Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Defeatism and Defencism: bury the dead

Socialist Organiser no. 481, 3 April 1991 · scan p. 12 · about 1,514 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

Hampton ack Cleary's review of the Communist Party book on the Second World War - About Turn (SO 479) raised number of important issues for

socialists involved in the recent anti-war movement. In particular, by touching on the controversial role of the Trotskyists, who were the only militant workers at the time to oppose the war without lapsing into pacifism or chauvinism, he sets an agenda for a valuable future The three issues of most importance regarding the attitude of Marxists to wars are:

(I) the dichotomy between "defeatism"

and "defencism" adopted from some of Lenin's writings;

(2) what became known as the Proletarian Military Policy (PMP) elaborated by Trotsky between 1938 and his death in 1940;

(3) the application of the Marxist principles, strategy and tactics during WW2 by the British Workers International League (WIL).

This latter issue, regarding the actual activities of Trotskyists during WW2 would require a separate article in itself, especially if the whole international experience, such as the resistance movements in France and Greece, were to be included. However, for the record, anyone trying to give an account of this experience should remember that much of the work done by militants was at its infancy in terms of a rounded, all encompassing approach, and involved many debates and differences which were still unresolved by 1945.

For example, in the WIL a debate occurred between Healy and Grant on the one hand and Haston and Levy on the other over both fundamentals and on concrete questions like the Home Guard.

This brings me to Cleary's main contention - of the link between the PMP and so-called "revolutionary defencism". It is not clear whether this link is meant to be a logical one, ie. that the PMP was in theory a "defencist" policy; or whether it is an empirical claim, that in practice the Trotskyists who subscribed to the PMP were "defencists" • However, in both cases we need to know: (a) what the PMP really meant; and (b) what defencism really means.

The modern forms of defeatism/defencism originate with the Bolsheviks, initially in 1904-5 during the Russo-Japanese war — where they were for the defeat of Russia: meaning the victory of Japan; and later in the imperialist World War 1 as clarification for the workers' movement in the struggle to avoid subordination to their "own" governments' warmongering.

"Detencism" in these circumstances was used by the Social Democrats for defence of the fatherland (the nation), but in practice also meant support for their own (bourgeois) governments — just as Kinnock did during the Gulf War. Hence defeatism - but applied for all sides, to all imperialists. There were three ditterent senses in which dereat/ defence was used: (1) to explain the aims of the wars, and whether workers should support or oppose them politically with their own methods;

(2) to explain the attitude workers should take to the outcome of military campaigns re: of the victory or defeat of each side;

(3) to explain the particular tasks of workers in each concrete war situation.

Unfortunately these separate senses, which were expressed more clearly by other revolutionary internationalists (eg. Liebknecht's "the main enemy is at home"), have become hopelessly confused or encrusted with theology in Cleary's words, as to render

Right: French Trotskyists produced a German language newspaper "Arbeiter und Soldat' (Worker and Soldier') during the Nazi occupation. They organised a cell in the German Army which was discovered by the SS. All its members paid for this activity with their lives.

Below: Neath by-election 1945: When Trotskyist Jock Haston dared to stand up against the wartime electoral "truce' he was denounced as a Communist the Tories and as a fascist by the Communists!

WELSH TASTERI ASE THE TE PARLIAMENTARY FOR COUNTY OF GLAN

Orgas des Deade de Kommunines-ion NIEDER MIT DEM KRIEG atunes (Deutsche Seltice der rieter laterentonalé)

Wannal ver den Bergering sagen den imperialistischen Krieg la der verten enla READ NEA 1 THE COMMU IST PARTYS AMPHLE terms when they were found to be inadequate - defeatism and defencism disappear from the Marxist arsenal between 1917-24, ie. during the high point of the theory and practice of working class revolution so far.

It should be warning enough for us that "defeatism" became a "principle of Leninism" again only as a weapon to beat the Oppositionists with (Trotsky had criticised the term during the First World War, as had Luxemburg and loads of Old Bolsheviks, many of whom also later fought Stalin).

he point is that the sheath of defencism/ defeatism is not an adequate starting point for elaborating Marxist politics towards particular wars. Critics of the PMP are confounded by the policy precisely because it does not fit clearly into either category, but this is merely a sign of theoretical sterility.

The first thing to say here is about World War 2, which was a continuation of the first war, ie. a conflict between the major capitalist powers over markets and colonies, spheres of influence. But it was no mere repetition, but involved new factors which though they did not change the overall character of the conflict, certainly added to the complexity of the situation and affected workers' consciousness. Principally they were the USSR, as a system apparently different from capitalism, and secondly, the rise of Nazism, smashing the German proletariat.

A further point needs to be made about the precedents of the PMP. Both Marx and Engels were positive warmongers in certain situations (eg. US civil war, Franco-Prussian war), and in Lenin's work there are references to trade unionism in the army and

people's militia (eg. "On the Disarmament Slogan", 1916). Furthermore, during the dual power situation in 1917, he even linked the struggle to overthrow the bourgeoisie by the working class to the tasks of "national defence"

Similarly, in the early Communist International and the CPs in the 1920s, we find references to the necessity of military training, election of officers and organisations within the forces. The particular points made by Trotsky on the PMP have a grounding in the classical Marxist tradition.

was the Proletarian Military Policy? It was not meant as a distinctGive policy to distinguish fascist from democratic imperialist countries, nor a fetishising of the power and influence of Hitler or a denial of the imperialist character of the conflict as a whole.

Rather, it was a set of slogans, ideas and tactics given this characterisation, but in the context of the militarisation of the whole world working class. The advanced workers needed a policy in the context of the reality of capitalist militarisation - a situation in which pacifism was totally useless [what.

should be done about Hitler?], and in which chauvinism was binding the workers to their oppressors at home.

This meant representing the interests of workers in the context of a changing situation - in the army where, with millions in uniform had no choice but to go with their comrades. It meant a fight for democratic rights in the army, for control over training, over officers, over equipment. It meant a fight against the militarism on the home front — in Britain the Emergency Powers Act, the ban on workers' papers, the speed-up in the factories.

It also posed the question of power in terms of real concerns of workers, eg. in Britain/US: if you fear Hitler, then defend yourselves and your organisations by overthrowing the bourgeoisie. None of this meant abandoning lessons about the character of the state army or the nature of the war - but rather Marxists had to relate to actual struggles, actual conditions, actual experiences which thousands of workers were going through, and which they would fight against.

To repeat, this policy supplemented the agreed principles (opposition to imperialist warmongering, workers continue to struggle for their own interests) in order to link these tasks together, not an endorsement of the "allied" war aims. In all of this Trotsky was. clear:

(1) that every war situation should be understood concretely and specifically;

(2) that for workers, their own interests, struggles, aims and organisations, ie. politics, came first (just as in peace time) and military considerations are secondary;

(3) the point for Marxists is to elaborate the tasks in response to the war situation, to arm workers with the ideas to make their own emancipation.

Cleary between the PMP and defencism o I think the linkage made by Jack is unhelpful in explaining either idea.

In the case of defeatism/defencism, starting with military speculation, however important this may be in particular wars for the working class (as in the Gulf War), does not supply us with the method to establish the revolutionary policy, especially in the complex conflicts of the twentieth century.

Better that we follow Trotsky's views from 1915, which Lenin implicitly accepted in 1917, which Rosmer suggested in 1936, and which various Marxists - Shachtman, Goldman and Draper (in the US) and Pearce (in Britain) have repeated ever since -defeatism and defencism get us nowhere, let us bury the dead!

Long live independent working nationalism!

----- pull-quotes -----

LUIE HEATH DIVISION

TROUNGE THE TROISKYTIES RIFASCISM

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 481

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →