Movie writer Pauline Kael retires "The sharpest film critic ever
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-03-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
grands are adowed to stay caused by outsiders doing the jobs, allowed to stay, because of the There was not a whiff of a sug- between the two countries involved. gestion that these people be dealt Does this new method of reporwith by locking them up in airport ting represent a turn-around in the aminations of the women to make migrants, British.
that only bona fide relatives All of a sudden there's nothing Film Belinda Weaver mourns Pauline Kael's retirement Pauline Kael is stepping has held, either singly or in haven't read her, is (in my opinion)
the most interesting film writer around. Her retirement is a shame and a loss to anyone interested in movies.
For my money, Kael is the sharpest, most intelligent, most consistent and most individual film critic ever. She is the one film writer whose books of collected reviews sell consistently well. They aren't just ephemeral stuff. They have lasting value, both as entertainment and as a guide to twenty-five years of movie history.
All of which sounds rather pious and dull. But Kael is never dull.
Infuriating at times, yes, but never boring. Her reviews are slangy and easy to read, and even if you disagree wholeheartedly, her review is still stimulating stuff. She helps you see what you saw in a wholly new way. Her words win you over.
Quite often, you find you've come round to her way of seeing a movie.
Kael began her film writing career with Sight and Sound, but she never really belonged there. Here style is much freer and looser than the rather hermetic, theory-dense prose of most Sight and Sound writing. At the New Yorker, she found her place. She wrote what she liked, they didn't change a word, and the public lapped it up.
Her reviews alone are worth keeping, but she has never concerned herself solely with films. She has always been interested in the film business, and the ways the industry has changed and developed since the collapse of the old studio system. In her collections of reviews, there is usually at least one long article on the current state of film making. Occasionally pessimistic, she is nonetheless hopeful on the whole about movies. She believes they're worth caring about, worth arguing for.
Kael has never believed that a film critic should be a dry and abstract theoretician, or worse, an extension of a film studio's publicity department. If a film is bad, she says so, and she tells you why - not in wordy theories, but in simple trenchant language.
She has offended all kinds of people - film producers, stars, studio heads - but she keeps on. They fear her because she can back up what she says. Step by step, she takes a film apart and shows us what it's really made of.
If she is unhappy about movies today, it's largely Hollywood she is chastising — the Hollywood where the real art form is no longer the movie, but the deal.
In Taking it all in, she says:
*The studios no longer make movies primarily to attract and please moviegoers; they make movies in such a way as to get as much as possible from the prearranged and anticipated deals. Every picture (allowing for a few excep tions) is cast and planned in terms of those deals. Though the studio is very nappy when it has a box offic nit, it isn't terribly concerned abou the people who come out grumbling. They don't grumble very loudly anyway, because even the lumpiest pictures are generally an improve. ment over television; at least they're always bigger. They [the studio heads) feel safe with big-star packages, with chase thrillers, with Pauline Kael known ingredients...There is an even grimmer side to all this: because the studios have discovered how to take the risk out of moviemaking, they don't want to make any movies they can't protect themselves on. Production and advertising costs have gone so high that there is genuine nervous panic about risky projects. If an executive Jinances what looks like a perfectly safe, stale piece of material and backs it with stars, and the produc. tion costs skyrocket way beyond the guarantees, and the picture loses many millions, he won't be blamed for it — he was playing the game by the same rules as everybody else. If however, he takes a gamble on a small project that can't be sold in advance - something a gifted director really wants to do, with a subtle, not easily summarised theme, and no big names in the cast - and it loses just a little money, his neck is on the block. So to the executives a good script is one that attracts a star, and they will make 'It's becoming tough for a movie that isn't a big media-created event to find an audience, no Redford, and any number of sureto-be-blockbusters that no amount of hyping could sell.
Of the blockbuster phenomenon, she writes in Reeling:
"It's becoming tough for a movie that isn't a big media-created event to find an audience, no matter how good it is. And if a movie has been turned into an event, it doesn't have to be good; an event - such as Papillon - draws an audience simply because it's an event. You don't expect Mount Rushmore to be a work of art, but if you're anywhere near it, you have to go; Papillon is a movie Mount Rushmore, though it features only two heads...[People] want what everyone's talking about", and even if they don't like the picture...tney don't feel out of it."
In Kiss Kiss Bang Bang, she has nothing but contempt for the Hollywood money men who see themselves as "creative":
*The men in the movie business who can work regularly and talk publicly about their creative freedom are those whose fundamental aspirations (they really have no convictions) are the same as those of the studio heads - to b successful, to be acclaimed... Bein, creative means knowing how to ex "Not for her a wishy-washy retelling of the plot, followed by a half-hearted exhortation to ploit other people's ideas or earlier work you remember; being creative justifies ignorance and ruthlessness, indifference and finally even contempt for art. Being creative is having something to sell, or knowing how to sell something, or having sold something..It's in this context that picture-making is considered a creative business...Despite their protestations...they enjoy the power. of packaging something for the millions and they're contemptuous of something that reaches only a few thousand people - even though what the millions buy may be so readily consumed that it has no more effect than one candy bar eaten by an adolescent already disfigured by acne, and even though the work that fails' now because it appeals only to a few thousand or a half a million may add a few thousand more year by yea may perhaps be of lasting value.
What distinguishes Kael's writing, apart from its readibility, is that she consistently takes a stand, argues a point of view. Not for her a wishy-washy retelling of the plot, followed by a half-hearted exhortation to "go and see it and make up your own mind". She argues for the films she thinks are important, and she is ruthless about films she considers trash.
Not that she is high-minded. She enjoys "bad films" — films so bad they're funny - as much as anyone. She can see they're as much fun, maybe even more fun, than some "good" films. Of Arnold Schwarzenegger's Raw Deal, she writes:
"Raw Deal is reprehensible and enjoyable, the kind of movie that makes you feel brain dead in two minutes — after which point you're ready to laugh at its mixture of trashiness, violence and startlingly silly crude humour...It's lucky that Irvin [the director] doesn't ask us to believe in anything on the screen: that solves the problems of how to react to its star, Arnold Schwarzenegger... Schwarzenegger was ideally cast as the fearsome humanoid in The Terminator, but how can you make a hero out of a man who as an actor seems likably, harmlessly gaga, and who appears to have hams implanted above his eiDows?
All the same, she has never equated lowest common denominator films with good "bad" films. Formula films, rehashes of earlier successes, raids on old, worn-out genres, or the current rash of sequels all came under fire from her as evidence of the bankruptcy of Hollywood's "creative" community.
Kael's words were a compass to steer by. You might agree or disagree, but she was a pole you could depend on. She was consistent.
Though I found lately that 1 disagreed with her more and more, I still found her entertaining, pithy, witty and easy to read.
her work has lasting value and I think it has, it is because she has consistently punctured pretension, consistently exposed the crassness of Hollywood/money values, and consistently argued for the few good films and film makers around. She has pushed good films, wherever she found them, and in doing so, has kept alive what's most worthwhile about movies - she has helped us find and value the precious few films that make us feel and think and see the world in ways we hadn't thought of before.
*special relationship that existed thinking of the powers that be?
wrong with crossing borders, finpotential race riot. And of edito stay mere
----- pull-quotes -----
down as film critic of the New Yorker, a position she
collaboration with other writers, for more than twenty years. Pauline Kael, for those who
'go and see it and make up your own mind'."