Israel: outrage is not enough
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-03-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
Increase Sou're wrong at orry, Join Anderson, but but Israel, about the Palestinians, and about SO too (Letters, SO 478).
Firstly, you confuse the Israeli government with the Israeli nation. Yes, Israel has a nawkish, aggressive government, but does that necessarily mean the nation of Israel should have no right to exist? On that criterion, every state in the world should be closed down. (I would like to see all states disappear under socialism, but that's another issue).
Most Israelis now in Israel were born there; they have, for better or worse, formed a nation, and have the right to exist behind secure borders. Yes, they seized the land from the Palestinians, but most modern states were formed by conquest.
The only difference between Israel and a country like the US is that Israel seized land recently. To be consistent, you should be telling Americans to get out of American, Australians to get out of Australia, but you're not. Why not, if you believe that Israel should get out?
You don't say where they should go. You have no answer beyond saying Israelis and Palestinians should live together in one state. But that is no answer. You can't remove deeply-felt antagonisms by wish or by decree. Neither Israel nor the Palestinians want your solution.
What the Palestinians want is their own state, not a state shared with someone else, and unlike you, they recognise the right of Israel to "The Palestinians want their own state" exist. They may not like it any more than you do, but at least they are living in the real world.
It's not enough to have feelings of outrage. Solutions must be found. SO's position - a two-states position — is the position of the PLO, so your jibe that we have ig nored them is silly. You are the one out of step.
Your position is the one the PLO has thrown overboard, perhaps realising at last that it doesn't mean two nations living side by side in harmony within one state, but merely the conquest of the Israelis.
Maybe that would satisfy some primitive urge for blood revenge, but it would not be a lasting solution. The answer to the Israel/Palestinian question is not a perpetual seesaw, with each nation coming suCcessively out on top. The only answer is a division of the cake, with each side having uncontested control over its own piece.
Belinda Weaver, Islington.