labour opportunists have quite a lot in common once they sit down and talk things over in a civilised manner).

The problem was a culture clash in terms of union organisation. The TASS Stalinists made little secret of their intention to lick the ASTMS into shape and impose their regime on the new union. However, the ASTMS membership proved remarkably resistent to Ken Gill's version of union "democracy" and set very strict conditions on the merger — much to Clive Jenkins' displeasure. Central to the ASTMS rank and file's demands was defence of the branch structure against -TASS's "divisional" arrangements. As a result, MSF re. mains a federal union, with "Section I" continuing the -TASS tradition, and Section A" being, in effect, the he present election of "general secretary designate" - is in many ways a showndown between the two traditions. Barbara Switzer is the "progressive" (le, —semi-Stalinist) candidate, backed by the old TASS bureaucracy. Her opponent, Roger Lyons, comes from the ASTMS side and has the backing of Neil Kinnock The election has already been the cause of a major in ternal union row: under the terms of the 1988 merger, the procedure for electing the general secretary should have been sorted out at the 1990 annual conference. It wasn't. Many members felt that the election should, therefore, be delayed until the 1991 conference and invoked the union's internal grievance procedure to ensun Disgracefully, an NEC member, John Gardiner, took case to the High Court to block members' use of the union's appeal court! Gardiner (who has stayed on the NEC throughout this affair) is firmly in the Lyons camp — which would seem to rather undermine their claim to represent a more democratic approach to running the Switzer and the Ken Gill TASS "Broad Left" are undoubtedly bureaucratic and in many respects worse than Roger Lyons and Co. But at least Switzer represents some sort of opposition to "New Realism" and Kinnockism. She stands for the repeal of all anti-union Of course, what's really needed is a rank and file-based left, willing to challenge the new realism of Lyons and the bureaucratisation of Switzer. Happily, there are some signs that activists from both the old unions are getting together to build just such a current. in the meantime, it has to be very, very critical support for Switzer.

HOUD AYN _s I mentioned here INSIDE "left" vs "right" battles in the TGWU are ZAMIN often pretty mystifying & GAIN affairs involving personal - PYPNi antagonisms and longnurtured grievances but precious little (at first glance) in terms of boring old politics.

So it is with relief that I turn now to the MSF. Like By Sleeper the T&G, the MSF is presently riven by a bitter "left" vs clear. any given time.

benefactors of humanity.

UNDERGROUR OU IH HIL IN

----- pull-quotes -----

A last week, the bitter THE UNIONS

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 482

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →