Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Theory and the anti-war movement

Socialist Organiser no. 480, 28 March 1991 · scan pp. 14–15 · about 1,069 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

To signiticant pol- of Honecker and Causescu between Socialist working class. (To be fair, Action and Socitiien the Revolutionary ComOutlook (Letters, 8 munist Group is right with tion are much more, shall "ultra-leftism", even if this we say, distinctive than usually translates that. "whatever Socialist Outlook is Socialist Action's role in position broad tront the Committee organisations, apart from the CSWG. dedicated CUTES гесенну exeluding the characterised my own group, "Trots". TELE Socialist Society, strius arrestion "Trojan horse for European which we now know, was of capital'"). A picture begins to representatives of the Socialist Outlook (not a Further evidence is sup- go) have published a pam1989: in op- Stalinism. Socialist Action's position to the somewhat platform appears to be quite rose-tinted version retailed by the reverse. concluded that the downfall THON CHH agree with Frank Kitz (Letters, SO 479) that Socialist Worker's "core message was to oppose the Gulf war".

I also agree that "that the opposition [to war] was not bigger is not due to whether or not Socialist Worker got its line 100% correct...

On the other hand, Frank Kitz seems to agree with me that SW's line was far from 100% correct; at least, he does not contest any of my argument against SW's initial pro-Saddam line (when it claimed that Saddam was *playing an anti-imperialist role"), against SW's subsequent retreat into bland pacifism, or against SW's support for Iraq's occupation of Kuwait.

I disagree - and I hope Frank Kitz disagrees — with John Molyneux's ludicrous self-congratulation in his "Teach Yourself Marxism" column in SW of 16 March. *The struggle against the Gulf war is a perfect example of the importance of theory.

"The positions taken by Socialist Worker and the Socialist Workers' Party enabled a le paper and paty anti-war movement...

"But these positions were not simply a spontaneous reaction to events by SWP members. On the contrary, they were based on an analysis of imperialism developed and renewed by WHAT'S ON Thursday 28 March Has the Poll Tax Finished the Tories?, Newcastle SU meeting. Speaker: Chris Croome, 8.00, Rossetti Studio by the Trent pub Thursday 4 April "Ireland: Beyond the Slogans", Leeds SO meeting. 7.30, Packhorse pub, Woodhouse Lane "Left-wing anti-semitism - myth or reality?", Liverpool SO meeting. 7.30, Trade Union Centre, Hardman Friday 5 April "After the war", Socialist Society meeting. Speakers include John Palmer, 7.30 Malet St Marxists since the beginning of the century...

In the SW pamphlet on the war, the line of backing Saddam as "anti-imperialist" and supporting the Iraqi occupation of Kuwait is simply asserted — in half a sentence - without any supporting argument at all, good, bad, or indifferent. There is no "theory" at all, Marxist or otherwise.

What SW writers have done on the theory of imperialism points quite another way. Before 1968 they used to argue that imperialism had become a thing of the past. "It is difficult to see what value there is in still using the word imperialism today" (Michael Kidron, International Capitalism, 1965).

Later writings (like Nigel Harris's book The End of the Third World) take a view more similar to that from which we in SO denounced Iraq's occupation of Kuwait as "sub-imperialist""

It was partly because SW had no consistent, coherent line on the war linked to any body of theory thatdespite SW's often large mobilisations for the anti-war demonstrations - it played no leading role at all in the anti-war movement. It only tagged along with the pacifist, pro-UN, prosanctions Committee to Stop War in the Gulf.

SW made its own propaganda, against illusio "Ireland and Socialists", Manchester SO meeting. 061 227 9004 "The politics of famine", London SO Forum. Details: 071 639 7965 Tuesday 9 April "The Middle East - what solution?", Brighton SO meeting 6.00, Further Education College. Pelham St SO London Forums Monday 8 April "The politics of famine' Monday 22 April "Pornography and Censorship"

Conway Hall, Red Lion quare, London WC1, 7: the UN and for troops out, but it did nothing to try to shape and direct the whole anti-war movement.

CND's top officials and their allies, in the Committee to Stop War; the "Revolutionary Communist Party" with its campaign for "Victory to Iraq!"; and Socialist Organiser, in alliance with Socialist Outlook in the Campaign Against War in the Gulf, Labour Against the War, Trade Unionists Against the War, and the Student Federation Against War in the Gulf - we all made our various efforts to shape and lead the anti-war movement, efforts good or bad, successful or unsuccessful. SW made no such effort.

John Molyneux is right, after all, that theory is important. No amount of good theory could have radically increased the opposition to the war. But good theory, in the hands of a substantial organisation, could have helped to sharpen the antiwar movement and to teach anti-war activists how to continue the struggle against the all!

March)? Far from it! The An obvious starang point Stop War in the Gulf. S4 appointed usel gatekeeper disastrous course backed all the wav emerge.

CPB and CPGB.

plied by on the the Mandel group, SA have roots of war. As Frank Kitz comments, the point is neither to laugh nor to cry, but to understand - and we arrive at understanding by debate and polemic such as I attempted in my criticism of SWI Frank Kitz doubts "whether it is possible for honest socialists to stay in a Labour Party headed by the butcher of Walworth Road". But he answers his own argument.

Neil Kinnock's shameful line on the war made the antiwar movement much smaller than it could have been. Whether SWP leader Chris Bambery was closer in his understanding of the war to Leon Trotsky or the tooth fairy (l'd say the tooth fairy) made relatively little difference.

It was vital for honest socialists to do all they could to build the opposition to Kinnock where it mattered most, inside the Labour Party, rather than remaining on the sidelines and giving Kinnock a clear run.

Martin Thomas Islington SA are not alone in this view;

An- Add to this Socialist Action's do, say or think"; their optheir predilection for wild inbad lot, as wild-eyed Trots Dies Phil Edwards

Scan page 15

defend Pat Markey! Socialist Organiser No. 480 page 15

----- pull-quotes -----

ot the same at " Nitical differences!- was an outright defeat for the

PS in Monday 8 April

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 480

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →