Spare us the pretend ideology
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-03-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
WOMENIS-EMEI Millward he Christian Church has a parable about three men being given a number of "talents" (in those days a form of money).
The first man frittered his talents away on wine, women and song and was left in debt. The second man buried his talents, neither using nor abusing them, consequently getting nowhere. The third man used his talents to the full, putting them to work, so finishing up much better off than when he started.
I would like to offer the following alternative parable. Three women were each given a number of talents (in our sense of talents). The first woman used all her talents making herself beautiful so that a talented man would come along and look after her for the rest of her life. This is the equivalent of feeding a cow on grain then eating the cow. Why not just eat the grain? Or use the talents?
The second woman denied she had any talents. She thought she was a worthless person and that all the talents had been given to other people. Consequently she went through life feeling bad, and the world was a poorer place for it.
The third woman used her talents to the full. But she had a miserable life too because everyone said she was trying to be like a man.
The fourth woman would argue that she reads Cosmopolitan and so has the best of all possible words. (But that's rubbish, actually she reads SO!)
read two women's magazines this month Spare Rib and Vanity Fair. I have to say that Spare Rib is about as interesting as Derek Hatton's memoirs.
The first 25 pages are filled with interminable badly written letters about the ideology of Spare Rib. The rest of the magazine consists of badly pasted up listings and Much of the "debate" in the last issue concerned women's "erotica", in other words dreary verse versus lesbian S&M. Examples of both had been provided the previous month. •I thought Spare Rib was quite brave to publish the S&M piece, which was explicit. Unfortunately, the quality of the following debate did not justify the bravery.
People are going to go on playing out their S&M tantasies whether they are ideologically sound or not. Other people are going to write down their fantasies to share them.
I cannot see that such fanliberating, on a world scale. tasies (realised or not) are On the other hand, I am not in favour of the ideologues of the bedroom trying to "stop" such fantasies escaping into practice or onto paper.
Truly the best of all possible worlds would be if so-called feminists stopped writing to Spare Rib about it, and spend their time worrying about something important.
Vanity Fair by contrast treats its readers as sentient beings, capable of sustaining concentration for more than 5 minutes. From the outside the magazine looks like Cosmopolitan. Inside it has several long articles on current events (Palestine for example).
It's like the Economist with beauty advertisements. It had nothing about sex! Vanity Fair is what a woman's magazine ought to be (without the advertisements preferably).
Women deserve better than the banality of Cosmo or the pettiness of Spare Rib. Women are not an alien species who need snappy guides to a great sex life because we are too stupid to read anything else.
Women need Spare Rib and its pretend ideology like we need a hole in the head.
inis