Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Crime at the top

Socialist Organiser no. 479, 14 March 1991 · scan p. 13 · about 990 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

Film Belinda Weaver revie WS Godfather, part 3"

The Godfather, part 3" leaps twenty years to 1979 from where it ended in part 2. The Corleone family has pulled out of the gambling business and gone legitimate.

In the lavish ceremony that opens the film, Michael, 'the Godfather' (Al Pacino), is endowed with a papal decoration for his charitable work.

It seems the family has finally pulled itself out of criminality into the mainstream of American capitalist success.

But this is misleading. Within moments, we're back in a darkened room, Michael is behind a desk with his bodyguard beside him, and he's intervening yet again in the kind of dispute he had hoped to leave behind him.

To make matters worse, one of the men quarrelling is his nephew, Vincent (Andy Garcia), the illegitimate son of his murdered brother Sonny. Vincent has inherited all his father's foolhardiness and brash manner, and he's triggerhappy. When in doubt, shoot first, seems to be his motto.

Vincent looks, and is, trouble. All the same, this is the man Michael must tame, to groom him for the succession. Michael's own son has repudiated the family business, just as Michael himself once did. An alternative must be found. Only Vincent fits the bill.

The Michael Corleone of "Godfather 3" is a very different man from "Godfather 2" , and it shows in his face, which is dry and stiff, as if the juices have been sucked out of him. He seems tired, ready to lay down his burden, a husk of the man he was. Only his eyes, which burn intermittently, seem alive.

He's a disappointed man, caught cruelly in the ironies of his life. He tried to detach himself from criminality to save his family, but finds that the higher he climbs, the more crooked things get. The businessmen at the top are just as greedy, just as venal, as those grubbing out a living below, and they're more dangerous, because they have more to lose if they fall.

Michael makes much of his efforts to protect his family, yet it was his gangsterism that endangered them in the first place. The bloodiness of his methods drove away his wife, and alienated his children, leaving him alone and isolated.

All the bitterness of his life seems to be concentrated in Michael's face, in the heavy lines, in the brooding eyes. This is a man who gained the world, but lost his soul. He's haunted by the blood on his hands, by remorse. He has lost his taste for killing. And that makes him vulnerable.

his is a sumptuous epic, but the sumptuousness lies mainly in the settings and the soundtrack rather than in the story.

As in the two previous Godfather films, there are plenty of scenes of family gatherings in American and Sicily, and we get grand opera and the Vatican thrown in as well. But the story is uninvolving.

It takes in the Corleones' attempt to buy into respectability via the Vatican Bank and a European conglomerate, Immobiliare, and it weaves into the plot the deaths of Pope John Paul I and the banker Calvi at Blackfriars Bridge.

But for once, and mistakenly, the family's enemies are barely identified. Much is made of the gangster Joey Zasa, who confronts Michael and Vincent, but he turns out to be a pawn of people higher up. We're left unsure for a long time who the real puppet master is, and when he's unmasked, there's no "Aha!"' We barely recognise him.

For all its convoluted plot, the story is thin and meandering, with loose ends, such as the family's future in Europe, left hanging at the end. Coppola seems uninterested in the plot, as if the growing family problems absorbed him more.

There are no shortage of those. Vincent, the hothead, is romancing Michael's young daughter, Mary, against Michael's wishes. Connie, Michael's sister, has grown into a Lady Macbeth figure, always egging people on to greater violence.

It's evidence of Mafia sexism that Connie is never considered for the role of Godfather. Like Vincent, she's as hard as nails, ordering deaths as if they were dinners.

The greatest disappointment for me was Vincent, though whether the fault is Andy Garcia's or the script's is hard to tell. The role is certainly underwritten. We never get inside Vincent for a moment.

One moment, he's no more than a violent thug, the next he's a smooth, calculating Don receiving homage from his men. There's no reason for the change, we don't see him develop. We can't guess at his motives or his feelingsPerhaps he's meant to represent the third stage of the degeneration of the Mafia code. Brando's Don Corleone (Michael's father) was ruthless, but he had tamily loyalty and a code of honour, twisted though it was. Michael, in murdering his brother Fredo, betrayed the code, and Vincent seems to have no code at all. He's simply a mass of seething ambition, and at the end we're left unsure whether he betrayed Michael or not.

Though Pacino always played Michael as implacably • selfcontrolled, we could usually tell what he felt. Even in his silence, he signalled his self-disgust and alienation. Vincent signals nothing.

aken together, the three Godfather films are an epic covering the rise to wealth and power in America of an Italian immigrant family.

The Corleone family methods were simply capitalism taken to bloody extremes, competition run rampant. Unlike capitalists, though, the Mafia families prided themselves on their code.

Women and children were protected, "civilian' members of the families were not targeted.

With the coming of drugs, the competition for ever greater profits hotted up, and the code broke With Godfather 3, Coppola seems to be saying there is no code any more, that international capitalism is ruthless and implacable, that corruption reaches right to the top, and that the toughness and amorality of a Vincent are what it takes to succeed.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 479

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →