Lecturers chopped for speaking out
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-03-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Special ticket offer! hael Cohen (left) and Colwyn Williamson: suspended for speaking out "A used to be a slogan cademic standards of the right" • says Colwyn Williamson. "We now see it as a slogan of the left".
Williamson and another philosophy lecturer, Michael Cohen, were suspended from their jobs and banished from the college premises by the Council of University College Swansea on Monday 25 March. A third lecturer, Anne Maclean, was suspended in November 1990 and forced to resign in February this year; a fourth, Geott Hunt, quit, dissatisfied, in June last year. The row is all because the lecturers spoke out to question academic standards in the College's Centre for Philosophy and Health Care.
"The economic pressures on academic administrators" • says Colwyn Williamson, are making them hysterical. They're desperately competing for students, with fewer and fewer resources to deal with them. There is tremendous pressure to lower "We are not against more students coming to university, far from it; but the resources necessary to maintain standards in the face of increased numbers must be provided"
The criticisms have provoked such sharp reaction, says Colwyn Williamson, because of the "new management style" in colleges like Swansea, which mostly means "just acting tough"
"By the end of 1989", report Williamson and Collen, *53 MA dissertations had been submitted in that year by students in the Centre... the examiners found them all worthy of the degree... (This) might suggest an exceptionally high standard of work, but it might also suggest that the examiners were not doing their job properly"
The students had to submit a dissertation and "a minimum of four" essays. But one student got an MA having submitted only two essays, another having submitted only one. One successful dissertation had been copied word for word from books - to the extent of at least 4,257 of its 9,500 words - and the student's tutor had warned the examiners in advance that there might be such copying.
How the examining board decided to pass such candidates is unclear because, according to Cohen and Williamson, it looks as if the examining board never met.
The teaching on the MA course consists mainly of five 2½ day conferences held over the two years of the course. The speakers are mostly prestigious medical figures, rather than academic philosophers.
The sessions tend - so the critics say - towards ambling debates on issues like abortion or euthanasia, rather than any sustained academic study.
"One persistent request made by students was for reading lists... in advance... but it was not taken up"
The students for the MA are mostly doctors and other healthcare workers, and their applications are usually supported by references rather than academic qualifications. Cohen and Williamson cite a statement from two former secretaries of the Centre: "We were never asked to write for references and we never saw any references. At no time did we arrange interviews for applicants... » Almost all applicants were accepted. A PhD student proved unable to spell the word "university"
Cohen and Williamson question the whole rationale of the Centre. It was launched in 1986-7, they say, as an effort to "make philosophy useful and relevant, and give it a value in the market-place. It purports to teach doctors and others how to deal with the ethical problems of modern medical technologies".
This market-oriented approach **is a paradigm of the priorities that are now expected to govern universities"
The lecturers union, the AUT, has supported the critics' call for an inquiry into the academic standards of the Centre by qualified people from outside the College. On Friday 22nd the authorities halfconceded this demand, commissioning an inquiry by Sir Peter Swinnerton-Dyer, Chief Executive of the Universities Funding Council. Cohen and Williamson are arguing for academic philosophers from outside the University of Wales to be involved in the inquiry, and A weekend of socialist Dozens of speakers from a of socialist opinion gather days of debate. Many inti guests.
Caxton House, North Friday 28-Sunday 39 wide rang for three ernational. protesting that the inquiry has been pre-empted by the decision to suspend and banish them.
A slate supporting the critics has swept the board in the Swansea Student Union elections. Colwyn Willis on papa for acade the that the standards is net directed against students: on the contrary, they want to make sure that students are offered something worth studying.
Essex University Students' Union has passed a resolution calling on all students to boycott Swansea for postgraduate work until it reinstates the critics.
Cohen, Williamson and their allies want to extend their battle into a national campaign for academic standards and for adequate public spending on higher education, mobilising both lecturers and students. They have set up a Fighting Fund, and ask for contributions (cheques payable to *Academic Standards Fighting Fund"') to Chris Arthur, 17 Bristol Road, Brighton BN2 1AP.
creche • food • accommodation Special ticket offer! Before end of April: unwaged f4; studen low-waged f7; waged E10 (Thes prices are for Saturday & Sunday Add E1 (unwaged) and E2 (other)
tickets which include Friday.)
Name..
Address.
Return to Alliance for Workers* Liberty, c/o PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA. Cheques to "Workers"
Liberty'
Scan page 6
nis
----- pull-quotes -----
Workers' Liberty 9