A story of Australia "democracy'
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-04-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
Special ticket offer Janet Burstall looks the life and times of John Kerr, former Governor General Australia •very Australian I abor Party supporter have felt a delayed sense of justice with the last week that John Kerr had died.
While some obituary writers attempted to portray Kerr as a "giant" and a brilliant public figure, he will al wavs be remembered as the man who sacked the Whitlam government.
Kerr came from a working class background, his father being a boilermaker, and lived in Balmain where the first ALP branches had been formed.
In the 1930s he was, briefly, one of a very small number of Trotskyists in Australia. By the 1940s he, like many others, had become so repulsed by Stalinism that he joined in the battle to rid Australia of communism.
During the war he worked in military intelligence to counter "enemy elements" and later went to Washington where he was seconded to the OSS, forerunner of the CIA was the cold war that really brought him to notice. Within the ALP the hard right organised "Industrial Groups" (members were known as Groupers) to fight in the unions against anyone they considered to be a communist.
While the CP's union strength had diminished from the immediate post-war years, when at one point they had a majority on the ACTU executive, many of the largest industrial unions were min theit hands. Well organised but internally they were run as mini versions of the USSR. No opposition was tolerated and the party line was unquestioned The first big union to fall to the groupers was the ironworkers (FIA). In a bitter and sometimes violent election Laurie Short defeated the existing secretary. Short had also been, with Kerr, one of the few early Trotskyists.
When Short went to the FIA building to assume his office the locks had been changed. With police assistance he gained entry, only to find that the offices had been reorganised and the secretary's was now in the corridor.
The groupers tactics all along had been twofold: to fight within the ranks and to fight in the courts. They had seemingly limitless financial backing.
Because of the centrality of the courts in the industrial relations system, both left and right relied on legal firms that derived almost all their income representing the factions in the courts.
Kerr represented Short and won, and became the chief legal adviser to the groupers.
A national referendum was conducted on outlawing the Communist Party, which was only narrowly defeated. And in 1954 the ALP split, The groupers had lost out in the decisive national conference and so walked out of the party, torming the Democratic Labor Party (DLP). Many right wingers stayed with the ALP, some for tactical reasons, but others because they were groupers opposed to the smear and fear tactics.
The split meant that Labor didn't win government again until 1972 even though three times between 1954 and 1969 they won more than 50% of the national vote.
Kerr also left the ALP but didn't join the DLP, instead concentrating on his legal practice and working with the CIA front group the Association for Cultural Freedom.
Why then did Whitlam appoint him GovernorCertainly many warned him against it, both from the left and the right. His pedigree was well known.
The answer isn't clear, perhaps even Whitlam doesn't know. But one thing is clear: Kerr's subsequent actions were entirely in keeping with his character.
By late 1975 Labor was reeling from the effects of the economic recession. Inflation was 16% and unemployment was growing rapidly. Whitlam was forced to reshuffle his Cabinet and appointed as the new Minister for Labor Jim McClelland, a life-long friend of Kerr who had also been one of the small number of pre-war Trotskyists.
The Conservatives under Malcolm Fraser were threatening to block the supply bills in the Senate where Labor was in a minority. It was a very risky tactic as opinion polls showed large majorities against the threat. Pressure was on both Labor and the coalition. Whitlam had decided not to budge and believed the coalition would back down at the last minute before supply ran out at the end November.
At the same time Whitlam had talked of not renewing the leases on the US's spy bases at Pine Gap in Central Australia. (Pine Gap A weekend of socialist discussion Dozens of speakers John Kerr looking ridiculous in top hat provided much of the US's satellite coverage of Iraq during the Gulf War.) They fell due on 9 December. It is extremely unlikely he would have made good his threat, but the CIA certainly took it seriously.
Indeed, William Colby, the CIA's Director, later wrote that the Whitlam government posed one of the three threats in his career and said it ranked with the 1973 Middle East war! Such was the CIA's paranoia about a reforming Labor government.
Without any warning, or any discussions with the elected Prime Minister, Kerr called Whitlam to his office on November 11 and sacked his government and made Malcolm Fraser Prime Minister.
That afternoon the coalition was defeated in the House and Labor won a vote of confidence. Immediately, the Speaker went to tell Kerr of the decisions, but Kerr refused to even see him.
So in one day an unelected representative of the British Queen sacked an elected Prime Minister and then ignored the decisions of the Parliament.
Spontaneous strikes and demonstrations took place when Kerr's actions became from a wide range of ocialist opinion gathe for three days of debate. Many international guests.
House, Friday 28-Sunday 30 28-Sunday June reche • food • soc • accommodation known: Hundreds of thousands of people took to the streets as Whitlam urged supporters to "maintain the rage"
But even then Bob Hawke, President of the ACTU, was urging workers not to strike but to wait for the December general election. The momentum was lost and as the campaign focus turned back to the economy Labor was annihilated at the polls.
