Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The conspiracy the Birmingham

Socialist Organiser no. 478, 7 March 1991 · scan pp. 8–12 · Patrick Murphy · about 5,712 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

The final appeal hearing for the Birmingham Six is now taking place at the Old Bailey. Their innocence is not denied by anyone. The hearing may take one more week: one more week in jail, one more disgusting formality. were convicters of the Sa sie TRA Sixteen pub bombings in Birmingham. Conviction was based on "confessions" tortured out of them, and on very disputable, maybe fabricated "scientific" evidence.

Hugh Callaghan, Patrick Hill, Gerry Hunter, Richard Mellkenny, Billy Power and Johnny Walker were given 21 life sentences each. The judge set no limit on the term of their imprisonment. The British state locked them up and threw away the key.

Britain is not Stalin's Russia, but the trials and treatment of these men resembles the arbitrary and brutal punishment meted out in the name of "justice" by an authoritarian state.

For most of their 16 years in jail, these men must have felt that they would not wake up from this They are now waking up. They will be released and compensated — in so far as they can be compensated. Theirs is a terrible story! I 1974 three bombs went off n Thursday 21 November in the centre of Birmingham - two in pubs. 21 people were killed and 162 were injured. Most of Joanne Walker, the daughter of Johnny Walker, one of the part in a candlelit vigil outside Wormwood Scrubs, London. the victims were civilians, many of them were Irish. It appears to have been a confused and bungled IRA operation. By any standards it was a monstrous and senseless attack.

The reaction to the bombings was one of widespread convulsive horTOr. At British Leyland's Longbridge plant there was a mass walk-out the day after.

Workers carried placards saying "Hang the IRA bombers". '. In a letter to Chris Mullin MP, quoted in his book, Error of Judgement, one of the victims sums up the mood: "I hated all of them, their families and anyone who had anything to do with them. It was many years before I could think objectively about Irish people. My irrational feelings were exactly the mood in which these men were convicted. Normal housewives attacked an Irish man in a local Woolworths. Stones were thrown in an Irish neighbour's window."

The anti-Irish sentiment and hysteria was inflated by the government. The then-Labour (later SDP) Home Secretary Roy Jenkins talked about the immediate reintroduction of the death penalty.

Jenkins told the House of ComCommons, and everyone else who was listening: "under the present circumstances one could be justified in enabling the police and others to take exceptional measures in order to protect our people from indiscriminate killings."

So the police were given the signal to make a quick arrest (it must be a quick arrest), to use as much violence as "necessary" They had to be seen to be dealing forcefully and competently with the situation.

But more than this. For the average thick-eared cop, "protecting our people" would translate into an injunction and a license to give someone (any Irish person will do) a kicking.

The British state has shown consistently that it does not know many other ways of handling "the Irish problem"

And so the police found six men they could "fit up" , and did the job expected of them. They took five men travelling from Birmingham to Belfast off a train the day after the bombing. Suspicious! They were Irish. Very suspicious!

One phone call sorted it out. One cop spoke to another cop: "we have detained four men at Heysham"

The other cop replied, "take them in". (The other two were arrested later).

Three of the six men knew James MacDade, a raw IRA recruit who had blown himself up a week earlier. They were on the way to his funeral. They were schoolfriends. It was a chance to visit family and friends.

None of the men were IRA or Sinn Fein members or even known as politicals to the Special Branch. Essentially the six men were Irish. That was enough. This was their crime. The rest was just a matter of experienced police "jailors" fitting them up.

arrested Trishmen. They were his is what happened to the detained (without cautioning). They were taken to Morecambe, followed swiftly by the press, to whom the police gave out a signal that they had got the guilty men.

All the police top brass from the surrounding area swarmed down to Morecambe and 100 policemen volunteered their services. But they were not required. The police had the man for the job, George Reade, Chief Superintendent of the West Midlands police force.

Reade, who subsequently did a bunk to Australia, and five of his investigative team were armed with revolvers on 22 November. They were very eager to begin the interrogation.

First of all, forensic tests were done. It seems clear Reade regarded this as a formality: "I make no bones about it," he said, "T'd have brought them back [to Birmingham] whatever the forensic tests said."

The Home Office forensic expert who conducted the tests on the men (for traces of nitroglycerine) told the court he was 99% certain the three men who tested positive had been in contact with explosives. Yet this same expert - Frank Skuse was very uncertain at the Appeal hearing about whether he had conducted the test correctly. Subsequent tests disputed the original findings. But no-one could tell for sure now because all the relevant test documents had gone missing. Where they were, Skuse could not say. Frank Skuse was later compulsorily retired and is apparently a personal friend of George Reade.

