The left press and the test of war
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-03-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
Over 100,000 marched on 12 January; but could we have had more, earlier, if the left press had been better? Photo: John Harris he left press proved its value dare G war by being the only voice of opposition to the unanimous pro-war offensive of the official media.
But a Marxist newspaper should do more than just express opposition. It should analyse, put things into context, present facts and arguments which help its readers form an independent understanding of what happens.
And it should be an organiser, helping, for example, to organise the anti-war movement.
Socialist Organiser tried to help clarify and organise antiwar opinion. We argued that the sanctions were a step towards war, not an alternative to it. We said that the quarrel between Iraq and the US over Kuwait was a quarrel between thieves, but the US military build-up aimed far further than Kuwait. It aimed at the crushing of the US's former ally, Saddam Hussein's regime in Iraq.
Support for the peoples of Iran against Iraq in the closIraq against US assault ing stages of the Iran-Iraq should not, however, be confused with credence for Sad- it to start calling the same dam Hussein's regime which was indeed as vile as imperialist. the warmonger press made it out to be. Troops out of the ing just that. "The more US Gulf! Iraq out of Kuwait! we said.
We also debated the issues in the columns of the paper, providing material for readers to make up their own minds.
We argued for and promoted united-front campaigns against the war.
That is the record. How August). does Socialist Worker, the most important of the other left-wing weeklies, compare?
It carried a number of articles explaining quite well it should support. what was wrong with the UN and sanctions. Its attitude to Saddam was all over the place.
At first it seemed to take much the same line as SO.
After all, SW had only recently denounced Saddam campaign. Hussein as a puppet of US imperialism - so much so that it even supported the murderous Islamic regime in For the Pal right 10 a st to sell-determinatio die East with LORRAISER cluding the israei for all nations, in Jewel Two nations, Two states!
Ip postage (or pies for E4, post D BOx 823, LE iE15 4NĄ tion of its support for "anti-imperialist" Saddam. It joinwar — so it would be hard for ed the (pro-sanctions, antiTroops Out) Committee to Saddam regime anti- Stop War in the Gulf without Many word of argument By mid-August it was do- against the Committee's ofFficial line, and echoed the pressure builds up, the more Committee's witch-hunt Saddam will play an anti- against the (pro-Troops Out) imperialist role...In all of this Campaign Against War in the Saddam should have the sup- Gulf. port of socialists...Socialists SW was finally rewarded must hope that Iraq gives the for its political servility with US a bloody nose and that an attempt by the officers of the US is frustrated in its at- the Committee to Stop War tempt to force the Iraqis out in the Gulf to witch-hunt it of Kuwait..." (SW, 18 out of the Committee. Even that provoked no re-think by SW was evidently convinc- SW, no reassertion of SW's ed that Saddam's demagogy own views, nothing, but a represented a powerful anti- bland statement that it was a imperialist movement which pity the Committee's officers were so divisive.
In the same vein of rah-rah In SWs pamphlet on the revolutionary *anti- war, its August line of giving imperialist" posturing, SW credence to Saddam and his started its anti-war agitation "anti-imperialist" role was by calling its own demonstra- re-stated - for form's sake tions, without regard to any - in one subordinate clause attempts to create a united of one sentence, without any supporting argument at all.
Then it turned around. The Marxist task of thinking Without saying it had been things through, worrying out wrong, or formally changing issues, digging deeper than its views, it dropped all men- Journalistic comment and been abandoned antoget had The pro-Saddam line found some practical expres sion, however. When Iraq attacked civilian targets in Israel with Scud missiles, sw did not go as far as cheering it on - though that is certainly the logic of its line that Israel's very right to exist must be denied.
It even carried a critical comment, to the effect that such missile attacks are not really the best way of doing things. But the gist of its coverage was to denounce
LATI
any condemnation of the attacks — first by way of denouncing the mainstream media's real hypocrisy, secondly by saying that Israel deserved no sympathy after what it had done to the Palestinians.
And, on the ground, many SW supporters were gleeful about the bombing of Israel, drawing out the logic of SW's politics on this question.
Here as on Iraq SW showed itself unable to distinguish between the rights of a nation and political attitudes to the leadership or government of that nation. It was unable to support Iraq's rights against US assault without giving credence to Saddam, unable to denounce Israel's governments without declaring the whole Israeli Jewish people fair game for Iraqi attack.
SW tends to argue in terms of "good" anti-imperialist peoples (Palestinians, Iranians, etc) and "bad" pro-imperialist ones (Israeli Jews, etc. The odd thing in the Gulf crisis, which caused it so much embarrassment, was that Iraq had to be transferred from the category of "pro-imperialist" to "anti-imperialist"
What was wrong with SW on the war was not only, and not mainly, its conclusions. It was its way of presenting, or not presenting, its arguments — or its absence of argument.
It did not even make a serious attempt at being what a Marxist newspaper should be, a paper which enlightens its readers, helps them think for themselves, jolts their prejudices, opens their minds to questions they had never thought of before. 10!
----- pull-quotes -----
EYESON THE LEFT
Socialist Worker GULF WAR OUT OF THE GULF