Revenge and the Palestinians
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-03-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
AGAINST THEI TIDE Sean Matgamna s you read this, terrible things are Kuwait by vengeful Kuwaitis. Of the 200,000 or so Palestinians in Kuwait — a high proportion of them Kuwaitiborn — god knows how many have now been killed or tortured or rounded up and imprisoned.
The settling of scores and the meting out of summary punishment - frequently arbitrary, unjust, and savage — is a normal feature of overturns such as that which the flight of the Iraqi army has allowed the Kuwaitis to carry out. Aggressive cruelty is also "liberated" , and people who were recently in fear of their lives act out the part played by their recent oppressors, hunting "collaborators", "quislings" , and suspect foreigners of all sorts.
"Moral judgements on the Palestinians in Kuwait who collaborated with the Iraqis tell us nothing about the attitude we should take to them where basic rights are concerned."
It does seem to be true that there was extensive Palestinian collaboration with the Iraqis. That should surprise no-one. Many Palestinians in Kuwait had lived too long as hewers of wood and drawers of water not to be antagonistic to the caste of privileged Kuwaitis; the PLO's support for Saddam Hussein must have translated "on the ground" into more than mere words; and the well-publicised mass enthusiasm for Saddam of the West Bank and Gaza Palestinians must have had its counterpart among Palestinians in Kuwait.
Now, after the defeat of Iraq, the PLO and the Palestinians stand disgraced. They are, lots of people seem to think, no longer worto a homeland is inalienable thy of support, or less worthy than they used to be. The realpolitik case for "solving"' the *Palestinian problem" remains, but the moral drive based on recognition of the Palestinians' rights and indignation at the injustice they suffer is weakened.
he Palestinians are in some measure experiencing what the Israeli Jews have experienced over the last ten or 20 years: a massive loss of sympathy.
After the Holocaust sank into people's consciousness there was much sympathy for the Israeli Jews, for decades. Then, slowly, it eroded. The prolonged occupation of the West Bank and Gaza and the repression of the Palestinians; the consequences in world capitalism of the Arab use of oil as a weapon of economic pressure after the Yom Kippur war of 1973; the development of close alliances between the metropolitan capitalist countries and some Arab states - all shifted the way people saw the Israeli Jews. The intifada — an unarmed people standing up to the powerful and brutal Israeli army of occupation — finally turned general "public opinion" very hostile to Israel.
For the left, the hostility had come much earlier — from the Six Day war of 1967 and shortly after, as Israel assumed the repulsive role of an oppressive colonial power.
To the left the Israeli Jews became though not in these words - d *bad people", undeserving of support and forfeiting their right to self-determination because of Israel's treatment of the Palestinian Arabs.
seems to me that what has happened with the Palestinians in broad public opinion shows in a fresh light just how wrong and false is the attitude the left has taken up towards the Israeli Jews.
The idea that because of the PLO's alliance with Saddam Hussein and the oppressive behaviour of some Palestinians in Kuwait the Palestinians are proven a "bad people", or a people who have forfeited or had diminished their basic right to self-determination - that is the same idea that the left has about the Israeli Jews. It is false and destructive.
There are neither good nor bad peoples. People in general behave in certain ways in certain conditions. Moral judgments on the Palestinians in Kuwait who collaborated with the Iraqis are neither here nor there politically: they tell us nothing about the attitude we relive it On 26 March 1871 the first workers' government ever was set up — the Paris Commune.
Prussia had defeated France in war, and France's bourgeois government signed an agreement giving the Prussian troops the right to enter Paris. The workers of Paris rebelled.
The Commune survived only nine weeks until the capitalist government at Versailles deporting others. The Commune's positive socialist measures were necessarily limited.
But what it did do led Karl Marx to write: "Workingmen's Paris, with its Com mune, will live forever as the glorious harbinger of a new society."
should take to them where basic rights are concerned. Likewise, moral judgment on the Israelis has no weight when their right to self-determination is under discussion.
Socialists try to understand why people behave in certain ways in certain circumstances, and look for change in those circumstances. We make moral judgments, but we do not lose sight of the historical realities.