Three of the men tested positive and they were singled out first for the extraction of confessions.

Patrick Hill was told he was "covered in gelignite from head to toe". He was told he would be shot, he would be dumped on the motorway, no-one would ever know. Hill did not confess.

On the way to Birmingham in a police car, his testicles were whipped with the handle of a police truncheon, a cigarette was stubbed out on his bare feet.

Billy Power was also told he would be thrown out of a car. He was pushed up against a window and told he was going to be thrown out. He was beaten senseless and until he was hysterical. He signed a 900-word confession. The police chiefs drank a glass or two to celebrate...

Johnny Walker had his ulcer scar repeatedly thumped. He had an and the trigger pulled. He was made unloaded gun pointed at his head to stand on one leg with his hands on his head. When he lost balance he received a kick in the genitals or on his legs. All of the men were hit, kicked, shoved against walls.

In cells back in Birmingham they were not allowed to sleep. They were ordered to stand up, then ordered to sit down. They were threatened with dogs and with shotguns. Thus did the police get their confessions.

The men were charged and sent to Winson Green prison. Here they were again beaten up by prison officers.

At the trial where the men were convicted the judge (Judge Bridge) summed up for three days. Virtually all of his time was spent knocking down the defence case. It was all set up. It was all a foregone conclusion. Nobody cared!

In 1976 the prison officers at Winson Green who beat the men up were prosecuted privately by their victims. The six used this as a chance to plead their innocence, to prove they had been beaten into making the confessions. The defence solicitors claimed the men had been beaten up before arriving at Winson Green. This anomaly of course went unnoticed.

"or 10 years the men rotted in *jail. Then in 1985 Chris Mullin MP took up the case for World in Action. They found a former police officer to come forward and corroborate the men's charges of police torture.

Mullin examined other evidence as well. In 1987 Douglas Hurd referred the case to the Court of Appeal. None of the new evidence was listened to at all by the judges. Again the bogus, falsified, sham "integrity of the system" was defended at the cost of justice and the liberty of the citizen.

In 1990 the Guildford 4 were released. They too had been convicted on the basis of forced confessions. Now the convictions of the Birmingham Six could be seen for the outrage against justice that they were.

The press have concentrated on two themes in the last week. Firstly. how this "miscarriage of justice" could have happened. And, will it happen again?

Scan page 9

that kept working class?

Six in jail *Miscarriage of justice" is an eroneous and meaningless term for what happened. It was meant to lappen. This was their justice. This ras their system. It is still their ystem today.

Of course the courts work enerally, normally. Legal Aid, nough restricted, is provided. Laws te not only made to serve the in"Most of the people who conspired to lock them up and who have Socked up countless ther innocent people Still remain in their privileged, powerful mositions.

ests of the ruling class, they are so shaped by class struggle. Of urse, the police serve not only eir own corporate interests or the crests of the state all the time.

my people, in many cirannes, can find some measure rection" from the police. in "exceptional cir= - the IRA bombing L the miners' strike - the martial functions of the & courts are rolled away. ties show us what the margeois law is really Birmingham have had 16 years ripped out of their lives.

They have been the victims of a criminal police, Home Office, and judicial conspiracy! No other words describe what has been happening to them. Yet most of the people who conspired to lock them up and who have locked up countless other innocent people still remain in their privileged, powerful positions. Policemen who fake evidence, scientists who swear away people's lives on sixth form science level tests, judges who play along with police they know are liars and framing artists, yet play along with them, Home Office officials who turn a blind eye — these are the sort of people who still run the police and judicial system in Britain.

For 16 years the state, its judicial functionaries, its bureaucracies, and its petty-tyrant police servants have systematically ignored, denied, suppressed and - literally - shredded the truth.

At all costs the Birmingham 6 were not to be found innocent. To preserve a belief in the established order - that was their goal. It was a goal to which they were quite willing to make human sacrifices. For former top judge Lord Denning it was — he said it explicitly - a small price to pay. As one of the Appeal Court judges who stopped the Six's prosecution of the police who beat them up, he made this attitude grotesquely clear: "If the six men win [their prosecution] it will mean that the police were guilty of perjury, that they were guilty of violence and threats, that the confessions were involuntary and were improperly admitted in evidence and that the convictions were erroneous.

*That would mean the Home Secretary would either have to recommend they be pardoned or he would have to remit the case to the Court of Appeal. This is such an appalling vista that every sensible person in the land would say: "it cannot be right that these actions should go any further'."

