Peace is impossible
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-03-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
of political phenomena, not daring fingered dawn. to penetrate to their economic The decades preceding the causes. present war have been well At the hands of capitalist reality designated as a period of armed the idea of eternal peace, on the peace. During this whole period basis of a 'reasonable' agreement, campaigns were in uninterrupted has fared even more badly than the progress and battles were being idea of liberty, equality and fought, but they were in the ternative to hindered in their military build-up by all the well-wishing blueprints for peace. Then as now, the attachment of the "soft left" to pressure on, and pleas to, the powers that be, left them helplessly trailing behind those powers when they decided to go to war.
The "soft left" of 1914 were for peace - until their governments joined the war.
Likewise, today's "soft left" were for staying with economic sanctions and diplomacy - until war started. Then - more "practically", more "realistically" than opposing war — they conducted a "struggle" , consisting mostly of humble words in Neil Kinnock's ear, for the war's objectives to be limited to the recapture of Kuwait.
They were against the blitzing of Iraq, the destruction by bombing of KA1 1 No comment aim was, and has been ever since last August, to crush Iraq and restore stable US domination in the region — and that aim could never be reached by negotiations.
The US-led intervention was always about crushing Iraq. The land invasion of Iraq was merely one further stage in a process already well underway.
Sanctions were not an alternative to the drive to war. They were the start of the drive to war, they were the preparation for war.
When the "soft left" first committed themselves to a policy of gentle words in Neil Kinnock's ear — who in turn had a policy of gentle words in John Major's ear — then they committed themselves to war. All their reasoning, their careful blueprints, had no weight at all against the hard material interests driving for war.
To want the US to act as a policeman - but a bit more patiently, gently, and peacefully -was always stupid wishful thinking. Either you support the bloody imperialist conquest of Iraq, or you oppose imperialism. There is no third choice.
Now as in World War 1, the lesson is: to fight the roots of war we must fight capitalism, not just preach the abstract rules of peace.
Pacifism springs from Pine same historical roots democracy. The bourgeoisie made a gigantic effort to rationalise human relations, that is, to supplant a blind and stupid tradition by a system of critical reason.
The guild restrictions on industry, class privileges, monarchic autocracy — these were the traditional heritage of the Middle Ages. Bourgeois democracy demanded legal equality, free competition and parliamentary methods in the conduct of public affairs.
Naturally, its rationalistic criteria were applied also in the field of international relations. Here it hit upon war, which appeared to it as a method of solving questions that was a complete denial of all "reason".
So bourgeois democracy began to point out to the nations - with the tongues of poesy, moral philosophy and certified accounting - that they would profit more by the establishment of a condition of eternal peace.
Such were the logical bourgeois pacifism.
From the time of its birth pacifism was afflicted, however, with a fundamental defect, one which is characteristic of bourgeois democraev its nointed criticieme addressed themselves to the surface Leon Trotsky fraternity. For capitalism, when it rationalised industrial conditions, did not rationalise the social organisation of ownership, and thus prepared instruments of destruction such as even the "barbarous' Middle Ages never dreamed of.
The constant embitterment of international relations and the ceaseless growth of militarism completely undermined the basis of reality under the feet of pacifism. Yet it was from these very things that pacifism took a new lease of life, a life which differed from its carner puase as me blood analian L1.s aud purple sunset differs from the rosycolonies alone.
Proceeding, as they did, in the territories of backward and powerless peoples, these wars led to a division of Africa, Polynesia and Asia, and prepared the way for the present world war. As, however, there were no wars in Europe after 1871 — in spite of a long series of sharp conflicts - the general opinion in the petty bourgeois circles began gradually to behold in the growth of armies a guarantee of peace, which was destined ultimately to be established by international law with every institutional sanction.
Capitalist governments and munition kings naturally had no objections to this 'pacifist' interpretation of militarism. But the causes of world conflicts were accumulating and the present cataclysm was getting under way. Fiand on forise capital rance is the classic which leans for its support on the petty bourgeoisie of the cities and the towns, the most conservative class of the kind in the world, and numerically very strong.
Thanks to foreign loans, to the colonies, to the alliance of France with Russia and England, the financial upper crust of the Third Republic found itself involved in all the interests and conflicts of world polities.
And yet, the French petty bourgeois is an out-and-out provincial. He has always shown an instinctive aversion to geography and all his life has feared war as the very devil - if only for the reason that he has, in most cases, but one son who is to inherit his business, together with his chattels.
This petty bourgeois sends to Parliament a radical who has proSul is muusu y ILS UIcigu col- stoppage ol a loW ol monstruus
Scan page 9
Third Republic: the political system dominating various lines of industry.
САЛЬТА. Baghdad railway: in 1899 a leader of the radical wing of the European economies and societies were Bourgeois democracy: formal or German company signed a contract dominated by landlords who claimed parliamentary democracy, limited by a witn ine turkish empire, whien then part of the produce) as their hereditary • The present war: Trotsky is writing Baghdad. This Turkish-German linkFrance, who hoped to grab bits of the election on the slogan "He kept us out shopkeepers, craft workers, business rotting Turkish Empire for themselves, of war", and then took the US into kno scrim io uneheeked Dower. n new proteiom scoormes. .soi-empicem w'emelme no cause of international friction right coula ie ne mha uee cisnwaihy.. ansiast ditscrant never built. the search by big powers for military "guild" or association of each trade. both from the wage-working class and •. Басниівени Many of these traditional privileges the capitalist class or bourgeoisie warmongers' mised him to preserve peace - on to war: our represent the one hand, by means of a league ministry have been ‹ of nations and compulsory international arbitration, and on the other, with the cooperation of the Russian decades Cossacks, who are to hold the Ger- preceding the war man Kaiser in check.
This radical deputy, drawn from have been well the provincial lawyer class, goes to designated as a Paris not only with the best intentions but also without the slightest period of armed conception of the location of the Persian Gulf, and of the use, and to peace. During this During th whom, of the Baghdad railway.
This radical "pacifist' bloc of whole period period deputies gives birth to a radical campaigns were ministry, which at once finds itself bound hand and foot by all the uninterrupted diplomatic and military obligations progress and battles and financial interests of the French bourse in Russia, Africa and Asia. were being fought, Never ceasing to pronounce the proper pacifist sentences, the but they were in the ministry and the parliament colonies alone". automatically continue to carry on a world policy which involves France in war. war," says th. French citoyen, nglish and American *therefore the war must have been pacifism, in spite of the forced upou us, and in the name of differences in social and ideological forms (or in the absence Aries of such, as in America), is carrying on, at bottom, the same task.
It offers to the petty and the middle bourgeoisie an expression for their fears of world cataclysms in which they may lose their last remnants of independence. Their pacifism chloroforms their consciences - by means of impotent ideas of disarmament, international law and world courts - only to deliver them up body and soul, at the decisive moment, to imperialism, which now mobilises everything for its own purposes: industry, the church, art, bourgeois pacifism and patriotic "socialism'.
"We have always been opposed Short, atives, mo our pacifist ideals we must fight it ipposer tc to the finish." And the leader of the French pacifists, Baron d'Estournelles de Constant, endorses this pacifist philosophy of an imnerialict war with a nomnone inc.
CAROL YEAR qu'au bout.
The English Stock Exchange, in its prosecution of the war, has need first of all of pacifists of the Asquith (Liberal) and Lloyd George (radical demagogue) type. If these people go in for war," say the English masses, "right must be on our side." Thus a responsible function is allocated to pacifism in the economy of warfare, by the side of suffocating gases and inflated government loans.
More evident still is the subordinate role played by petty bourgeois pacifism with regard to Imperialism in the United States.
The actual policy is there more prominently dictated by banks and trusts than anywhere else. Even before the war the United States, owing to the gigantic development Af it in Anatoe and ita fansion am and restrictions, *the heritage of the Middle Ages", survived in many countries until the 18th or 19th Middle Ages (around 1100 to 1500)
capitalist social and economic system economic, legal, and political power over ine peasants on er and and a or mequalty.
about the First World War (1914-18). here means such hereditary claims. • Petty bourgeoisie: small "Monarchic autocracy" means the o naherf workers W ODeTMEN CK BAM bEi merce, was being driven in the directi terests and world pr The European this develonment a VP positively feverish.
At a time when many well-meaning persons were hoping that the horrors of the European slaughter might inspire the American bourgeoisie with a hatred of militarism, the actual influence of European events was bearing on American policy not in psychological channels but in material ones, and was having precisely the opposite effect.
The exports of the United States, which in 1913 amounted to $2,466 million, rose in 1916 to $5,481 million! Of course, the lion's share of this export fell to the lot of the war industries.
The sudden breaking off of exports to the Allied nations after the declaration of unrestricted submarine warfare meant not only the in France from 1870 to 1940.
ruled most of the Middle East, to no caused dam tool and and did so aller world war l; it was a through to 1914. The railway was Jonn s omin -immi.
systematically on of world inlicies. war imparted imperialistic speed that was Socialist Organiser No.479 page 9 profits, but threatened with an unprecedented crisis the whole of American industry, which had been organised on a war footing.
It was impossible for this thing to go on without some resistance from the masses of the people. To overcome their unorganised dissatisfaction and to turn it into channels of patriotic cooperation with the government was therefore the first great task of the international diplomacy of the United States during the first quarter of the war. And it is the irony of history that official 'pacifism', as well as 'oppositional pacifism', should be the chief instrument for the accomplishment of this task: the education of the masses to military ideals.
Bryan rashly and noisily expressed the natural aversion of the farmers and of the "small man' generally to all such things as worldpolicy, military service and higher taxes. Yet, at the same time that he was sending wagon-loads of petitions, as well as deputations, to his pacifist colleagues at the head of the government, Bryan did everything in his power to break the revolutionary edge of the whole movement.
war should come," Bryan telegraphed on the occasion of an anti-war meeting in Chicago last February, "we will all support the government of course; yet at this moment it is our sacred duty to do all in our power to preserve the nation from the horrors of war." T the entire programme of pety hese few words contain bourgeois pacifism: "to do everything in our power against the war" means to afford the voice of popular indignation an outlet in the form of harmless demonstration, after having previously given the government a guarantee that it will meet with no serious opposition, in the case of war, from the pacifist faction.
Official pacifism could have desired nothing better. It could now give satisfactory assurance to imperialist 'preparedness'. After Bryan's own declaration, only one thing was necessary to dispose of his noisy opposition to war, and that was, simply, to declare war. And Bryan rolled right over into the government camp.
And not only the petty bourgeoisie, but also the broad masses of workers, said to themselves: "If our government, with such an outspoken pacifist as Wilson at the head, declares war, and if even Bryan supports the government in the war, it must be an unavoidable and righteous war..." It is now evident why the sanctimonious, Quaker-like pacifism of the bourgeois demagogues is in such higher favour in financial and war industry circles.
Trusts: groups of companies Bryan: William Jennings Bryan, American Democratic Party, and repry mt biarr poesie nosWilson sentin Uuen 1e Vilse ge -isore wi!lsoe, 1912 to 1920. He won the 1916 • World-policy: used as a synonym and diplomatic sway, spheres of influence. semi-colonies, and colonies.
Scan page 10
Organiser N PERSPECTIVE
----- pull-quotes -----
They were the start of the drive to war, they were the preparation for war".
ft" backed wal under capitalism