Instead of Fraser, who had masterminded the withholding of supply, Kerr became the figure of hate. Nowhere could he go without being greeted by enormous demonstrations and boycotts. The pressure obviously affected him such that when he presented the Melbourne Cup the next year he was drunk on national television - before millions he slurred his speech. With his penchant for top hats, and his ruddy cheeks, he became a figure of ridicule.
When Fraser later appointed him UNESCO Ambassador he lasted only four months before the uproar forced him to resign.
His last years were spent virtually in internal exile, making few public appearances. His actions warranted such treatment. Special ticket Before the end of April: unwaged E4; students/low waged E7; waged £10 (These prices are for Saturday & Sunday. Add £1 (unwaged) and £2 (others) for tickets which include Friday.)
Name..
Address.
Return to Alliance for Workers* Liberty, c/o PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. Cheques Worming be el ho do you think is "I really do wish these agents of the police and the state would go awa! because they are not wanted.
"They are nothing but idiots who want to play into the hands of the media. They are the enemies of this campaign and they've got no place in it.
*Brothers and sisters, don't let these people distract you. That's why they've been sent here today and they've probabl been paid to do it as well."
Some old Stalinist hack back 40 years ago in the dark days when they could get away with such blanket denunciations of their left-wing critics, Trotskyists, anarchists, and others?
No, the speaker is a self-proclaimed Trotskyist. He is comrade Tommy Sheridan, Chair of the All Britain Anti-Poll Tax Federation. The diminutive "Tommy" tells you not that he is a friendly popular guy, but that he is a member of Militant, which affects this style.
Sheridan was speaking from the platform at the London anti-poll tax rally on March 23; denouncing left-wing hecklers, critical of the Anti-Poll Tax Federation, an out and out Militant front organisation.
The quotation is from Workers' Press. We have checked that it is broadly accurate.
Sheridan's diatribe is proof that these people are incapable of learning. After last year's anti-poll tax riots in London the leaders of the Anti-Poll Tax Federation thoroughly disgraced themselves when Steve Nally, he Federation Secretary ublicly promised on TV to 'name names" of those who had fought the police - that is, turn anti-poll tax activists over to the police and their law courts!
The Tories were attempting to repeat the trick that had worked so successfully during the 1984-85 miners' strike, and focus attention on "violence", making that and not the poll tax the issue. Their press was baying away with this theme, repeating police lies about what happened. So were the leaders of the Labour Party.
Nally, Sheridan and the leaders of Militant let themselves get caught up in this hysteria. Not grasping what was going on, they tried to play the Tole of "good boys and girls" for the Tory media, willing to help nail "violent" "rioters". lI was a disgraceful, panic-stricken performance.
What it revealed about Militant's leading clique is that they lack some of the most basic and irreplaceable instincts of the serious working class March 1990 - Nally said he would socialist militant.
The organisers of the anti-poll tax demonstration would have the right and the duty to steward it and try to control, for example, anarchists who tried to act on the belief that a riot is more useful than a vast peaceful demonstration.
But to go from that political (or stewarding) conflict with mistaken comrades to an offer to ferret out their names and make them available to the police, the courts, and their jailers - that is to cross the class line in politics. Worse, th bland TV promises of Nally to turn informer showed that he doesn't know such lines exist.
There may have been a few anarchists looking for a fight on the anti-poll tax demo in March 1990. But two things were outstanding about the riots.
The violence was started by the police in Whitehall and elsewhere. And even the television news reports showed the police driving crazily into crowds and attacking innocent bystanders.
The second outstanding thing was that lots of not very political people were drawn into resisting the police on the street This too was reported in the serious bourgeois press (the Daily Telegraph, for example.
But it passed by the awareness of the Militant leaders of the Anti-Poll Tax Federation. They joined the gutter press and Kinnock, offe ing narks' services to the coppers who had behaved like Cossacks in the centre of London.
A year later even the police investigation into what happened and why has publicly criticis ed the police.
As far as we know, Militant never repudiated Nally. Now they compound their political infamy with Stalinist-style slander against their critics: the proud would-be coppers' narks of last year now denounce the sort of people they then offered to hand over to the cops as.... cops! Yuk!
Militant operates as a closed sect, and runs a weekly paper which on principle (Stalinist principle!) carried few articles letters by members or non-members who disagree with them. Internally, a high level of conformity is maintained by a quasi-religious atmosphere and by diatribes against even a hint of dissent, of the sort Sheridan spewed out at his critics.
An organisation like that will take on board only such lessons of its own experience as itthat is a tiny group of its leaders - choose to take account of. The result is that they can commit the political atrocity they committed last year and learn nothing from the experience.
Militant's internal "education" has evidently focused on a hate campaign against anar chists" and "ultra-lefts"* , not on how a prominent **Militant could offer to turn informer.
That is what burst out in sheridan's yobby speech from the platform after the demonstration on 23 March.
Scan page 15
British Timken: Socialist Organiser No. 481 page 15
----- pull-quotes -----
Workers' Liberty
EVIE-ON THE EFT