"Reasons of state" override justice and the right to freedom of the six innocent and tortured men. The massive falling off of public confidence in the police over the last decade or so proves that many "sensible person[s] in the land" believe it is not right that policestate-style policing should go on in Britain while arrogant brutes like Denning sit in judgement to rubberstamp police frame-ups.

The labour movement must fight for justice, in general, and for our own class. If the Labour Party were for instance, to take up the case of the Tottenham 3, to fight for some democratic controls over the police and to fight against increasing incroachment on the rights of detainees, or any one of those things, then this would go some way towards making right the barbarous treatment these six men received at the hands of the state.

By Patrick Murphy For anti-war campaigners one of the most dispiriting sights is the apparent acceptance, or even enthusiasm, press. But nationalism is a powerful identity for people whose real day-to-day identity embodies lack of power and status.

Working-class support for war is also stoked up by exploiting fellowfeeling for soldiers drawn from our class. There is a reai cutting edge to the idea that support for war is support for "our boys" and opposition (or support for the other side) is the worst kind of treachery.

These depressing observations came to mind when, recently, heard the idea that only the working class can stop this war" recited like a dogma, a hollow slogan, at a political meeting. To most people there it seemed to have no grip on reality, yet there is too much truth in the notion to let it be so misrepresented.

he visible power of capitalism at war disguises a weakness, because our rulers rely utterly upon us during war, even more so than in "normal times".

Between 1914-18 the British Liberal government made a special arrangement with the trade union leaders to grant union recognition, improved pay and conditions, in return for a promise of total cooperation during the war.

Unions were suddenly a vital part of society in the eyes of people who had previously seen them as sworn enemies and a threat to order and stability. Arthur Henderson became the first Labour Cabinet Minister in Asquith's coalition in 1916. Lloyd George infuriated politicians by announcing his war aims to the TUC before speaking to the Commons as the war ended.

The shame is that union leaders used the war to accept this promotion rather than to oppose and defeat the slaughter of their fellow workers. The evidence is clear, however, and it shows that the labour movement could prevent or halt wars.

The Russian workers 1917 crippled the war effort of the Tsar and later Kerensky.

1963. MINEURS ERANÇAIS. EN LUTT CONTRE DE GAULA SOLiDARITÉ FRI 1984. ANEURS ANGLAIS. EN LUTT CONTRE TATCHE.

SOLiOARITE DI PoUR LE CHARG MÊME COMBAT Workers of all lands. unite!

In Britain in 1920 Lloyd George's war fever and anti-communism went too far even for the Labour and TUC leaders. He was eagerly supporting attempts to overthrow the Bolshevik government by sending troops, weapons and supplies, together with the other imperialist armies, to fight in the so-called Wars of Intervention. London dockers refused to load a ship, the Jolly George, which was to carry weapons for this war. The TUC and Labour Party then threatened a general strike. That ended Britain's role in that war.

So the short-term jingoism we come to expect is not fixed or permanent. It can be changed by a labour movement which challenges it and leads opposition.

And only the working class can bring down the system that causes war.

The working class is uniquely anti-capitalist it is anti-capitalist in a unique way.

Many individuals, from many backgrounds, choose to oppose wars and capitalism through conviction; they make a good or bad job of it, sometimes giving their lives to the struggle, too often giving up in frustration. The working class fights capitalism often regardless of choice, or will, or understanding of that system.

The job of socialists is to make the workers' movement fully aware that freedom for our class and the continuation of production based on profit, controlled by a tiny few, are incompatible aims. The point here, however, is that workers, even the distorted and bought-off labour leaders, fight capitalism regardless of their initial intentions and political will. A good example is the confusing story of modern Eastern Europe.

Workers in Poland, East Germany, and Hungary are ideologically in favour of capitalism. They believe that the market offers the lifestyle and wealth in consumer goods denied to them by Stalinism. They vote and march for pro-capitalist politicians.

Every news bulletin from Poland tells us, on the other hand, that workers are threatening to strike against unemployment, cuts in wages and welfare provision caused by the switch to a free market. Even when enthusiastically pro-market in ideas, the working class, because of its place in society, is anti-capitalist in spirit, it has a built-in anticapitalist dynamic.

No socialism is possible if it is to be made only by conscious, politically aware volunteers who remain aloof from the existing working-class movement for fear of being contaminated. Such people remain aloof from the only force that can change society, for fear it might first change them.

he labour movement could have transformed the anti-war movement into a movement that could have ended the war and defeated imperialism. As it is, war against Iraq and other Arab people by the West and her regional allies has not been ended.

Equally, the opposition to war, especially amongst the young, could be a tremendous force for transforming a politically lifeless labour movement. A serious, sizeable socialist organisation embedded in the workers movement could still fuse the gut anger of radicals with the latent power of labour to wage the only war worth fighting, "the mother of all battles" - the class war.

Scan page 10

srael and the Palestinians riser Part two of a decument on the Gulf crisis from the Israeli socialist organisation Matzpen Why does the Iraqi regime not withdraw from Kuwait, now that concentrated military power is directed against her?

Ithough the speakers of the coalltion have tried to picture Saddam •Hussein as a blood-thirsty monster, his unwillingness to withdraw and surrender - at least until now — has to be explained by the fact that the character and aims of this war are not decided upon in Baghdad, but in Washington.

The United States has left Iraq with no other option but to fight until the last drop of blood. From the moment it became evident that the coalition wanted Saddam's head or — in more political words — the elimination of his regime's power, every ruler would have behaved just as he does, ie. to resist as long as he can, and for any price.

Maybe (and this is only a hypothesis) the Iraqi regime thought that the coalition would concentrate its military power to liberate Kuwait already at the outset of the war. In that case Saddam Hussein could have excelled in the eyes of his people and in front of the Arab masses as the ones who fought against Kuwait and lost with honour. However, from the moment the military campaign focused on Iraq, the message became clear: the coalition wants to destroy the Iraqi regime and its leader, and it will not stop until this task is completed. In this sense, the coalition carries the full responsibility for the dimensions of this war and its extension beyond the borders of Iraq and Kuwait.

The bombing of population centres in Israel and Saudia Arabia, the spilling of oil into the Gulf, the digging in of the Iraqi army and Saddam Hussein's apocalyptic declarations, are part of the battle of a regime and its leader who are fighting for their survival. Even if we understand that Saddam HusArafat sein's actions are actions of desperati‹ n, it is clear that he will continue to behave like a wounded lion struggling for his life, as long as the United States will proceed to implement her war aims in the battlefield and in the media, and as such he will want to wound and hurt whoever is in his reach.

Does this imply that the missile attacks against Israel are justified?

ust as there is no justification for the destruction of Iraq, and for the catastrophe occurring to the Iraqi people, including loss of lives, refugees, and the demolition of the civil infrastructure of the state, so there is no justification for death and destruction caused by the Scud missiles in Tel Aviv or Haifa. Israeli civilians, just like the Iraqi population, are a victim of this war.

If the Iraqi regime regards the emission of missiles on Israel as a justified military action, it is not because Saddam Hussein is crazy, but because there is a strong historical link between the role of the Israeli state in the region and US imperialism.

Even if we understand that the Iraqi regime attempts to draw Israel into war in order to undermine the coalition, and not to "liberate Palestine", , it remains true that this political manipulation is possible only on the basis of the unique role Israel has been playing in the region since its establishment. Israel, together with the western states, participated actively in the 1956 war, which aimed to strike at Jamal Abdel Nasser's regime following the nationalisation of the Suez Canal. Israel has been holding onto Arab terTitories occupied in 1967 for now more than 20 years, she brutally represses the Palestinian people, and refuses to sign any human rights declaration or any agreement concerning nuclear disarmament of the region.

According to western sources, Israel is in possession of chemical, biological and nuclear weapons. Israel is developing ballistic missiles, and entertains one of the biggest and most sophisticated system of land and air forces.

Israel has an agreement of strategic cooperation with the United States which resembles the agreement between the NATO states. This cooperation finds its expression in the field of intelligence as well as on the level of the armed forces (eg. provision of supplies to the US plane carriers in the Mediterranean Sea.

Israel insists on her sole right to eliminate any nuclear threat in the region — as she did for example in the 1980 bombing of the Iragi powerplant — but refuses to be controlled by international commissions set up to prevent the distribution of nuclear weapons.

Israel conquered an Arab capital, Beirut, and tried with US support to establish a regime to her taste.

These examples leave no doubt that Israel is serving the imperialist interests in the region, thereby conveying a permanent threat to the Arab countries.

The United States regards Israel as a military fortress, always ready and prepared to strike out in favour of western interests, either to stop unwanted developments among the Arab masses, or to prevent the Arab regimes from upsetting the balance of power in the region.

Although Israel is not actively involved in the present war, she performs in a passive way, a central role in the United States' policy aiming to establish a new order in the region, once Saddam Hussein's regime is destroyed.

The fact that Israel has not yet responded to the missile attacks on its population cenDevastation in Baghdad given to the needs of the coalition, bu to be seen first of all as a result of cleat given by Washington. In this sense, Is US mercenary: acting whenever she i ed, and paralysed when unwanted.

If Israel is really not interested in b volved in a war in the region which, sight, does not concern her, she has towards a solution of the Israel-Pak conflict, towards a peace settlement v Arab states, for the disarmament region from non-conventional weap declare her neutrality in internation flicts, etc; in other words, she has to her political and military leaders.

The context described above explair although the missiles are emitted by Ir Israeli government and its partners *The coalition "opposition" carry part of the responsiblity for the victims in the country. It is enough to listen to Shlomo Lahat (Tel Aviv mayor) or to Yossi Sarid (Civil Rights Movement) calling Tel Aviv residents "deserters" or "non-Jews" (because they leave the city in fear), in order to understand that to the politicians of the Zionist parties, the country's population is no more than cheap cannon-fodder in the framework of the strategic cooperation with the United States.

Here we have to add that in spite of the euphoria of national unity, and in the very days that the population of Gush Dan is suffering, the Israeli government and leading industrialists are passing a state budget which contains major cutbacks in the standard of living, and announcing that workers will not receive their salaries if they stay away from work because of the bombings. Suddenly it also becomes clear that, although we are "all one people" , the income tax authorities know well how to distinguish between rich and poor, and that compensations paid for war damage will not be sufficient to re-build homes or to purchase lost property. Also here, Shlomo Lahat, in brutishness characteristic for him, knew to make it clear it it has r orders rael is a is needBeing inon first ; to act estinian vith the of the ons, to al conchange as why, ag, the wants to qi regime and will task is to the residents of Hatikva Neighbourhood (poor Tel Aviv quarter) that even if they find themselves in the frontline of the present battle, the attitude towards them will not change: he decided not to distribute compensations individually, because we all know that in Hatikva Neighbourhood "they will spend the money on drugs"* This despising attitude only supports the claim that there is a wide gap between the interests of the majority of the population in Israel, workers and residents of the poor neighbourhoods, and those of the politicians of right and left, capital owners and IDF generals. The Jewish masses in this country have the basic interest to live in peace and stop paying the blood-price; the Israeli ruling class is interested in consolidating more and more the Israeli army-machine, to continue to function as the small partner of US interests, ie. to continue to live with the Israeli-Arab conflict in general, and with the Israeli-Palestinian conflict specifically:

Are these the factors explaining the joy expressed by the Palestinians in the occupied territories after each missile attack on Tel Aviv, and the PLO support for Iraq?

Were we have to distinguish between the joy expressed by the Palestinian residents and the political position taken by the Palestinian national movement.

Concerning the first, the explanation is simple, even if many Israeli activists against the occupation will not like it. Israelis easily forget the responsibility of their government and security forces for what is done in these territories. It is enough here to remember the thousands killed during the three years of the Intifada, the thousands wounded and arrested, the curfew imposed now already for more than two weeks, the humiliations and the violations of basic human rights, in order to understand that every missile-blow on Israel is welcomed and happily received by the Palestinians. Maybe this is infantile behaviour, but as long as the majority of the Jewish population supports the policy of the Israeli government, we should not be surprised by this attitude.

Concerning the PLO and the national movement, their support for Iraq is based on a sound political decision. The Palestinian

Scan page 11

that Saddam ssein" Israeli victim of Scud attack holds part of the missile that destroyed her home people have learnt through bitter experience that to trust in the American will to "pressure" the Israelis — as a consequence of pressure coming from various Arab states - into solving the Palestinian question is equivalent to committing suicide. Since 1948 and until the present war, there has not been any significant change in the United States' attitude towards the Palestinian question, and in her unconditional support for Israel.

True, there are many illusions and much acquiescence to Saddam Hussein's dictatorious regime in the national movement, and this may add to the frustration following his probable defeat.

However, as explained above, the political decision taken by the national movement, besides Iraq against the American aggression, is correct even if the outcome of the battle is known beforehand. Every victory of imperialism in the region automatically strengthens Israel, and is equivalent to the defeat of the Palestinian national movement. And already, today, we can see some practical result of this process on the diplomatic level: the growing sympathy for Israel, the promises for raises in aid given by the United States and Germany, and the isolation of the PLO, are only a few examples.

Somebody might ask: maybe there is a justification for an anti-imperialist position, but if the United States will not eliminate Saddam Hussein, we will have to continue suffering from the danger of Iraqi missiles? W Iraqi missiles, to acknowledge the hoever is willing today, because of right of imperialism to make order in the region, will have to accept tomorrow that the United States will turn another regime into a regional power, to "eliminate" a new problem.

Whoever trusts in the United States' friendship with Israel forgets that imperialist interests in the region will dictate who will be a friend and who an enemy, and whether the friend of today will become the enemy of tomorrow. The "common fate" shared by the United States and Israel may — under different relations of power - turn into a danger for the very survival of the Israeli population.

The illusion elimination means the elimination of the missiles is a dangerous one, because of the facts cited above: Saddam Hussein's regime is the fruit of western interest; and the West might in the near future create another Saddam Hussein in the region.

Our region has suffered many wars due to the United States' and her local allies' interests. And the elmination of the Iraqi missiles is not what is going to bring peace and quiet to the region.

The most realistic and most pragmatic solution is the immediate stop of the battles in the Gulf, and the demand for the immediate withdrawal of the allied troops from the regime. These are the minimal preconditions which can justify a halt to the Iraqi missile attacks and prepare the ground for regional negotiations.

Is it necessary to continue the struggle against the occupation Whether peace or war, it is the duty of W the protest movement activists to continue to struggle against occupation. The Israeli national consensus claims that whenever the cannons roar, we have to keep silent. There is no mistake greater than this one. The present Israeli government, just like the preceding one, is using this argument in order to silence any form of struggle for changes in Israeli society, whether concerning the question of occupation and the various questions of democracy, or concerning social To surrender the right to struggle means to surrender to the present government, in all the political questions which are part of the controversy. The government is not waiting for the end of the battles in order to implement its projects concerning the Palestinian question and social questions. In these moments, the government is trying to strangle the Palestinian masses' struggle in the occupied territories by means of a prolonged curfew, aimed at lowering the standard of living to a degree which will make life Socialist Organiser No. 478 page 11 there unbearable. This clearly intentional starvation!

At the same time, the policy of wild incitement against the Arab population continues in order to justify acts of revenge and punishment later on. The arrest of Sari Nusseibeh, under the pretext of espionage in favour of Iraq, is an act which uncovers the intentions of the occupation authorities; according to the state of Israel, all Palestinians are spies of Saddam Hussein, and under conditions of war, any form of punishment and repression of spies is justified.

If the protest movement does not want to take part in these crimes we have to step up the struggle now, without hesitation, and raise the following demands:

• Lift the curfew immediately! policy of starvation!

• Free Sari Nusseibeh and all administrative detainees!

• Stop the incitement against Arab population on both sides of the gre line!

Which steps bring region? W peace in our region can only be le do not want to create illusions. Real achieved on the basis of far-reaching changes:

As long as imperialism governs the region, whether directly or indirectly by means of regimes sharing its projects (Israel and Arab states), the danger of new outburts of conflicts will remain.

The necessary changes will not be brought about by external forces, but by the majority of the masses and the progressive forces in the region. The overthrow of the Iraqi regime must be an act performed by the Iraqi people itself. The exchange of the Israeli government has to be the result of joint efforts of the Israeli and Palestinian people.

The complete disarmament of our region from all non-conventional weapons has to be the first step towards the reduction of the standing troops.

The natural resources of the region have to contribute to the prosperity and welfare of the people living in the region, and not to the profits of imperialist companies, or a few rich families.

And what about our immediate solutions?

Our answers are:

• Stop the battles in the Gulf; immediate withdrawal of the foreign troops from the region;

• For an immediate agreement concerning the disarmament of the region from nonconventional weapons;

• Negotiations between the Arab states on the solution of the Kuwaiti question;

• Immediate Israeli withdrawal from territories occupied in 1967;

• Israeli-Palestinian negotiations for the realisation of the right of the Palestinian reople for self-determination.

Let us not become collaborators in this war for oil, because the price we will have to pay will be heavier than Scud missiles!

Scan page 12

dy Chatterley trial highlights lessons for left about censorship When censors ruled Socialist Organiser No. 478 page 12 Trials of

----- pull-quotes -----

THE POLITICAL FRONT

of the working class for war. Much of this is whipped up by the

Israeli socialists spe ne war,

tres cannot be explained by considerations ERSPEC

destroy the Ira and its leader, stop until this completed."

public attention is focusing question of the Gulf war? N PERSPECTIVE

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 478

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →