A thin shield for madhouse politicians
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-03-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
By nni Marjoram's letter raises some important questions.
An article by Martin Thomas in SO 477 looked at the small group round Socialist Action, which despite its general insignificance played a central role in the Committee to Stop War in the Gulf. It explored the contrast between SA's "official" line, published is its magazine ("victory to Irag!"), and its actual politics in the anti-war move ment, where it supported sanctions, opposed troops out, and helped or tried to exclude those who did campaign for troops out; and it told a little of SA's long history.
And because of that Anni Marjoram accuses us of "witch-hunting" SA. That the article provoked cries of *witch-hunt" does not surprise me, in the sense that I expected it. Nor will it surprise readers grown used to hearing cries of "witch-hunt" used as small change in polemic on the left. We have heard it before, from Militant and from the WRP for example.
The cry of "witch-hunt" is one of the most potent cries on the left. If, as the old saying has it, "patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundrel" , accusations of witch-hunting are the last refuge of those on the left who don't have any better answer to what is said about them.
Yet it should surprise us - in the sense of "startle" - that an article which deals truthfully with part of the political history of Socialist Action (Anni Marjoram does not question that it is truthful) should for that reason be accused of "witch-hunting".
Why? Why should the fact that the Ross group — while publishing an "open" revolutionary magazine — chooses to operate by worming around in various disguises with labour movement and peace movement bodies impose on us absolute silence about who they are and what, politically, they have been? Why should their "deep entry" allow such a group to shed their history (and even the politics A Workers Liberty Socialist Organiser pamphlet 75p currently publish in their magazine) and impose on us — if we don't wan to be "witch-hunters" — the obligation to be silent about that history at those politics?
Rationally, witch-hunting here
means doing things to get people expelled from the Labour Party (or, I suppose, repressed by the state). Of that there is no question. As Anni Marioram uses it, "witch-hunting" means "exposing" to the left people who operate in disguise within the broader left, even though they will not therefore be expelled or persecuted.
The article could not have helped the witch-hunters. The Labour Party bureaucracy has within itself, or seerating at ispecials in or jobs, Trotskyism", trained in the faction fights within the student movement. For a certainty they know what Socialist Action is, who is who within its operations, and where it comes from. Our article told no likely witchhunters anything they did not already know. It did not provide them with additional "proof"; nor could its publication possibly have triggered Labour Party machine into action against SA it would not otherwise take. Tribune, for example, had repeatedly identified Socialist Action "Trotskyist" and "revolutionary defeatist" long before the article appeared.
What was specific to SO's commen on SA was not the "tagging" and "identifying" — that was common property for anybody with any knowledge of the left - but that we filled in the real political history behind the name-tag. That is, we trie to educate the left about Socialist Ac tion.
Party, or in the anti-war movement, who might want to expel or exclude Socialist Action?
Then a real dilemma would arise: where to draw the line between unwillingly "helping" the expellers and "witch-hunters" and depriving antiwar activists of the light that knowledge of the political anatomy of SA would shed on the conflicts in the anti-war movement.
If the conflicts in the anti-war move ment were important - and surely they were - then who had a right to lay aside the weapon that knowledge of SA would provide to those fighting
----- pull-quotes -----
ut suppose all that did Bip people in the labor,