[ON NOTE HASTON Is a VUTE for AMENTAR!…]
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-04-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
ON NOTE HASTON Is a VUTE for AMENTAR!
STE-ELECTION 1945 defeatism/defencism pretty meaningless.
What is more, it should be plain to anyone who thinks about the issues that the Marxist position is more subtle and complex than just supporting one side (defence) against the other (defeat), though this is as far as some commentators have got. With the appropriate, out of context quotation, this tradition has, however, replaced an honest assessment of reality by some sections of the left. Hence we get: (1) "the defeat of one's own government is a lesser evil" [defeat by who — which class, and compared to what?]; (2) "Marxists should wish for the defeat of their own governments" [by doing what exactly?]; (3) "thę defeat of one's own government facilitate revolution" [perhaps, but in whose interests?] Lenin at least had the virtue of seeking an independent policy for the working class to pursue in time of war — to carry on the class struggle internationally - even though his formulations are open to misinterpretation.
He also had the virtue of abandoning such It should be plain anyone who thinks the issues that the Marxist position is. nore subtle and complex than just supporting one side against the other."
Scan page 13
ichard Harris's latest fi Another Irish 'tour de force Film Tony Brown reviews The Field verything about The Field •Is dominated by Kichard Harris as Bull MeCabe. At times Harris seems larger than the screen itself. He is very much the focus, the centrepiece of the film, which is ultimately the film's weakness.
It is one of those 'tour de force' roles that Harris plays to the full. Everything revolves around him.
The Bull's whole life view has been dominated by the Irish famine in the middle of the 19th century. His family was dispossessed, all his brothers and sisters sent overseas to avoid the death which encompassed the parish. He remained only: because he was the oldest son and was meant to re-inherit the land.
With his father he worked from morning till night to make ends meet. His mother died in the field but he worked on in order to save the crop. He proved that he was ready to inherit.
When we first meet him he is preparing to pass on to his son the three acres of lush green land that Richard Harris plays Bull McCabe My Left Foot. This is not too surprising as it was made by Jim Sharman, who directed My Left Foot, and there as Mrs McCabe is Christy Brown's mum, once again portraying the long suffering, silent rock of the family.
The first time we see John Hurt, who by the way gives a remarkable performance, I thought of John Mills in Ryan's Daughter, and as the movie goes on you can't help but be reminded of Barry Fitzgerald in any number of Irish films of the 1940s and 1950s.
The Field does tackle a number of difficult questions, setting them in a small Irish village, as a microcosm of Irish rural life.
Legal ownership of the land against farmers' rights, religion and power, tather and son relationships (we see nothing of the mother/son relationship), and centrally, the land which takes on an almost mystical presence.
Unfortunately, these questions are unbalanced by some rather unbelievable scenes, notably the fight and carrying of the Socialist Organiser No. 481 page 13 seaweed, which only serve to prove that the ageing Bull is as strong as two young men. This is even harder to believe when one of them is a strapping Tom Berenger, But the final scenes really outdo all this. We get a crescendo of tragedy and grief, a reciting of the Lord's Prayer, and a pretty strong sense of dissatisfaction.