Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Sunday before the war

Socialist Organiser no. 478, 7 March 1991 · scan pp. 12–13 · about 1,688 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

Below, a sleek content Lays out fresh flowers Soon oil-fields, burning:

Helicopters are warning! Rattling, clattering, reverberating echoes And bounce along the streets outside the nospital, Big swirling blades appear on its high flat brow; Near Whitechapel Road this cold bright Sund morning The engines of mercy test their wings for Helicopters are on the roof, rehearsing.

Warning!

See the maimed, the coffined, blind and returning:

Helicopters are on the roof, rehearsing -warning!

street-trading man for the visiting hour cities, seas, and babies will the roof, rehearsing — From the car park market gleaning what th can, Two well-dressed women hurry to the tube Humping high-backed kitchen chairs home the nest:

Is it the cold, or are others too depressed? See the maimed, the coffined, blind and mad returning:

Helicopters are on the roof, rehearsing -warning!' Named for its benefactor, "Saddam Hussein' The gilded white-walled mosque is sullen, scorning, Fixed in the skein, balancing loss with gain, Outshouted by the chattering blades that fly: Arcane, well-muffled Bangladeshis hurry byAnd suspect alien brown-skinned men interning, scorning.

Helicopters are on the roof, rehearsing warning!

Behind mad ripper Jack's wrecked lanes, sell:

Here, mapping out a place in the market arcadia Ragged men lay trash for sale down on footpaths; Bare stalls sell rusted tools, old clothes, nails:

Junk they sell from old folk's lairs, bequests Of wealth from those despoiled and dispossessed, Last riches from the life-long near-distressed All teapots, vinyl, lamps, big radios — dustscored Lives rendered down, spread boards.

See the maimed, the coffined, blind and mad returning:

Helicopters are on the roof, rehearsing -warning!

Wholly dispossessed, the lost, mad, ruined Drunkards, shelter by the station — junked freight, Obsolete! There, neat on a vendor's stacked hateFilled jingo prints, flash portraits of a wour Bourgeois soul: its parody — its aureole! And high above the whoring propagandists cold suborning Helicopters are on the Warning.

On Whitechapel Road this frost-bright Sun morning Cold, covened drunks blades And see the high, big, noisy renegade Engines of mercy test their wings for war — Mercy for their own; mercy after, not be Helicopters are on the roof, rehearsing — warning!

Soon oilfields, cities, seas and babies will be burning:

Helicopters are on the roof, warning!

Matg: freedom The belief in freedom of speech and writing and in wide toleranci for views you detest was long something which defined the left as against the traditional conservative right. With it, inescapably, went opposition to censorship and to the use of forc to repress or regiment opinion. Stretching back over hundreds of years to the English Civil War of the 1640s, and earlier, the great causes and fights through which the best bourgeois democratic freedoms were won - of conscience, science, press, assembly, organisation and utterance - were all in the main left wing causes. They were won by the contemporary left with word and deed.

Our contemporary left, however, and especially the would-be revolutionary and Marxist left, is today frequently to be found in the vanguard of the intolerant banners, stiflers, "no-platformers" and bigots. It has become part of the general culture of the left that you try to ban those you don't like.

There are a number of reasons. for this. Good reasons: in the first place the spirit which flows from recognition that the class struggle isn't a gentle debate, either in parliament or the trade union negotiating rooms, but a conflict. In particular, there is recognition that the proper response to National Front racist thugs chanting abuse at black people not to try sweet reason with them.

There are bad reasons: the "struggle" spirit is taken into debates within the left and into arguments both about nuances and even about facts. Views -and even facts - you don't like are to be shunned, stifled and banned. Everyone on the left knows how easy it is to get yourself tagged as a "racist or "sexist" or "anti-Irish chauvinist - normally by emotional people using such labels as crude weapons of intimidation.

For example, to question the broad left's attitude to the Middli East, or, for South Africa, to dare to disagree with, or reject, the ANC, or, for Ireland, to repudiate the Provisional IRA, is to get yourself denounced as a "racist" or a "pro-imperialist".

These are all examples taken from SO's collective experience. They testify to a left-wing condition in which emotion takes the place of reason, crude guilt takes the place of argument, and, in general, the left itself has on many questions taken up the traditional place of the old conservative right wing.

Even when it is a matter of literary censorship, opposition tr it can no longer be read off and taken for granted from general left-wing opinions. The spirit of Stalinism is still abroad on the left - even amongst antiStalinists.

In this account of a famous court case, that in which Penguin Books won the right to publish DH Lawrence's Lady Chatterley's Lover, Mark Osborn shows how very recent a thing it is for Britain not to have crude literary censorship - 30 years and less. Simone signoret. This realism was to shock the establishment ahe year is 1960.

T Penguin Books is on trial at the Old Bailey for an attempt to publish Lady Chatterley's Lover, the DH Lawrence novel.

Lawrence has been dead for 30 years and the book is on sale in most countries outside the Commonwealth. But this is the first attempt to produce an unexpurgated version in Britain.

The case against Penguin had been brought as a test under the 1959 Obscene Publications Act (OPA).

Britain has a long record of censorship and book banning. The Victorian judges were able to ban Flaubert and Zola -they contained passages which aroused "libidinous and lustful desires" and were condemned as "obscene"

One thousand copies of DH Lawrence's The Rainbow were destroyed in 1915. The police removed some of his paintings from display in 1929 because pubic hairs could be seen.

Lawrence hit out at *the shadow of the grey elderly ones who belong to the last century, the eunuch century, the cenlicy of the mealy-mouthed Lawrence's target was the Director of Public Prosecutions who had described Freud's work as "filth" and threatened his publishers with prosecution unless circulation was reduced to doctors who were prepared to hand in their names and addresses.

James Joyce's Ulysses was banned for a time. Radclyffe Hall's Well of Loneliness, a novel about lesbianism, was banned for one line: "and that night they were not divided" -with the justification that the book glorified the "horrible tendencies of lesbianism"

Cyril Connolly, Lawrence Durrell, and Henry Miller were all banned before and after the war.

There was always a big element of class discrimination in that the only people who could read banned books were those who were rich enough to afford foreign travel. One of Penguin's crimes in the eyes of the British state was to plan to publish 200,000 copies of Lady Chatterley at a price working class readers could afford.

It all came out in the Lady Chatterley • court case: ignorance, class prejudice, sexism and sex stereotypes - in the comments of the judge and the prosecution.

The prosecutor tells the jury, which includes three women, that they will have to decide if "Lady Chatterley depraves and corrupts". He asks them if this is a book they would "wish their wives or servants to read"!

«The tide can be turned back too. In the US a big part of the reactionary tide has been made up an unholy alliance feminists and fundamentalist Christians. "

The prosecutio • of rude lists the various • quantitie words in the book. Interestingly enough, "arse" is mentioned six times.

But what really bothers the prosecution is that Lady Chatterley contains lots of sex: 30 pages out of 300. Do you know what they thought wrong about sex? Quite a lot of it happens outside Lady Chatterley's bedroom! Lady Chatterley and her lover, a gamekeeper and a servant, have sex in his cottage, a boarding house and even in the woods. Just remember that next time you are pulling bits of grass out of your hair and underwear.

The prosecution with dozens of expert witnesses - all of whom said that the book was good or very good. So they changed tack. They decided to put the fictional character of Lady Chatterley on trial. Her crime? Being an adulterous woman, upper class too, and enjoying sex with a servant! And as the judge helpfully pointed out, the book does not even see them punished, The jury disagreed with the judge. Lady Chatterley was legally published and sold three million copies in three months.

The fight against the thought police went on through the '60s and '70s. Juries became younger and more working class after 1972 when the age of jury service was reduced to 18, and property qualifications were abolished. Also, attitudes had changed. Juries were less likely to convict. By the end of the 70s the censors were not getting their way under the OPA.

Last Exit from Brooklyn, which dealt with homosexuality, was prosecuted in 1968 (and allowed publication). It was as late as 1969 that strict censorship ended in the theatre. There was the Oz magazine crial of 1971, the Gay News sex and blasphemy trials a decade ago.

There will be others.

The tide can be turned back, too. In the US a big part of the reactionary tide has been made up of an unholy alliance of feminists and fundamentalist Christians.

The left is unclear as to its principles. As the British left is now it may find itself playing the role of cannon fodder for a general reaction.

Clare Short puts a bill to ban Page 3. The SWP have supported bans on Jewish societies for "Zionism" . The Union of Jewish Students supports the banning of the "anti-Zionist" Return magazine. The Militant side with the Stalinist Rumanian state when it suppresses "right-wing" demonstrators.

All this is wrong in principle and counter-productive too.

Scan page 13

RAL FRON

----- pull-quotes -----

Whitechapel, East January 1991

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 478

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →