An open E Kock
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-03-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 16 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 16
Riot police attack poll tax protesters on last year's Photo: Paul An open Kinnock Murphy ORGANISER letter to Neil from Cate N Last March you and your eil Kinnock:
•deputy, Roy Hattersley, rushed to side with the police after they had clashed violently with anti-poll tax protesters in central London.
You knew that there had been widespread fighting, many injuries over 500 arrests. You could have known nothing else since, of course, you were not on the demonstration.
You didn't want to find out what had happened, or why. You knew already all that you wanted to know. You knew you were with the police and "law and order". That, your public relations minders had been telling you for five years, was where the votes lay.
In the prolonged media outcry that followed, you lent your voice to the Tory campaign to whip up a general revulsion against the violence in central London, brand the anti-poll-tax marchers as responsible, and use that as a moral blackjack to help beat down opposition to the poll tax.
That was what the Tories were trying to do, Neil Kinnock, and you helped them. The police could do no wrong where you were concerned.
you ignored the wealth of testimony from participants in the march - most of them almost certainly Labour voters - that the police had started the riot in Whitehall by riding their horses into a peaceful crowd, some of them sitting on the pavement.
You ignored the testimony of your own eyes — I assume you watch the TV news - that the police had behaved with reckless and indiscriminate violence, driving horses and police vehicles dangerously into crowds, savagely batoning peaceful bystanders, and in general behaving like a panicky mob of trainee Thatcherite cossacks.
You must have seen all that on your television screen, Mr Kinnock. It made no difference. It didn't even make you pause and reflect. It didn't lead you to ask for any sort of impartial inquiry.
Nor were you - despite your "previous life" as a man of the left - alarmed for civil liberty when newspaper and TV photographers were hounded by the courts and made to turn over their work to the police, who used it to trace demonstrators.
You lent your full weight to everything the police, the tabloid press, and the courts decreed, Mr Kinnock. You went along with the press assertions that there had been a coordinated insurrectionary movement at work in central London that day.
In a well-known passage from his book on the Spanish Civil War, George Orwell memorably explained how he came, against some of his Mattsson previous political prejudices, to side in May 1937 with the Anarchist and Trotskyist workers against the Republican state in Barcelona. *When I see the workers being attacked by their natural enemies, the police, I don't have to ask myself which side I'm on"
Neither do you, Mr Kinnock. Neither do you. And there is the pity of it.
Now the report of Scotland N Yard's own inquiry into the anti-poll-tax fighting - by the Deputy Assistant Commis sioner, John Metcalfe - admits that there was no coordination against the police, and that the police made big errors.
That is quite a lot for an official police inquiry to admit, don't you think, Mr Kinnock? Perhaps an impartial inquiry would find a lot more to criticise in the behaviour of the police?
Mr Kinnock, things were done by the police during the "riots" and in collecting evidence afterwards which pose a grave threat to civil liberty in this country, and to
to
freedom of the press. In view of the admission now by the police themselves that things were not as you and the rest of the Establishment and its press said they were in Trafalgar Square last March, is it not time for you, the leader of the Labour Party, to change your tune?
You should demand a proper public inquiry into the riots and what happened afterwards. You should defend those still being hounded by the state for their part in the demonstration last March.
And, Mr Kinnock you should here and now pledge your support to the next anti-poll-tax march on 23 March. That would be one way to help behave phemsee and retrain froce turning this event, too, into a riot. imme the nes action, then r Kinnock, the poll tax immense damage. If Labour wins the next election, then we will owe our victory much more to the Tory blunder with the poll tax than to anything you have done in seven years as leader.
Having more or less
etter
that the poll tax is unjustifiable, the Tories nevertheless seem set to keep on with it, perhaps modified.
There could not be a greater opportunity for the Labour Party to get the Tories on the run in the three or four months before the general election probable in June than a vigorous campaign against the poll tax. The Tories have wrongfooted themselves badly by Socialist Organiser is the only paper on the left with the clear, unambiguous message: Troops out of the Gulf! Iraq out of Kuwait!
E25 for a year; E13 for six months; E5 for ten issues.
Send cheques, payable to SO, 823, London SE15 4NA.
Nami Address Overseas rates (for a year): Europe E30, US $90. Australia A$120. Giro account number: 367 9624. effectively admitting that the tax cannot be continued, but refusing to go on and abolish it.
There is still time for you to help build the campaign that will sweep the Tories out of office if they dare to go to the electorate in June.
It is about time you joined the anti-poll-tax campaign, Mr Kinnock!
WHICH ASS T2 LIKE To KIck
----- pull-quotes -----
to Socialist Organiser! SOCIALIST write he KesIst this 12