Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Was the collapse of Stalinism tragedy or triumph?

Socialist Organiser no. 480, 28 March 1991 · scan p. 14 · about 670 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

of the United Secretariat of the Fourth International (USFI) was held last month.

The USFI is one of the major international associations of Trotskyist groups. Its best-known figure is Ernest Mandel; in Britain, Socialist Action an Socialist Outlook are the publications sympathetic to its ideas.

A report of the Congress in the 28 February issue of Rouge (weekly paper of the LCR, the French group affiliated to the USFI explains that: "On the work situation, the debate was mostly about the assessment of the imperialist counter-offensive and the international relations of forces after the fall of the bureaucratic dictatorship.

*Differences on that point did not prevent wide agreement on tasks, and in particular on the anti-imperialist tasks (campaign for the abolition of Third World debt, against the Gu war, for the defence of Cuba against American threats), on the democratic struggles in Eastern Europe (for the right to self-determination of the oppressed nationalities, for the reconstruction of an independent workers' movement), and on the attitude to adopt to the apitalist plan for Europe.

"However, the difference: do maybe clarify disagreements which have emerged on the way to relate to the unification of Germany, the balance sheet of the Nicaraguan revolution, and, more generally, the direction the international consequences of the dynamic under way in "The resolution presented by the outgoing Executive Committee on this point got about 88% of the votes; a minority resolution, presented by the Tendency for the Construction of the Fourth International, got about 7%, the rest being divided between two other minority resolutions, presented by Socialist Actio (US) and the Socialist League of Britain (a little more than 1% each) and abstentions.

"On the Soviet Union, the debate was about the crisis of the bureaucracy an the balance-sheet of the command economy, on the national question, on Gorbachev's international policy, on the plans for the restoration of a market economy and the obstacles to it, on the social and democratic demands around which an independent workers' movement can reconstruct itself. The majority resolution got about 83% of the votes, the percentages for the mino rity resolutions being the same as on the international resolution."

The German fortnightly Sozialistische Zeitung, around which the West German USFI supporters organise, gives further information on the debates.

*There were no programmatic differences despite the dramatic politica changes. There were clear political differences with three minority currents (ISG-Britain, Socialist Action-US, a part of the LCR-France), which were able to rally about 9 to 13 per cent of the delegates between them. Certain political assessments were common to them, but they had differences among themeselves on a series of questions.

*They assess the collapse of Stalinism as uniformly positive, because it gives the working class new scope for its self-organisation and political formation.

*The atrocious ideological devastation, which Stalinism has left in the heads of the working class, and the fact that the socialist project as such possesses no credibility today is for them no cause to account to themselves for the contents and the new forms of politics. From the mass movements which are directed towards rejection of the consequences of the reintroduction of the market economy they hope for an immediate strengthening of the revolutionary forces, and the understanding that the old system was no sort of socialism and socialism has yet to be won..."

The Sozialistische Zeitung report also gives some organisational details.

"The Fourth Internationa is not yet an organisational pole of attraction. Its membership has fallen to 9,000. 3,900 members live Western Europe, 3,700 in Latin America; of those, over 3,200 in two countries, Mexico and Brazil.

«While the membership is growing in Latin America, it has fallen by about 25% in the West European sections.

200 people took part in the Congress, of whom 20% were women. There were 85 mandates from 26 sections; three sections were not represented.

*In Sri Lanka, the NSSP an organisation of 2,700 members, has demanded admission to the Fourth Ernest Mandel

----- pull-quotes -----

EYE ON he World Congress

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 480

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →