Thrashing out the disputes in the anti-war movemen "Your witch-hunting has destroyed what little credibility you had"
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-03-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
BL0D01 I STOP | F2 : STOP STOP CE A ST FIRE Labour Women's Action Committee ast year I was contacted as the secretary of the Labour Women's Action Committee about your campaign to stop the witch-hunt against you.
LWAC has always taken a strong line against witch-hunts, and as an organisation we of course supported the campaign.
As well as support from LWAC, I also gave permissien for my name, as an individual, to appear on leaflets in support of your campaign which were then distributed at Annual Conference.
I did this because, although I found your positions on issues such as pornography quite ridiculous and distasteful, I am willing to defend your right to be in the Party.
It is against this background that write to you about your disgraceful public witch-hunting of members of other groups on the Left. However one disagrees, organisational defeat of the politics should be the outcome, not the setting up of individual members.
You have been defeated within STOP NO STOP WAR HOWI DP WAF:
STOE STA AR 1eтmл CT/D NOW CEASETIRE STOP STOP WAR!
WAR!
NOW!
NOW Photo John Harris - that is, go on fighting their politics.
Whether Anni Marjoram means it so or not, the cry of "witch-hunt" here is a cry against Socialist Action being exposed politically, a convenient shield, a bit of demagogy to divert attention and muddy the issues.
And indeed, very often, the cry against "witch-hunting" is an expression of political and intellectual corruption in and around the would-be Trotskyist movement. It is used as a tool to suppress and inhibit discussion of facts, issues and histories, and the "Opposition to a narrow witch-hunting regime in the Labour Party should not mean the revolutionary left making ourselves always move round in the dark"
effect is to make it needlessly difficult for young people, especially, to form an overview of the movement they are interested in.
It is common for the exposure of anything discreditable about a group to be tagged as "witch-hunting" because the discreditable facts could b used by the labour bureaucracy or the state. But many things that might be so used are of such importance to the labour movement that they should nevertheless be brought out into the open.
Opposition to a narrow witch-hunting regime in the Labour Party should not mean the revolutionary li the Committee to Stop the War in the Gulf, and then you go away and start witch-hunting people you consider to be your opponents. This has destroyed what little credibility you had with major left campaigns within the Party.
to be taken too seriously again.
CIL.
making ourselves always move around in the dark, fearing alwars to light a torch because it might show up something discreditable which "could be used... history b the old Workers he clearest example in recent Revolutionary Party.
The WRP of Gerry Healy was for years a bought-and-paid-for spying and propaganda agency for Arab governments, including, until 1980 o about then, Iraq. (It even helped get some members of the Iraqi CP shot Saddam Hussein's government.)
That was all quite clear from its press (including a lavish pamphlet glorifying Saddam Hussein). It was also an utterly crazy sect.
Then in 1981 it moved into the Labour Left. It "reclaimed" the political souls of former long-time members like Ted Knight, then leader of Lambeth Council. Some of them became secret members. They launched Labour Herald, supposedly edited by Knight, Ken Livingstone, and Lambeth councillor Matthew Warburton, but actually put together by WRP member Steven Miller, and, to use a libel-avoiding formula, printed on very favourable terms by the WRP press.
(It also had local government advertising revenue).
Labour Herald was a WRP operation" — passed off as "Labour Left"
and entwined with a central part of the local government left. It had WRP politics — on the Middle East for example - and meshed into other WRP "operations".
The Herald was quickly accepted part of the mainstream left (which, The weird history of Socialist Action The offending article given its politics, tells you a lot about he mainstream left). Lots of people were taken in. You got strange ironies.
In late 1983 the WRP pulled a stunt at the time of the TUC Congress, *exposing" Arthur Scargill's attitude to Solidarnosc. Scargill's scandalous politics on Stalinism should by then have been news to no-one. But there was a big tabloid press outery, flowing from the WRP exposure. There are grounds to suspect that the WRP acted in collusion wih Fleet Street — possibly for money.
It was part of the softening-up bombardment in the build-up to the miners' strike that the Tories were preparing. Yet Arthur Scargill continued to write for the WRP-linked paper Labour Herald.
The Herald was an effective and successful "operation". It continued until the WRP exploded in 1985, and then — eloquently - died. Ken Livingstone recently was still very bitter about this collapse, attributing it to MIS.
To tell the truth to the labour move ment about Labour Herald was also, inescapably, to help possible witchhunters who wanted to move against those foolish enough to associate with the Herald. When SO did tell the truth, we were denounced as witchhunters. The supporters of the Herald could and did appeal to the antiwitch-hunt" left culture.
Yet, plainly, telling the labour movement the truth about Labour Herald overrode the many issues that were raised demagogically under the catch-all cry "witch-hunt".
It any given moment there A is a balance to be drawn between helping the enemies the left by exposing things discreditable to sections of the left, and making possible the necessary political debate within, and circulation of information in and around, the left.
The idea that always and everywhere the cardinal principle, overriding everything else, is to avoid anything that might help the witch-hunters, is a crippling absurdity. For the left to develop, it must rid itself of what is discreditable; and to do that, it must know about it and discuss it openly!
And in any case, to repeat: in terms of its likely objective effect, there was nothing in our article which amounted to witch-hunting, "fingering" , or "set ting up" Socialist Action. The article was aimed at telling the left who and what this group was which had helped reduce the centre of the anti-war movement to the politics of the madhouse. And that needed to be done.
Finally, three footnotes. No, we are not in favour of pornography: we are in favour of free speech and against censorship.
We were not "defeated within the Committee to Stop War in the Gulf", but - like a wide range of other groups - refused affiliation. We did not "go away", but continued to cam paign for a united anti-war movement and to help launch united initiatives where we could, like Labour Against the War and Trade Unionists Against the War.
While Anni Marjoram did indeed support the campaign against the ban on SO, Socialist Action did not. They did everything they could to hinder it short of directly voting against it.
Why didn't Anni Marjoram write Socialist Action complaining about their real witch-hunt against us and many others in the anti-war movement, or their lack of opposition to the real witch-hunt against us in the
----- pull-quotes -----
People like myself will always take a principled stand against anyone being witch-hunted out of the Party, but please don't expect
CHD. tuch cka