Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Pills to Q - or boost profits

Socialist Organiser no. 479, 14 March 1991 · scan p. 14 · about 468 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

Lince BBC1 showed th follow-up study on th link between vitamin consumption and IQ last Wednesday (7th), chemists's shops all over the country have emptied.

The investigation was carried out by, among others, Professor Hans Eysenck - al psychologist who, in his book Race, Gender and Intelligence "proved" that genetically women and blacks are less intelligent than white men.

The study was of 615 children aged 12-16 years in California. They were divided into four groups. One took the full recommended daily amount of vitamins, one twice the amount, one half the amount, and the other quarter took placebos (pills with no active ingredient at all).

IQ improved an average of 3.7 points among those taking: the full recommended amount of vitamins.

There are lots of methodological problems. The were never given an initial IQ test, so could not be compared. It could have been a sample biased towards younger children, and the results could just be from a "growth spurt". The results for the other three groups were never explained.

And, apart from all that, the programme never questioned the class issues in health and education.

Many children's diets do lack vitamins. Working-class kids often get poor diets - little fresh fruit and vegetables lovingly prepared, no fresh orange juice instead of fizzy pop.

And they live in poorer hous ing. They have less access to schooling and educational materials. They have less time. and space to study, often shar: ing a bedroom with brothers and sisters. Parents are too tired to help them with homework, and cannot give them the personal computer or the private lessons afforded to middle class kids.

The only decent meal some kids get is the "free school meal" , which many councils ar slashing to stop getting poll-tax capped. Free milk has long gone.

It is interesting to see who funds big research projects like these. Booker, the Nutritional Products manufacturer, has now launched two types of vitamin pill, one for children aged 7 to 10 years, another for older children, even though no studies have been carried out o under-11s.

Robert Maxwell was one of the three backers behind the research, and sure enough on Thursday Vitachieve's special offer was given a large advertisement in the Daily Mirror. This apparently was the last straw which led to the resignation of Mirror editor Roy Greenslade.

The study reminded me of one done after the Second World War, when the Government was encouraging women back into the home, which stressed the importance of the mother in child-bonding and later psychological well-being.

It looks like another example IQ.

----- pull-quotes -----

By Rebecca Homan

groups were not matched for age, sex or initial IQ. A third

of big business's attempt to boost profits, with another pro mise of eternal youth or higher

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 479

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →