Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

What should we say about local taxes?

Socialist Organiser no. 480, 28 March 1991 · scan p. 4 · Colin Foster · about 666 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

The Tories are now proposing a combined property-plus-poll tax to replace the poll tax.

Labour says councils should have a revised version of the rates (a property tax). The Liberal Democrats favour a local income tax.

What should socialists say?

No system of local taxes, however well-designed, can undo the inequality and injustice of capitalism. Only collective ownership and democratic control of the wealth of society can do that.

But some sorts of taxes are participation" , the Social Contract. better, or less bad, than others.

Property taxes, or rates, have one great advantage. They are simple and easy to administer. That's an advantage not just for administrators but also for socialists. Rich people will always find ways to evade any complicated tax. They can't evade rates.

Moreover, businesses have to pay rates out of their prothe government, then we will do it." fits as well as workers having to pay out of our wages.

Rates mean the rich paying more than the poor, But -and this is the big disadvantage - they tend to mean the rich paying a smaller proportion of their income than the poor, because the poor spend more of their income on housing than the rich.

Rate rebates compensate, but clumsily and partially.

Small businesses also suffer from the rates system, because they have to pay more in rates, as a proportion of their turnover, than bigger businesses.

Some of these problems could be reduced by making rates more flexible. Why shouldn't councils be able to charge more rates per pound of property value on bigger, more costly buildings than on small, cheap buildings? Why shouldn't councils be able to set rates on businesses. much higher than rates on homes, rather than the relation between them being set by Whitehall?

Local income taxes have the advantage that your tax rate is decided directly by your ability to pay. They have two disadvantages: they can be no fairer than the national income tax system, with all its loopholes for the rich; and, like the poll tax, they involve some sort of local "register" of people in each council's area.

Again, a • more flexible system could be better. Why shouldn't councils be able to claim a sort of "poll tax" from the employers of workers who live in their area (and from the central government for unemployed people in the same way that the National Insurance fund collects employers' contributions? After all, employers wouldn't have a workforce without the education, housing, and social services provided by the council: why shouldn't those employers help pay?

Central government grant to councils is good in that it siphons money from rich areas to poor areas where the council has a lot to do and few rich people to get any sort of tax from. What's bad about it is that it can give central government excessive power to control and victimise local councils - power which the Tories have used ruthlessly.

Central government grant should be decided by predictable formulas which the government can't easily alter.

Generally, socialists should support local government having more autonomy to raise its own income and make its own decisions. Local councils in Britain are much more restricted in what they can do than councils in other countries.

Several times since 1979 courts have found the Tory government to be breaking the law. Each time the Tories have just changed the law to square it with what they want to do.

Local councillors, in contrast, can be hauled up in court when they have broken no definite law but only done what the District Auditor reckons to be "imprudent". Labour councillors in Liverpool have been disqualified from office and fined huge sums for their delay in setting a rate in 1985.

Central government needs to be much more subject to the law, and local government needs to be much less subject to central government.

Such reforms would mean more local democracy and more scope for genuinely socialist local councils.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 480

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →