Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Rottenness in an ideal world

Socialist Organiser no. 479, 14 March 1991 · scan p. 14 · about 442 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

'm sorry I didn't convince Lilian Thompson with my defence of David Lynch.

I think this is because she's taking much too superficial a view of his work, starting from a knee-jerk reaction to the scenes of violence against women and missing the main themes altogether.

The 'wrath of God' stuff in particular has now been shown to be well wide of the mark. Laura was not inherently bad but had her life wrecked, then ended, by her father. Catherine Martell was not in fact immolated for her sins but has re-emerged as a strong, independent female character, while the 'nice girl' Maddy has been horribly murdered. -I'd venture to suggest that the point of Twin Peaks is this. Lynch has set up what Manchester Town Friday 22 March Camden Nicaragua Associatio Social: Roberto Pla (jazz) and Farolas Y Pepe (flamenco). E5/E3. Conway Hall, Red Lion Square, London 7.30.

Saturday 23 March National anti-poll tax demonstration, London. 12.00, Embankment Monday 25 March Socialist Organiser London Forum. "Their New Order". 7.30pm, LSE, Houghton Stree Speakers from Socialist Organser and include Kurdish Thursday 28 March "For democracy in the Middle East". Speakers from Palestian, Kurdish, Iraqi and Iranian groups. 7.30 Pakistani City Centre. Organised by Manchester CAWG. the likes of Ronald Reagan and the Moral Majority would consider an ideal world - tweeting robins, cherry pie and lumberjack shirts He then shows us that it's rotten literally to the core — the nuclear family personified by the Palmers is a nest of child abuse and now murdet.

The 'perfect society" is based on the abuse of women, naked capitalist and male power, intimidation and violence. Agent Cooper's inability to solve the crime and prevent the second murder is due to his wilfully naive belief in Twin Peaks as utopia.

Characters like 'Bob' and Frank in Blue Velvet are shown as wholly bad and terrifying. They are also shown as potentially part of every man. Lynch is asking important questions about male violence and about how we deal with it, how basically poisonous desires get into the subconscious of men and women alike and how hard they are to shift.

While there is a debate to be had about whether women should be portrayed as victims, I think this is a separate issue from whether a particular work is misogynist in itself.

Lynch certainly sets out to shock, but whether this can be classed as 'titillation for big bucks' rather than an attempt to confront difficult issues is a moot point. Certainly I think there are more positive inferences to be drawn from his work than those Ms Thompson has made.

James Shelley, Streatham.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 479

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →