Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The violence of the oppressor and the violence of the oppressed The invention of terrorism

Socialist Organiser no. 479, 14 March 1991 · scan p. 10 · about 1,127 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Those who do not remember the past are condemned to relive it Pat Murphy Twas debated and renewed again by. he Prevention of Terrorism Act Parliament last week.

Labour put up some opposition. They quite rightly pointed to the huge number of Trish people detained under the Act and contrasted it with the tiny number charged and the even smaller number found guilty of any offence.

Labour's central argument, however, was that the Act should not be renewed because it did not prevent "terrorism". It doesn't, of course. Even a prominent Tory MP, arguing for the Act, claimed that its importance was proved by the increase in "terrorist" incidents since 1974, when the Act was introduced.

Yet Roy Hattersley's main argument against the Act - that it strengthens "terrorism" — was an exercise in ducking the issues and running scared from the Tory accusation that opposition to the Act means support for "terrorism"

What is this "terrorism"? The IRA is "terrorist" because it commits acts apparently designed to terrorise people. Iraq had to be dealt with severely because it was a "terrorist state". The USA and Britain, which carpetbombed Iraq and blitzed Baghdad for weeks, were, however, the forces of international law and order. Israel, a state which murdered thousands of civilians in Beirut in 1982 and daily terrorises the Palestinians in the occupied territories, is a faithful ally.

The use of the term "terrorist" is blatantly hypocritical. But it has very wide credence indeed. It is taken as common sense in the liberal press and the Labour Party that there is a huge moral gulf between the state of Israel, say, and the IRA. ] definite meaning in "he term "terrorist" has, or had, a Marxist The Russian Marxists applied it to non-Marxist radicals in Russia who believed that assassinations of Tsars, ministers and generals were the way to disrupt the ruling class and "electrify" the masses into action. The term "terrorism" did not in that context convey moral disgust: on the contrary, the full description was "individual terrorism" with the disapproval concentrated on the Frid for fear of involving the whole Triple Alliance.

But confrontation was only postponed.

Six months later and with 2½ million on the the employers came for the miners again.

The coal owners demanded a wage cut and this being rejected, locked-out the miners. It was now class against class.

Amidst tremendous support for the miners in the working class, the Triple Alliance was involved, a sympathetic strike being called for April 16, 1921.

The Tory-Liberal government was now on a civil war footing. The Emergency Powers Act was used, reservists were mobilised and troops were posted to industrial areas. The union leaderships surrendered at lonce.

counterproductive. It is rarely the most useful way of mobilising a political struggle or breaking down divisions within the working class. A long experience - including that of the Russian Bolsheviks after the 1905 Revolution — shows that guerrilla warfare tactics, even when justifiable, carry with them an acute danger of degenerating into gangsterism. In situations of national or communal conflict they can also degenerate into dead-end revenge-seeking communal slaughter.

All that said, the violence of the movements of oppressed peoples is not morally lower than the violence of those in power, even if it is less "regular" and less neatly uniformed, and even if those in power have been elected by someone.

The African National Congress clearly represents a large section of the black people in South Africa. The PLO has been consistently proved to be the only legitimate representative of the Palestinian Arab nation: if the violence of the intifada forced Israel out of the occupied territories, that Perhaps not surprisingly, Thomas of the NUR and Williams of the Transport Workers backed out and left the miners to fight alone. Betrayed and deserted, the miners fought on for two months and were forced to concede defeat.

This monumental betrayal went down in working class history as 'Black Friday'. It was a colossal demonstration of the cowardice of the leaders of the labour movement. Moreover, it demoralised whole sec tions of the working class.

Section by section, the employers dealt with the unions in the wake of 'Black Friday'. Defeat followed defeat.

The picture shows a miners" his workmates to stand firm.

would be a tremendous step forward. The IRA is supported, actively or passively, by a sizeable part, though by no means a majority, of the nationalist community in Northern Ireland.

None of this automatically legitimates particular acts of violence or the choice of armed struggle" in any particular situation, but a couple of conclusions do follow. The violence of such movements is a political question, not one of individual criminal acts to be dealt with by "law and order" . And, all other things being equal, the violence of such movements is more understandable, more justifiable than the violence of mighty states which wield massive economic, political, diplomatic and military power. "Riots", said Martin Luther King, "are the voice of the unheard". O mostle to their sa te action ur rulers use the term "terrorist"

repression by governments which claim liberal credentials.

The Israelis helped tear Lebanon apart, bombed West Beirut into terrified surrender, and then chaperoned the Christian Phalange militias into the Sabra and Chatila refugee camps in September 1982, where they massacred thousands of innocent Palestinians. It was a war crime with huge repercussions, including in Israeli public opinion. The justification was that they were flushing out "terrorists" • It was a ludicrous argument, and not only because the PLO had been withdrawn wholesale only weeks earlier. The British introduced mass internment without trial, strip-searching, and psychological torture in Northern Ireland to deal with "terrorism" . The US supported the barbarous Contras against Nicaragua with the excuse that the Sandinistas were supporting "terrorists" in El Salvador, yet the Contras were conducting a campaign of terror against the people.

By and large, we simply should not use the term "terrorist" , and we should question what it means wherever we see it. It has lost whatever meaning it had, and it does nothing to clear up the complicated issue of our attitude to political violence.

The journalist Robert Fisk concluded after years in Lebanon that "the use of the word terrorism is akin to carrying a gun. Unless the word is used about all acts of terrorism -and it is not - then its employment turns the reporter into a participant in the war"

Violence must be judged by what and who it genuinely represents. That is a complicated matter, but there is nothing more futile than searching for the violence that does not produce "terror" There is no such thing as "friendly fire"

----- pull-quotes -----

THE POLITICAL FRONT

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 479

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →