When "left wing" was what Stalin said and did
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-03-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
Soviet foreign minister Molotov (gesticulating) with Hitler at cocktail party 1940. Books Jack Cleary reviews "About Turn: The British Communist Party and the Second World War" edited by Francis King and George Matthews (Lawrence and Wishart, £34.95)
n Andrew Boyle's book The Climate summer of 1933 between young supporters of Stalin's "Communist International", among them the future Stalinist spy Kim Philby.
Hitler had been in power six months. The powerful German Communist Party (and the strong German Social Democracy) had let the Nazis take power legally and peacefully, and had then suffered a tremendous rout as the terroristic Nazis turned the power of the state against them.
"Surely" , says one of the young men, daringly, "Stalin made great mistakes in Germany. Many of the things Trotsky said were right" • Philby turned on him indignantly. "Why", he said, "what Stalin does is left"
Stalin couldn't be wrong. Outside Stalin and what he did there was no left. "L'Etat, c'est moi" — the State, it is I — said France's absolute monarch Louis XIV. The left, it is the USSR and Stalin, said many left-wingers then.
Philby's comment was a statement of the essential truth about a whole epoch of working-class history. What Stalin — and for decades after Stalin was no more, the Russian or Chinese state — did was what was "left" Much that still passes for left - and even Trotskyist - politics originates as principles read off from the practice of the bureaucratic ruling state-parties.
This book, which shows the leadership of the Stalinist British Communist Party turning itself inside out and upside down at the start of World War 2 to keep in step with what Stalin had done, illustrates the point.
From about a year after Hitler came to power until September 1939 the CPs subordinated everything to "anti-fascism" (which often became anti-Germanism: in their antiGerman ardour, the French CP were to offer publicly to unite with patriotic French fascists!) They advocated working-class alliance with Liberals and even Tories to "stop fascism". . The Stalinist police and the representatives of the bourgeoisie suppressed the working class in Republican Spain during the Civil War of 1936-9, and thereby made the ultimate victory of Franco's fascists certain.
Then, suddenly, in August 1939, the USSR and Germany signed a non-aggression pact. It freed Hitler's hands to start World War 2. On 1 September Hitler invaded Poland. On 3 September Britain and France declared war on Germany. On 17 September Stalin's army moved into Poland by prior agreement with Hitler. The fascist and Stalinist armies met in the middle of the Polish state and partitioned the country. Stalin backed the "appeal for peace now that Poland is no more" then launched by Hitler.
Hitler and Stalin were firmly locked together. Soon Stalin would act according to secret agreements with Hitler and attack Finland; a little later, in 1940, he would annex the three Baltic states. Indeed, at one moment just before the Nazi invasion of Norway and Denmark, it seemed that British troops would land in Finland, and Stalin would be in the world war on Hitler's side.
That did all this mean for the super-anti-fascist parties of the of the Communist International, parties which had grown substantially and redesigned themselves in the five years of anti-fascist Popular Front The /Molotov-Ribbentrop August 1939 sent a tremendous shock through the West European and US Stalinist world. But it could be explained. The imperialist democracies did not want to ally with the USSR, and the USSR had a right to look after itself. What the Russian state did need not affect the policies of the CPs. They were still anti-fascist, they could still support the British-French war "against fascism" of which they had long been the outspoken champions.
Or so they thought. They continued to think that for the first two weeks of the World War, and acted accordingly. The General Secretary of the CP, Harry Pollitt — who had some standing in the broader working-class movement - immediately issued a pamphlet ardently supporting the war, entitled How To Win The War. The French CP General Secretary, Maurice Thorez, went one better than Pollitt: he joined the French army! (Within weeks he was to desert and flee to Moscow).
In German-occupied France - on the eve of the Nazi occupation of the USSR - the CP had been negotiating with the Nazis for the right legally to publish 'L'Humanité", its daily paper banned by the French government in 1939. Now it swung into organising the resistance.
The penny began to drop with the Russian invasion of Poland and Stalin's support for Hitler's "peace programme" . Soon the CPs did a fantastic somersault. Not only did they discover that Britain and France were, after all, waging an imperialist war which should be opposed, but that Hitler was the injured party!
The latter discovery was made for them by the all-wise Joseph Stalin when he supported Hitler's case against Britain and France and his peace programme. Suddenly, the CPs in belligerent France and Britain, which had been built over the last five years as antifascist movements, became not only defeatist but open pro-German propagandists, agitating on behalf of Hitler's grievances against imperialist opponents!
The looser sympathisers of the CPs ran for their lives, and for their sanity, in a great stampede. The working-class hard core stayed: many of them may have found the snuggling up to Tories and Liberals and French Radicals hard to take, and the pseudo-revolutionary posturing of the CPs against their own imperialism more convincing. The working-class would-be communists stood up to the repression that followed: the French party was banned, in Britain the party daily, the Daily Worker, was eventually proscribed.
About Turn is about the discussion that took place in the leadership of the British CP after the outbreak of war when it became necessary for them either to break with Stalin and the USSR or to stand on their heads politically. It is a verbatim record of the Central Committee proceedings. It may, as the editors claim, be the only verbatim record of such a discussion in the leadership of a CP anywhere.
It is a record of how serious and dedicated people who wanted to be communists and revolutionaries, most of them with brave histories of a long struggle in working-class causes, convinced themselves in a matter of days to turn inside out most of what they had been saying for five or six years. It is a record of how the implications of the fact, for them overweening, of what Stalin had done and was saying, was worked through and rationalised from.
At the start most of the leadership seemed to be against any change of line. In little over a week all but three — Pollitt, J R Campbell, and the party's only MP, Willie Gallacher — had changed outright. But the outcome was predictable. The choice was stark — to go along with Stalin, or to break away from what they saw as the great world-wide army of working-class revolution.
That choice, faced again and again from the mid-'20s, inched millions of people who started out as communists bit by bit away from socialist politics, and destroyed the Communist International as a working-class revolutionary force. But by 1939 these people had made the choice often enough - on issues like the Moscow Trials - for the outcome now to be certain for most of them, despite the strain.
Real political discussion didn't really come into it. All of that was a matter of afterthoughts, rationalisations, and doing your best to convince yourself of Stalin's point of view. He was, after all, the very embodiment of Marxism and world revolution, and, according to the "Philby principle" , he was in a position to define what was left-wing.
That I find remarkable in the book is how much of a semblance of a real discussion they managed to put up for their own benefit.
Since there was a strong socialist case against the policy of 1934-9, genuine splinters and shards of socialist politics and revolutionary or working-class feeling could be utilised to dress up the new line dictated from Russia. Their submission to the Pope in the Kremlin could be posed as a question of loyalty to the workers' state and the revolution: that was rationalisation on a basis of faith and discipline and mind-annihilating prostration more akin to the religious discipline of the Jesuit Order in its great days 400 years earlier than to the proper mode of operation of a self-liberating and selfemancipating working class.
The words of the Internationale must have stuck in their craws: No saviour from on high deliver/ No faith have we in prince or peer/ Our own right hand the chains must sever/ Chains of hatred, greed and fear.
he decision "for the line of the Communist International" was carried with three votes against.
Within a few weeks the three had confessed their sins and "criticised their errors" Pollitt retired as General Secretary, and, since the Party didn't have a secret police to jail or shoot him, lived to come back as Secretary when everything was stood on its head once again after Hitler invaded the Soviet Union in June 1941, and to remain in the post until 1956.
Now the CP could be super-patriotic again giving all-out uncritical support to the Tory-Labour coalition government, strikethat is, a British-US invasion of Hitleroccupied Europe.
In German-occupied France, on the eve of the Nazi invasion of the USSR the CP in Paris had been negotiating with the Nazis for the right legally to publish L'Humanité, its daily paper banned by the French government in 1939. Now it swung into organising the Resistance.
Poor Thorez had it harder than Pollitt. He didn't get back to France until 1944, when he was allowed in under licence from the bourgeois "Free French" leader, General Charles de Gaulle. "Thorez" , said de Gaulle, **is a useful man to have around"
So he was: the French CP joined the bourgeois state before it was kicked away into opposition once more in 1947About Turn is edited from the viewpoint of the ex-Stalinist "God knows what we are" people around Marxism Today.
The introduction, by Monty Johnstone, is party hack work, evading many questions and issues, giving the Party the best case he can. You would not know from Johnstone about the pro-German propaganda of the party - but there it is, in, for example, the editorials by R P Dutt in Labour Monthly of November 1939 and later.
Johnstone, who was for many years the Party specialist on "Trotskyism" , and who was himself briefly a Trotskyist in the later '40s, deliberately endorses misleading statements about Trotskyist attitudes to the war. You would think the Trotskyists in Britain were indifferent to the prospects of a Nazi victory and made no distinction between Nazism and British bourgeois democracy:
In fact the Trotskyists advocated the "proletarian military policy" , which was as near to "revolutionary defencism" as you could get short of announcing it. There is a tremendous amount of confusing theology encrusted like decades of coral growth around the questions of "defeatism" and "defencism". . But it seems to me that the policy of the Trotskyist Workers' International League was right. Both sides in the war were imperialist, and they denounced Britain's imperialist war aims. But there was a great difference between British bourgeois democracy and Nazism, so they linked the call for working-class revolution to the need for an effective fight against the Nazis. They said that the working class could not trust the British bourgeoisie to fight fascism.
That was not, as you might think from the book, anything like the policy the book tells you the CP promoted in 1939-41. Even less was it anything like the actual pro-German policy the CP pursued.
The modern CP still retains the most charming traits of Stalinism even while they are knocking at the door of the Liberal Democrats and the Kinnock faction of the Pollitt is the hero of Johnstone's account. But I can't believe that even the utterly misguided Harry Pollitt of 1941-7 would recognise the Marxism Today crew as his children. Yet they are — and Stalin's children too.
Scan page 13
alist Organiser No.
----- pull-quotes -----
of Treason there is a report of a conversation in Cambridge in the
breaking, witch-hunting strikers and Trot- skyists, and advocating a "Second Front"
government and helped to disarm the French working class and rebuild the French