The winter of revolutions
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-04-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
The has singlehandedly transformed from barren rock. But it's not his land, he rents it from the widow. His aim is to buy it from her and pass it on, thus righting the wrongs of decades past.
Into this small village, where things seem pre-ordained, comes the 'outsider' , the Yank, and order is turned upside down, with tragic consequences.
To the Bull, the Yank represents the return of those who emigrated, those who couldn't survive the famine, and have now come back to buy what they couldn't work to keep.
The problem is all the characters represent something from the Bull's memory of his youth. They are not characters in their own right, and in the end become stereotypes. They don't even get their own names, The priest, although trish, is still an outsider represents those priests who turned their back on the poor when they were hungry and homeless.
The widow is the cold landowner with no sympathy or empathy for the locals. The tinker and his daughter are those who stayed but were unable to get back on their feet.
This is a problem for plays turned into movies. The characters on stage are more often symbolic and not realistic as needed on the screen.
But the film also suffers from an "Irish movie' stereotype. Too much brings to mind Ryan's Daughter, or Books Theresa Jones The People:
Revolution c Timothy Garto Books, £4.99, Ash begins attended coal-mine in 1989. There Lech Walesa introduced his colleague Adam Michnik to the miners. Today Michnik has walked out of the Solidarity parliamentary caucus, is in a political group hostile to Walesa's and writes articles denouncing Walesa as a potential dictator.
Ash has written his account of four episodes of the 1989 revolutions. The four main chapters describe the June elections in Warsaw, the reburial of Imre Nagy in Budapest in June, the opening of the Berlin Wall in November, and two weeks in Prague November/December just as the CP government was about to resign.
The accounts are The f'89 1 Ash, Granta 1990 his book by a meeting he in a Silesian journalistic Lech Walesa style and make for easy reading, and at only 140 pages it is digestible in only one sitting.
Even though change is the central theme, Ash is not convinced that the events should be described as a "revolution" • Rather, he argues that there was a strong element of change from above led by an enlightened minority in the privileged elite in the still ruling CPs, and that in many areas remnants of the privileged elite still retain undue influence and authority.
His account begins in Poland just before the June elections. The 261 Solidarity candidates are told that the elections aren't democratic but "the key is hope that in four years there will be free, democratic elections." Four years! How tame this idea seems in retrospect.
As the overwhelming election results came into the Solidarity office in Warsaw, they were met with exaltation, incredulity and alarm. Alarm at their new responsibilities. Their timetable was two years of loyal parliamentary opposition before local elections in 1991 and, in 1995, a Presidential election.
In Budapest, police assisted and Ministers spoke at the reburial of Imre Nagy, one of the leaders of the 1956 revolution. Only one year earlier, oppositionists had been violently dispersed as they demonstrated in memory of Nagy's execution.
If nothing else had happened in the second halt of 1989, then what occurred in Poland and Hungary would have been regarded as spectacular and historic.
But in Leipzig, in late September, 5000 East Germans demonstrated for elections and reform.
By 2 October, 20,000 were on the Leipzig streets - the biggest demonstration since the failed workers' uprising of June 1953. The following Sunday, there were 70,000 and, two days later, police violently attacked demonstrators at the 40th anniversary "celebrations" of the GDR.
Rather than demoralising the population, the government's violence mobilised opposition. By November 9, 300,000 people were demonstrating. All in a matter of only six weeks.
On 9 November the wall By now there seemed to be a pattern to follow. = In Czechoslovakia the Stalinists refused to negotiate or contemplate anything other than the status quo, that is, its monopoly on power.
On 29 November the CP's. Secretary, Karel Urbanek, told Party members that they wouldn't concede to demands to dissolve the People's Militia. On December they did just that.
In the Federal Assembly, the faceless bureaucrats who for forty years had ruled the country, and preached the leading role of the Party, now voted to delete the Constitution's reference to the Party's leading role. They voted to remove Marxism-Leninism as the basis for education. Not a single dissenting vote. Even at the end not an honest person among them.
But the speed of change took the opposition by surprise as well. Civic Forum had stated that they "did not aspire to any ministerial post". . One week later, they told PM Calfa they "might be able to come to an agreement with him".
As in Poland and Hungary, there followed round table talks. In Poland the talks had lasted two months, in Czechoslovakia two days.
On 10 December, precisely to the Forum's deadline, President Husak swore in the new government and then resigned.
In a fortnight, Jan Carnogursky went from being a prisoner of conscience to being one of two first Vice Premiers with partial responsibility for the security apparatus. As had happened in Poland, prisoners became ministers and ministers became prisoners. Soon prisoners would also become Presidents.
The CP's apparatus crumbled. By the end of 1989 the Hungarian SWP had split in two; in January 1990 the Polish PUWP followed suit and within three months East Germany's Socialist Unity Party had lost its leading role, its name and at least half of its members.
Ash's book brings together these historic events in one small accessible volume and refreshes our memory of an inspiring six months.
But, more importantly, he provides an answer to those who see history as one slow gradual process of change. Those who say that groups of people can't change society except perhaps at the fringe. The events in Eastern Europe demonstrate more clearly than ever that change, inspired by popular and mass protest, dramatic, is urgent and essential.
----- pull-quotes -----
claims, they are a mix of revolution and reform, or "refolution". He