Don't slide into pessimism!
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-04-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
AGAINST THE TIDE n the aftermath of the war it is very easy for those of us who have been active in the anti-war movement to slide into pessimism and despair.
But if we do that, it would be an even bigger victory for the imperialists who have just slaughtered tens of thousands to protect the dictatorships they currently favour against one that crossed their interests, and who are now imposing a Pax Americana which threatens a lebanonisation of the whole Middle East.
We must quickly release ourselves from the debate about what might have been and make a serious assessment of the post-war situation. We must locate where and how the Left can maximise its effectiveness now in relation to the Middle East, and specifically how we should proceed on the Israel/ Palestine conflict.
The principles held by the Jewish Socialists Group and the objectives we had been fighting for long before the war remain the same. If anything has changed, it is the urgency with which they must be pursued.
We have long stood on the need for a political solution to the Israel/Palestine conflict that can guarantee a secure and productive future for the people who live there. A solution based on an end to occupation and discrimination, replacing it with self-determination on an equal footing for all Israeli and Palestinian Jews and Arabs - an equality that includes the relations between men and women, between the secular and the religious, and which provides the best conditions for socialist advance. sterile debate on whether a socialist ithin the Lett in Britain there is a solution should be on the basis of a unitary state or two states. As far as the JSG is concerned, these goals may be achieved through the creation of one state, two states or five states. It is not for us to decide or seek to impose our solution, but for the Israelis and Palestinians.
Our opinion, though, is that the two states position is the one that holds the best prospects for moving towards the goals of peace and justice in the area, that it is the position most likely to diffuse rather than further inflame nationalist tensions and meet the aspirations of the peoples of Israel and Palestine.
Although they have different starting points, and see it being realised in different ways, for some years now the mainstream PLO and many people in the Israeli peace movement have been converging on this posi tion.
Nothing that has happened either in the build up to, or during, the Gulf War makes us depart from these positions, but neither can we ignore what happened and how it affects medium and long term prospects for change. The Scud attacks on Israeli civilian targets may have undermined the argument that Israeli security will be found through territorial expansion.
Some left papers have suggested that the attacks will make Israelis understand the fears of the Palestinians in the territories.
I suspect the overwhelming effect will be to increase the hawkishness of the ordinary Israeli. The popular support given to Saddam by the occupied Palestinian people, both at a popular level and at a political leadership level - which can be easily explained in terms of the attraction of a leader superficially espousing pan-Arab unity and opposition to Western dominance — is unlikely to further confirm Israeli hawkishness.
we recognise that Israel is a very stratified society and understand that change must necessarily draw on the resources of both Israeli and Palestinian workers and social movements, it becomes clear that Saddam's hijacking of the Palestinian cause for his ends has done them and the left favours at all.
It seems that the Israeli right and far right have made gains during the Gulf war. Hidden behind a popular media miragé of Israel's statesmanlike restraint in the face of murderous provocations by Iraq, the Israeli state has stepped up its repression of the Palestinians. It has imposed drastic curfew measures in the territories, and locked up prominent Palestinian activists such as Sari Nusseibeh and Ziad Abu Zayyad. And Yitshak Shamir has appointed a neo-fascist to his inner cabinet from a fringe far right party.
ewish socialists have long recognised J that while Israel relies for military and economic support principally on the government of the USA, it also relies heavily on the Jewish diaspora, the Jewish communities around the world, for political and moral support, and further economic support. Israeli governments claim to act on behalf of Jewish interests in the world. The reality is that the Israeli state acts in its own interests, and its actions often run counter to the real interests of Jewish people in the diaspora.
The more cracks that can be made in the false diaspora consensus for Shamir's policy, the more Jewish people who believe in peace and justice refuse to let Shamir speak for them, the stronger will be the position of Israelis and Palestinians working for a just peace. If socialists here are going to aid this process they will have to re-examine some of their own formulations about Jewish communities and wrong assumptions that treat Jews, Israel and Zionism as interchangeable. There is a lot of loose talk in the liberal and left press about the alleged strength of the "Jewish lobby" in America as the most important influence on the politics of the Middle East. Jews in America, as in other countries, have very diverse views and are active in a range of political initiatives. There is a very powerful "pro-Israel" lobby. It includes the organised political establishment of American Jews, but also many non-Jewish interests - including fundamentalist Christian anti-semites who only like Jews who are thousands of miles away protecting American capitalist interests.
espite attempts by the media here in Domain ad to fuel the wa, in rel cons terms and to fuel racism, many communities came together in the anti-war movement, including people like ourselves from the Jewish community. Despite the pressures, there were some outstanding examples of solidarity, such as the campaign on behalf of Iraqi and Palestinian detainees, people like Abbas Cheblak, in which Jewish activists were very prominent.
Fascist groups in Britain used the war as a cover for stepping up their terror attacks on both Muslim and Jewish communities targetting mosques and synagogues and individuals in these communities. They also tried to infiltrate and exploit anti-war mobilisations.
A war which saw the White Christian west. triumph and humiliate a Third World Muslim country will continue to be exploited to the full by racists and fascists.
It will also be exploited by fundamentalists within minority communities who have their own narrow agenda and whose activities can threaten unity against racism.
Local anti-racists should note that the most infamous anti-semitic publication of the the Muslim Information Centre in North Internal Security. That is an issue for all anti-racists and anti-fascists to take up.
The best way we can influence Jewish and Palestinian unity and give support to all in Israel and Palestine who oppose imperialist domination to and Israeli occupation, and anti-racist and anti-imperialist unity across our communities here in Britain.
David Rosenberg is a member of the Group.
are The Victorians called them "Street Arabs". Homeless, penniless, young destitute children begging on the streets were a common sight in those days. There was no such thing as a welfare state then; children - and, indeed, adults - that capitalism couldn't exploit for their labour were left to fend for themselves, with no social provision bar the hated workhouse prisons.
Social democratic parties pledged to abolish destitu tion. In a time of capitalist boom they did, partly. The NHS, social security benefits, and other welfare services became the norm.
But the fundamental cause of poverty and homelessness - capitalism itself - was left unchallenged, its foundations remained unshaken.
Now, deep in yet another recession, capitalism attacks that welfare provision: it is unprofitable, so it has to go. Young, destitute people have returned to the streets; begging is the only "job" they can find.
Homelessness is soaring. exploitation of child labou is growing; more and more people sink into poverty.
No tinkering with the system can ever eradicate poverty. It can only make life slightly more bearable in times when capitalism is relatively "healthy". To eradicate poverty for ever we must eradicate the system which spawns we must destroy capitalism itself.
----- pull-quotes -----
20th century, which the Nazis treated as their bible, the Protocols of the Elders of Zion has recently been on display in the bookshops of
London, in both its full version and in an edited version, under the title Zionism and
who oppose discrimination and injustice in the Middle East as a whole, is on the basis of
Those not rememb the past
doomed to relive it