All peoples are capable of becoming oppressors. It is a central concern of Marxists — it was a central concern, for example, of Lenin when dealing with the national question in the Tsarist Empire and in Eastern Europe — that while supporting the oppressed we do not support them in demands which would make them oppressors of others. For example: we support the Northern Ireland Catholics. We do not support Irish Catholic nationalist proposals that would exchange half a million oppressed Catholics for one million oppressed Protestants coerced into a united Ireland.
t the heart of the process that turned the left comprehensively hostile •to Israel and to "Zionists" was a moral feeling that the long-oppressed Jews should know better, a moral outrage and indignation that they didn't.
Yes, the Jews should know better. In a world controlled by reason and morality which truly takes account of experience properly evaluated from the standpoint of a common humanity, they would. But that is not the world we live in. In our world the experience of national oppression and crazy chauvinism helps a few of its victims rise above it to a higher human standpoint: it convinces most of its surviving victims that they must in future be more assertive, more self-reliant, more ruthless, quicker on the draw for their own cause, their own nationalism, their own chauvinism.
That is what Hitler did to the Jews; that is what Israel has done to the Palestinians, though you cannot compare what happened to Europe's Jews with what has happened to the Palestinian Arabs. It is a common human Above: supporters of the Commune on the barricades. On the right: Louise Michel, one of the leaders of the Commune.
experience wherever there is national or communal conflict.
Modern Irish nationalism was reshaped and hardened into a new determination and ruthlessness by the memory of the murderous famines between 1845 and '49, which depopulated Ireland while the landlords, protected by the foreign English government, exported food. People born a hundred years later look back with shame - and, worse, sometimes with pangs of questioning, embittering doubt about their own nature, as part of a people who could let this happen to them - on the passivity with which so many easy-going, goodnatured people let themselves be starved to death or driven off the land: it is, even today a living factor in the ruthlessness of the IRA.
It is not Marxism which teaches that suffering makes you morally better, but mystical Christianity! "Socialists deal not in moralism but in programmes and perspectives for action. The Palestinian Arabs have an inalienable right to self-determination; so do the Jews.
The left will stand up to the backlash against the Palestinians. The left should also re-examine its own parallel "backlash"" against Israel.
There are no good peoples and no bad peoples. Inere are only peoples struggling blindly in human pre-history. Serious socialists are moralists, but we do not confuse morality with an understanding of the imperatives of historical and political events as they really evolve and will continue to evolve until the working-class as a conscious force, a "class for itself" , transforms them.
Socialists deal not in moralism but in programmes and perspectives for action. The Palestinian Arabs have an inalienable right to self-determination; so do the Israeli Jews.
Scan page 11
Supporters greet Hugh Callaghan - one of the Birmingham Six - on orensic fools Scientific evidence contritions of the Birmingham Six and to the loss of their appeal. It has also contributed to their acquittal after 16 years of imprisonment.
While the freeing of the Six will highligh: the dishonesty and brutality of the interrogating police officers, it also calls into question the role of the forensic service, funded by the government but not therefore licensed to distort the evidence against the accused.
Had they handled explosives?
Evidence that some of the Six had handled nitroglycerine came from two sources: forensic scientist Dr Frank Skuse reported the presence of nitroglycerine in hand swabs from Patrick Hill and William Power and Dr Janet Drayton reported a "possible positive" for nitroglycerine from a second swab from Hill. Despite the doubt cast over Skuse's evidence in the 1988 appeal (he was later compulsorily retired on grounds of limited efficiency"), the judges placed great faith in Dr Drayton's tenative view.
Now Skuse used the Greiss test for the presence of nitroglycerine. This involves the use of a solution of sodium hydroxide, the strength of whichis crucial to the sensitivity of the test. Later investigators found that with the concentration said to have been used by Skuse they obtained many "positive" results for other substances which also contain the nitro- chemical group.
These include nitrocellulose, found in the coating of some playing cards and smoking on the train to Heysham before their arrest. Skuse then claimed to have used a different concentration of sodium hydroxide but this would have implied such a level of contamination that the men would have been ill from nitroglycerine poisoning (it is used in small doses to treat the symptoms of heart disease.
However, recent findings by leading government scientists mean that it is possible that the positive results obtained by Skuse may have been due to a substance present on his own hands. Drs John Lloyd and Alan Scaplehorn obtained positive results from the liquid soap in use in 1974 and with which Skuse had washed his hands and his equipment. Skuse had in fact got positives from the equipment alone (ie. without the hand swabs), a hitherto inexplicable finding.
Also not mentioned at the trial was the fact that other passengers on ferries to Ireland were tested positive for the presence of explosives on their hands. They were however released when they said they had been handling rolls of adhesive tape which were then found to give positive results.
Drayton's results involved a test using gas chromatography mass spectrometry (GCMS). This works by vaporising the sample which then disintegrates into charged fragments - ions. These are accelerated by electric and magnetic fields by different amounts according to their mass. The fragment being sought was the nitro- group with a relative mass of 46 and Dr Drayton reported a "possible positive".
This means not much more than would be expected from the natural background concentration of the nitro- group. This was interpreted as showing the possible presence of nitroglycerine but, as pointed out previously, the nitro-group occurs in many other compounds, most of them innocuous.
Skuse reported Drayton's findings as his own in the original trial. Curiously, he seems not to have mentioned that his test on the hand swab used by Drayton was negative.
Drayton herself gave evidence at the 1988 appeal and the judges found her testimony particularly damning. She later said that they had misunderstood her, a point which perhaps underlines an incompatability of the legal and scientific minds, Drs Lloyd and Scaplehorn also looked at the GCMS test and found that they could obtain "positive" results for nitroglycerine from a hand swab from a smoker and from the food preservative cinnamaldehyde and various fatty acids found in food and cosmetics.
They concluded that Drayton should not even have recorded a "possible" positive, the information she had obtained being "fruitless and misleading".
It was this report that led the Director of Public Prosecutions to say that he was no longer relying on forensic evidence in defending the appeal. Drayton has now agreed that her original judgement was incorrect and she admits chat the Gas Chromatograph in question had been experiencing problems in recording the passage of samples through it. The chart for Hill's hand swab had been "lost"
The Mass Spectrometry side of the apparatus could also be monitored using an ultra-violet photography system. This would provide a check on the results of tests. Drayton said the UV system had not been switched on the day of Hill's test, but 13 years later rolls of film taken on that day were discovered. These were only made known when they were handed to Dr Lloyd's team last September. Two of the rolls were of the "background" , to test the purity of the machine. Nevertheless, they too showed a peak at a mass of 46, That left only the circumstantial evidence and the men's alleged confessions and it is with these that science has intervened.
Did they confess?
Confessions are often thought to be the strongest possible evidence of a person's guilt but there are all sorts of reasons why an innocent person might admit to a crime they hadn't committed. Some people are very suggestible; others are so claustrophobic that they will do anything to get out; others believe they will be found guilty anyway and know they will get a lighter sentence if they don't argue; some are simply beaten into submission.
But what about those people who won't confess. Do the police simply insert extra sheets before the prisoner's signature? Until recently, this has been difficult to detect but there is now a test called ElectroStatic Document Analysis (ESDA) which can show by analysis of the imprint on following pages whether the pages of a statement were written at the same time.
ESDA of Richard Mellkenny's interview notes show that, in his first interview, the first six pages were of a different type to the last three and were written in a different ball-point pen. His second interview notes were on 19 pages from four different pads and were also not written at the same time.
The record of the timings of interviews in Detective Superintendent Reade's notebook (he was in overall charge of the case) were also found to have been altered or added to later.
The issues raised by the case are manifold, but paramount among them are those concerning the scientific integrity of the Home Office Forensic Service. An incredible sloppiness seems to have been a feature of the work of some of the scientists, who, once they had an answer suggesting the guilt of a person, were unwilling to carry out confirmatory tests or were unwilling to accept the results of these if they did not support the initial findings.
There is also the fact that evidence tending to exonerate the accused was suppressed for up to 15 years. Surely the Forensic Service should have the duty to communicate its findings to the defence. It could be argued that faulty scientific evidence was the major reason for the lengthy imprisonment of the Birmingham Six, the Guildford Four, and the Maguires.
Scan page 12
ganiser THE CULTURA
----- pull-quotes -----
reconquered the city and massacred the workers, killing tens of thousands and
How scienti to keep the behind bars
fic 'experts' helpe Birmingham Six