[the Kurds! front thern Iraq, under the United…]
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-04-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
the Kurds!
front thern Iraq, under the United Nations, They are taking the idea to the UN for approval. This means that Major and Bush are probably not serious about it.
China, or the USSR, or both, are likely to veto any interference under UN auspices into the "integrity" of the Iraqi state. They have too many unwilling minorities of their own, from China's savagely oppressed Tibetans to the USSR's Baltic states, or Georgia, which has just voted for independence.
So Major and Bush may really be going through a manoeuvre to disarm their critics. They may also be putting additional pressure on those within the Iraqi army to whom they look for a coup against Saddam Hussein.
It nevertheless, the imperialist armies somehow press ahead and create a Kurdish enclave in northern Iraq, what should be the attitude of socialists? The short answer is that we should welcome it, while retaining , our attitude of distrust and hostility to the "Allies"
We have opposed, and continue to oppose, the very presence of the US and British troops in the region; but the Kurds face genocide.
"The en class is also the emancipation of all human beings without distinction of sex or race."
Kia WAVER сре си Urgew hser PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA devastesk DIN g89 7961 Lakestina for seporter Mondar Emitor: alonwOMMahony Published by WL Publications Ltd PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA Printed by Tridant Press, Edenbridge Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office Articles do not necessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser and are in а ретвелая селесии mseewvise siated To counterpose the Kurds' own armed struggle for liberation to imperialist intervention is senseless when the Kurdish fighters have been defeated and the Kurds are fleeing in terror. If, for their own reasons, responding to the mass exodus of Kurds, the imperialist powers set up an enclave which allows the Kurds to save their lives and to regroup even to some extent, then we must be glad for the Kurds. At the same time we will not ignore the other things, the fundamental things, which the imperialist troops do too, and what they represent in the region.
Socialist Organiser opposed the for oil and prestige, waged against Iraq by Saddam Hussein's long-time backers and armourers.
Iraq, a would-be regional imperialism and one of the most savage regimes on earth, had no right to seize Kuwait, we said. But the US response — and that is what it was, essentially, under cover of the United Nations — meant a partial "recolonisation" of Arabia, turning the clock back decades.
Then the US and its allies bombed Iraq's cities back into the 19th century, and, strong with a commanding technical superiority, slaughtered Iraqi conscript soldiers. But they left the Iraqi military machine intact. That was not for humanitarian reasons, but because they want the Iraqi state to survive. They hoped for a military coup to cut away Saddam Hussein while keeping the Iraqi state intact.
ahe 25 million Kurds are divided between five states: Turkey, Iraq, | Iran, Syria, and the Those states use the Kurds as tools and pawns in their antagonisms and rivalries. All of them are immovably against the Kurds' central demand, for an independent state encompassing all the Kurds: such a move would threaten their own states' integrity.
Turkey has long been an influential ally of the US. It is an aspirant regional sub-imperialist power, with a long-standing military regime which sometimes uses civilian masks. Turkey has eight million Kurds. It has long suppressed and oppressed them, attempting to force the Turkish language and identity on them.
The Kurds, to win freedom, face not one but five states unrelentingly hostile to their national aspirations. To win a state for all the Kurds will take a political earthquake.
The nearest parallel is that of Poland, partitioned for a century and a quarter between three great states, Prussia/Germany, Russia, and Austro-Hungary. It took the collapse of Russia's Tsarist Empire, and the defeat of the other two powers holding Polish territory, in World War 1, to give the Poles a chance to recreate a Polish state.
The Gulf war leaves all the opponents of the Kurds able to do business as usual, and worse.
The Kurds have a right to an independent state. Until they win that right, they will continue to be the victims of oppression from five sides.
When Socialist Organiser opposed the US-led assault on Iraq, we did so in the name not of defence of the Iraqi state, or of the integrity of Iraq, but of self-determination for the peoples of Iraq. We supported the Kurds' right to rise up against Iraq when it was weakened by war.
Today the Kurds have a right to play their enemies off against each other as best they can, and the right to take what help they can get. They face mass slaughter from Saddam Hussein's guns, and from disease, cold and starvation: anything which allows them to survive, and at least to hope to regroup, is better than that. For the left to tell the Kurds to reject an imperialist-protected enclave in northern Iraq because anything from the hands of imperialism is tainted would be to make ourselves absurd.
It would be no less absurd to have any confidence in those who have stood idly by while Saddam murders tens of thousands and sets over a million Kurds on a desperate trek to save their lives. They aided and apologised for Saddam when he used poison gas against the Kurds three years ago. This time the scale of the Kurdish revolt and of the repression, following the war, makes hushing-up impossible. If the Kurds gain any advantages now, that will be a poor and inadequate by-product of their own heroism and determination.
If the US and its allies do set up an enclave, they will probably try to disarm the Kurds within it, rather than supplying them with arms so that they can defend themselves. They will probably oppose self-government for the Kurds within that enclave. In the rest of Iraqi Kurdistan, outside that enclave, Saddam Hussein or his successor will push torward their policy of "Arabisation" , driving Kurds into the enclave and replacing them with Arab settlers. Those Kurds who, understandably, do not wish to go back into Iraq whatever promises they may get trom the Un, Will find the borders of Britain and the US closed when they seek refuge - indeed, it may be that one reason behind Major's proposal for an "enclave" is to deflect pressure for Kurdish refugees to be admitted to Britain's and the US's ally, Turkey.
Even if the US and Britain do decide to do something to help the Kurds, it will not undo the terrible things they did in the war against Iraq, and the terrible things they are likely to do in future if they maintain a military presence and the role of imperialist overlords in the region. Major and Bush remain what they were: murdering hypocrites. Eilitomad Board Graem Bush Vladimir Derer erny Engletton atin herian (Lakom Peni BInck Sections)
Eric Heffer MP Dorothy Maceda Ipes Marino John ME Iroy bha Nichblson Peter Tatchell BALDHOL drawn trom a brone cross-section or the i whorarenopposes tor them Urganiser. Views expressed in articies are Binesponsibilition thei thors and inpt off that Adisory Editorial Board
Scan page 4
Socialist Organiser No. 482 par